The idea of Jack cheating on Mel in Virgin River Season 7 feels shocking — but not impossible. Jack Sheridan has always been portrayed as deeply loyal, yet also emotionally guarded. When stress mounts, he often retreats inward, a trait that has previously caused cracks in his relationships. Season 7 may push this weakness further than ever before.
Rather than a physical affair, the show could explore emotional infidelity — confiding in someone else when he should be leaning on Mel. This kind of betrayal would be more in line with Virgin River’s subtle storytelling style, allowing writers to examine how distance can grow even between people who love each other deeply. For Mel, whose past is marked by loss and broken trust, even a small breach could feel devastating. If Season 7 goes down this path, it won’t be about shock value — it will be about whether honesty, accountability, and growth are enough to rebuild what’s been damaged.