Although Velma’s role in Tracker has taken a bit of a step back in season 2, some moments prove her characterization can still expand if she were to come back for season 3. For instance, in Tracker season 2, episode 5, “Preternatural,” Velma’s mysterious past is slightly unveiled when she urges Colter to take a job involving a missing teenager named Emma, who was raised by her brother after their parents died. This case hit close to home for Velma because, as she explains to Reenie, Velma’s mom was institutionalized when she was twelve, and her sister raised her.
Velma needs to return for Tracker season 3, not only because she works well with Shaw and understands how to operate his missions, but also to further develop her backstory and her sentimental investment in Shaw’s cases. Velma’s challenging childhood made her sympathize with Emma and her brother. The personal connections between the show’s characters and the people they’re searching for are needed to ensure the success of Tracker moving forward. Velma needs to return for Tracker season 3, not only because she works well with Shaw and understands how to operate his missions, but also to further develop her backstory and her sentimental investment in Shaw’s cases.
Let’s get real—Velma’s character in Tracker started out with so much promise. She was mysterious, had a history with Colter, and hinted at something deeper. But now? It feels like she’s running in circles. As Season 3 looms on the horizon, fans are beginning to ask a critical question: where can Velma go from here?
Unfortunately, the honest answer might be nowhere.
The Foundation Was Strong, But the Structure Fell Apart
Velma’s Debut Was Electric
When Velma first entered the Tracker universe, viewers were intrigued. She had grit. She knew things about Colter no one else did. She carried secrets, and she clearly had her own agenda. That combination made her stand out.
The Past Connection with Colter Hooked Viewers
Her complicated history with Colter Shaw added emotional weight to her presence. Was she a friend? A foe? Something in between? It was compelling… for a while.
The Arc That Lost Momentum
No Real Character Growth
As the episodes rolled on, Velma’s story didn’t evolve. She kept showing up with vague information and emotional baggage, but nothing changed. We didn’t learn much new about her, and she didn’t really grow.
Repetitive Role
She became the “handler” trope—popping in with warnings, cryptic messages, or updates from “the higher-ups.” That role got old, fast.
Season 2 Missed Critical Opportunities
Wasted Potential
Instead of digging deeper into Velma’s motivations or relationships, the writers used her mostly as a plot device. Her scenes felt disconnected from the main action.
Minimal Emotional Impact
Unlike other characters who had emotional arcs and turning points, Velma’s scenes lacked punch. There were no standout moments, no gut-wrenching reveals—just static dialogue.
Why Velma’s Arc Is Now at a Standstill
No Clear Direction
Characters need purpose. They need stakes. Velma has neither right now. Without new goals, secrets, or conflicts, her story has nowhere to go.
No Strong Relationships to Develop
Her dynamic with Colter has plateaued. They’re not lovers, not rivals, not even strong allies anymore. It’s lukewarm at best.
What Makes a Character Dynamic and Memorable?
Evolution Over Time
We fall in love with characters who evolve—who fail, adapt, and triumph. Velma hasn’t changed since Season 1.
Stakes and Sacrifices
Memorable characters face hard choices. Velma’s biggest “struggles” happen off-screen or are hinted at vaguely.
Tracker’s Expanding Cast Leaves Velma in the Dust
New Characters Are Outshining Her
Season 2 introduced fresh faces with vibrant backstories and motivations. Compared to them, Velma feels flat and unfinished.
Ensemble Fatigue
With more characters to juggle, screen time is limited. And the time Velma does get feels more like filler than substance.
Could Season 3 Revive Velma? It’s Unlikely.
Too Much Ground to Cover
Tracker Season 3 is expected to dive deeper into Colter’s family and unresolved personal trauma. There’s little room left for Velma’s development.
No Teasers or Setups
There’s been zero narrative setup for a Velma-focused arc. That silence speaks volumes.
