Mark Anderson’s journey on The Golden Bachelorette may have ended when Joan Vassos sent him home, but his romantic prospects may not be over just yet. In fact, I believe Mark’s exit could be a golden opportunity for Theresa Nist, who recently parted ways with Gerry Turner from The Golden Bachelor. Despite their 12-year age difference, Mark and Theresa seem like a better match than either had with their respective show partners. Here’s why these two Bachelor Nation stars should consider dating each other.
Two Separate Journeys, Same Destination
Theresa Nist made her memorable debut on The Golden Bachelor when she charmed Gerry Turner with a playful entrance, pretending to step out of the limo naked, wearing only a skin-colored dress. The two grew closer over the course of the season, and Gerry ultimately gave Theresa his final rose. However, their relationship, and the televised wedding that followed, didn’t last long. After only three months of marriage, they announced their divorce, citing distance as a key factor.
Mark Anderson first entered the Bachelor world when his daughter, Kelsey, brought The Bachelor contestant Joey Graziadei home on season 28. His charismatic presence made him an instant fan favorite. Many expected him to find love on The Golden Bachelorette, but despite a one-on-one date with Joan, their connection didn’t spark. Joan sent Mark home before the hometown dates, leaving him single and back to square one in his search for love.
Shared Experiences: Widowers Finding Love Again
Mark and Theresa have more in common than just their Bachelor franchise connections—they both experienced the loss of long-term spouses. Mark was married to his late wife, Denise, for 18 years before she passed away in 2018 after a brief battle with cancer. They shared five children together, and Mark has been navigating life as a widower ever since.
Similarly, Theresa was married to her childhood sweetheart, William Nist, for 42 years before his death in 2014. She and William had two children and six grandchildren, with another grandchild on the way at the time of his passing. This shared experience of deep love and profound loss could give Theresa and Mark a unique understanding of each other that they didn’t find with Joan or Gerry.
Age Is Just a Number
Though there is a 12-year age gap between Mark, 58, and Theresa, 70, it hardly seems a barrier to their potential compatibility. They’ve both led rich lives, raised children, and are now navigating the world of senior dating. Having gone through similar life stages, including the heartbreak of losing a spouse, they have more in common than most.
On The Golden Bachelor, Theresa’s age wasn’t an issue with Gerry, but their relationship faltered due to other factors, particularly their geographical preferences. While Gerry wanted to stay in Indiana, Theresa wasn’t willing to leave her home in New Jersey. However, with Mark living in Louisiana, which has a much more temperate climate and proximity to lively New Orleans, Theresa might be more open to relocating.
Is the Timing Right for Mark and Theresa?
At the end of The Golden Bachelorette, Mark left the show single after Joan failed to find a romantic connection with him. Theresa also remains unattached following her split from Gerry. Both are now at a point in their lives where they could be open to new possibilities and second chances at love. With their shared life experiences, understanding of loss, and similar values, it’s not hard to imagine that they could find happiness together.
Fans of Bachelor Nation are rooting for both Mark and Theresa to find love, and perhaps the timing is just right for them to give it a try. After all, both are single and searching for meaningful connections. What better time to see if these two stars from The Golden Bachelor and The Golden Bachelorette can write their next chapter together?
