During Tracker season 1, there were hints that Colter and Reenie may end up having a romantic storyline. Their brief romantic entanglement of the past was alluded to in Reenie’s introductory episode, and there was unresolved tension between them moving forward. The traditional will-they/won’t they dynamic carried throughout the season, even though it was clear that Colter wasn’t really in a position to be in a relationship. Still, the lingering question of a romance between Reenie and Colter remained.

At this point in the show, Reenie being with Colter would be settling for less than she deserves, and she’s better than that. Tracker season 2 has squashed that possiblity for now with the introduction of Reenie’s boyfriend, Elliot. And I’m actually great with that decision. Reenie and Colter work much better as friends. They clearly care for one another, but Reenie is a woman who knows exactly what she wants – and more importantly, knows what she deserves. Colter is a hot mess when it comes to his personal life and emotional openness. While he’s a good man and a great tracker, those qualities would make him a terrible boyfriend. At this point in the show, Reenie being with Colter would be settling for less than she deserves, and she’s better than that.

When it comes to complicated relationships, sometimes the best move is to just keep things simple. Reenie and Colter’s story is a perfect example of why some people are better off as friends rather than partners. If you’ve been watching their rollercoaster drama unfold, it’s clear that Reenie deserves a fresh start — without Colter dragging her down. Let’s dive deep into why Reenie & Colter should just remain friends and why she absolutely deserves better than the chaos Colter brings.

Why Keeping It Friendly Is Sometimes the Best Choice

Not every connection is meant to turn romantic. Sometimes, people click perfectly as friends but struggle when trying to become something more. For Reenie and Colter, their friendship has been the foundation, but stepping beyond that boundary has led to nothing but mess.

Friendships are often simpler, more genuine, and less emotionally draining. So why risk a stable bond for a tumultuous relationship?

The Mess Colter Brings to the Table

Let’s be real — Colter has created more drama than harmony. From constant misunderstandings to emotional ups and downs, his actions have caused more headaches than happiness for Reenie.

Emotional Rollercoaster

One minute things are fine, the next they’re in a fight. Colter’s inconsistent behavior keeps Reenie on edge, making it impossible for her to find peace or security in the relationship.

Lack of Accountability

It’s exhausting when one partner doesn’t own their mistakes. Colter tends to deflect blame or avoid serious conversations, leaving Reenie feeling unheard and undervalued.

What Does Reenie Deserve?

Reenie deserves someone who treats her with respect, consistency, and genuine care — not someone who adds stress and confusion. She deserves a partner who lifts her up, not tears her down.

Respect and Trust

Trust is the bedrock of any relationship. Reenie deserves a partner who shows up honestly and respects her boundaries.

Emotional Stability

No one wants a rollercoaster ride of emotions every day. Reenie deserves calm, understanding, and steady support.

The Benefits of Staying Friends

Choosing friendship over romance might seem like settling, but it’s actually a smart and healthy decision.

Preserving the Good

By remaining friends, Reenie and Colter can hold onto the positive parts of their connection without the heartbreak of failed romance.

Space to Grow

Sometimes, time apart and clear boundaries allow both people to grow individually and maybe come back stronger later — or simply move on peacefully.

Signs It’s Time to Walk Away

It’s hard to let go, but sometimes walking away is the healthiest choice. Here are some signs Reenie should consider:

• Constant fighting with no resolution

• Feeling drained or anxious about the relationship

• Lack of mutual effort

• Broken promises and repeated mistakes

Why Friends Make the Best Support System

Even if romance isn’t the answer, friendship still offers a powerful support system. Reenie can count on Colter in ways that don’t involve the emotional messiness of a relationship.

Trust Without Pressure

Friendship allows honesty and trust without the added pressure of romantic expectations.

Shared History and Understanding

They know each other well — that shared history can be the foundation for a lasting, meaningful friendship.

How Reenie Can Move Forward

Moving forward means making peace with the situation and focusing on self-care.

Set Clear Boundaries

Reenie should clearly communicate what she expects from Colter as a friend, avoiding blurred lines.

Focus on Personal Growth

Taking time to focus on her own happiness, goals, and passions will empower Reenie far more than trying to fix a broken relationship.

Colter’s Role in the Future

If Colter truly values Reenie, he’ll respect her wishes to keep things friendly and work on becoming a better person — even if it means not being more than a friend.

Common Misconceptions About Staying Friends

Many people think staying friends after romantic tension is impossible or a sign of failure. But that’s not true. It can be a sign of maturity and respect.

The Emotional Freedom in Friendship

Without the romantic baggage, friendship can offer freedom, joy, and real connection without stress.

Why Toxic Relationships Can Drag You Down

A toxic partner can stunt personal growth and happiness. Reenie deserves freedom from toxicity to thrive.

Lessons We Can Learn from Reenie and Colter’s Story

Sometimes love isn’t enough. Compatibility, respect, and emotional health matter just as much — if not more.

How to Support Friends in Similar Situations

If you know someone like Reenie, encourage them to prioritize their happiness and remind them that walking away doesn’t mean losing — it means choosing peace.

Final Thoughts: Letting Go to Gain More

At the end of the day, Reenie’s decision to remain friends with Colter and nothing more shows strength, clarity, and self-love. She deserves better, and recognizing that is the first step toward a happier, healthier future.

Conclusion

Reenie & Colter’s story is a classic example of why not every relationship needs to be romantic. Sometimes, the healthiest choice is to keep the friendship intact and avoid the mess that comes with trying to force more. Reenie deserves a partner who brings respect, stability, and love — qualities that Colter currently fails to deliver. By choosing friendship, she’s choosing peace, growth, and her own happiness. And honestly, that’s exactly what she deserves.