Stark’s comments show that he understands the role Buck plays in the show, and that his personality and mindset are not conducive to working as captain. It’s not that Buck would not be a good captain; he’s a very experienced and talented first responder. But being in that position is not what he naturally wants to do — at least for now. Buck is the type of firefighter who likes to throw himself into situations and immerse himself in his role, and this would be antithetical to being in a position of seniority, which is more about delegation. Stark’s comments about Buck are entirely correct, and show that the character’s 9-1-1 season 9 evolution might be a little more subtle.
Our Take On Buck Replacing Bobby In 9-1-1
Bobby Is A Big Loss, But Buck Needs To Move On In His Own Way. While it’s clear that Bobby is going to need to be replaced in 9-1-1, Buck is not the right choice for that, and it would feel wrong for his character to make that step. Ultimately, Bobby had one of the most tragic deaths in 9-1-1, and it will take a long time for the 118 to move on from this; Buck needs to do this in his own way.
Buck can move past this by doing what he has always done, and focusing on what brings balance to his life-saving people. There is, of course, the risk of more reckless behavior this time around, which is also a reason why Buck will not make a good captain choice, and he will need to find his own path to peace in 9-1-1 moving forward.
Let’s be real—Evan “Buck” Buckley has grown a lot since Season 1 of 9-1-1. He’s gone from reckless adrenaline junkie to dependable, compassionate firefighter. But as fans speculate whether Buck could take over Captain Bobby Nash’s role in the future, the answer isn’t so black and white. While Buck certainly has the heart and potential, several layers—both story-driven and character-focused—make this promotion feel unlikely. Let’s unpack what’s really going on here.
Buck’s Development Across Seasons: A True Underdog Arc
From Rookie to Reliable First Responder
In the early seasons, Buck was more about proving himself than leading others. His risky behavior often left his team worried rather than inspired. But over time, we’ve watched him mature.
Personal Growth Fueled by Trauma
From his heartbreaking breakup with Abby to the tragic loss of his brother Daniel, Buck’s journey has been full of emotional turbulence. These events shaped him, grounding him in empathy—an essential quality for leadership, no doubt.
His Evolution As a Team Player
Buck used to be impulsive, acting without thinking. But now? He communicates better, supports his team, and thinks about the bigger picture. That said, leadership requires more than just change—it requires consistency.
Captain Bobby Nash’s Shoes Are Hard to Fill
Why Bobby Is the Heart of Station 118
Captain Nash isn’t just a leader—he’s a mentor, a moral compass, and the glue holding the 118 together. His backstory, including his redemption arc after personal tragedy, resonates deeply with both the crew and viewers.
Leadership Isn’t About Heroism Alone
Bobby leads with calmness, experience, and wisdom. Buck, while brave and bold, often reacts emotionally. Replacing Bobby requires strategic thinking and balanced judgment—not just a willingness to run into burning buildings.
Does Buck Even Want the Job?
Buck’s Uncertainty About His Future
In multiple episodes, Buck has expressed doubts about his long-term goals. Remember when he considered leaving firefighting altogether? His identity crisis is still fresh.
The Burden of Command
Leading a firehouse is more paperwork than glory. Buck thrives in action, and administrative responsibility may not fulfill him in the same way.
Narrative Direction: What the Writers Might Be Planning
Setting Up Buck for a Different Role
Writers often subvert fan expectations. Instead of promoting Buck to captain, they might elevate him in other ways—like through personal growth, mentorship roles, or heroic arcs that don’t require a title.
The Emotional Core vs. Structural Shift
Bobby’s possible exit (whenever that may happen) would be a seismic shift. Replacing him with Buck could alienate fans who aren’t ready to see Buck in that light. The writers likely know that.
Fan Reactions: A Divided Fandom
Some Want Buck to Rise
Many fans have been rooting for Buck’s promotion. They’ve seen his potential and believe he deserves a shot.
Others Say It’s Too Soon
Plenty of viewers argue Buck still has growing to do—and that rushing his storyline would weaken its emotional payoff.
Character Dynamics Would Shift Dramatically
Buck and Eddie’s Friendship
A promotion could create imbalance between Buck and Eddie Diaz, whose dynamic thrives on equality and brotherhood. Making Buck captain could strain that.
How the Team Might React
Not everyone would automatically respect Buck’s authority. Chimney, Hen, and others might struggle to adjust to such a major power shift.
Could Buck Be a Future Leader Instead?
Long-Term Potential Is Strong
Give it a few more seasons, and Buck might grow into the role naturally. He just needs more experience and emotional regulation.
Building Toward a Big Payoff
A slower build makes the moment more powerful. Think of it as a delayed reward for fans who’ve watched Buck from day one.
Other Leadership Candidates at Station 118
Hen Wilson
Hen has consistently demonstrated leadership qualities. Logical, compassionate, and respected, she could be a better fit.
Chimney Han
Chim’s been a reliable pillar in the 118. He’s got emotional maturity and experience, even if he prefers flying under the radar.
Buck’s Strength Is His Passion, Not His Position
Every Team Needs a Maverick
Buck brings energy, heart, and intensity to every rescue. He thrives in the field, not behind a desk.
Heroism Isn’t Defined by Rank
In many ways, Buck is already a leader—his bravery and loyalty inspire others, regardless of official titles.
If Bobby Does Step Down—Then What?
Could We See a Transitional Captain?
There’s room for an interim captain—someone like Hen or Chimney could temporarily take the reins, allowing Buck to develop further.
An Emotional Goodbye or Mentorship Moment?
If Bobby exits the show, a proper sendoff with Buck receiving his blessing could be a touching, symbolic moment—even if Buck doesn’t take his place.
What the Future Likely Holds for Buck
Bigger Arcs, Not Bigger Titles
Expect Buck’s emotional and psychological growth to continue. Storylines will likely focus more on his healing, relationships, and self-discovery.
Leadership Without the Badge
He might lead from within the team, taking on mentorship roles or being the emotional anchor in tough times—without being captain.
Conclusion: Buck Isn’t Meant to Replace Bobby—Yet
Let’s not forget—Buck is only just beginning to understand who he really is. While he’s proven himself in fire and crisis, true leadership comes from life experience and wisdom, something Bobby has in spades.
Could Buck be a future captain? Absolutely.
But right now? It feels premature. And maybe that’s okay.
After all, leadership isn’t about rushing to the top—it’s about rising when the time is truly right.
