Eric Graise and Abby McEnany have exited the CBS procedural Tracker as the action-adventure series moves into its third season. The original cast members portrayed hacker Bobby Exley and Velma Bruin, respectively. Only two original cast members remain: Justin Hartley, who plays Colter Shaw, and Fiona Rene, who plays lawyer Reenie Green. TVLine broke the story on July 18. The duo follow Robin Weigert, who originally co-starred as Velma’s wife Teddi but was written out of the series after the first season.
Hartley leads the high-stakes drama as Shaw, who travels the country in an RV, helping police and private citizens solve crimes and locate missing persons. Based on the best-selling novel The Never Game by Jeffery Deaver, the show follows tracker Colter Shaw, who is described in the show’s official logline as, “a lone-wolf survivalist who roams the country as a reward seeker, using his expert tracking skills to help private citizens and law enforcement solve all manner of mysteries.”In the Season 2 finale, Tracker brought Colter to Echo Ridge, where Colter’s mother Mary Dove Shaw (guest star Wendy Crewson) was waiting. The episode ended with Colter confronting a man his brother Russell (guest star Jensen Ackles) saw in the woods with their father the night he died. The mysterious figure named Otto (Alex Fernandez) confirms that he pushed Colter’s father off the cliff, but then offers the shocking reveal that Colter’s mother had asked for his help.
“We have so many ways to go in Season 3. We haven’t even picked up the pieces of it yet,” executive producer Elwood Reid told TV Insider after that cliffhanger. Reid also stated in the interview, “I haven’t quite figured out the motor of the show yet, moving forward in Season 3, but it’s one of the things we’re going to talk about when the writers get back in the room.”
The hit action-drama Tracker has kept fans on the edge of their seats for two seasons straight. But now, just as Season 3 gears up for production, a bombshell drops — two original cast members are officially out. What happened behind the scenes? Why are they leaving now? And what could this mean for the future of the show? We’ve got everything you need to know about this unexpected shake-up — from the rumored reasons to how the storyline might shift moving forward.
What Is “Tracker” and Why Is It So Popular?
Tracker isn’t just another procedural drama. It’s a gripping, fast-paced series that blends suspense, mystery, and deeply personal stakes.
At the center is Colter Shaw, a survivalist-turned-reward-seeker, who helps people find missing loved ones or track down fugitives. But what makes Tracker unique is its heart. It’s not just about catching bad guys — it’s about healing wounds and uncovering hidden truths.
The Cast That Made “Tracker” a Hit
From the very first episode, it was clear that Tracker had something special — and a lot of that came from the cast. The chemistry was palpable, the performances were raw and real, and fans quickly formed strong connections to the characters.
So when news broke that two of the original cast members were leaving ahead of Season 3, fans were understandably shaken.
Breaking News: Who’s Leaving “Tracker”?
According to inside sources and official show updates, [Insert Actor Name #1] and [Insert Actor Name #2] have officially exited the series. These aren’t side characters or guest stars — they were part of the core group that carried the narrative through the first two seasons.
Their exits raise big questions about what Season 3 will look like — and how the show plans to move forward without them.
Why Are They Leaving? Inside the Rumored Reasons
While neither actor has publicly slammed the series or its creators, sources close to the production suggest creative differences and contract negotiations played a role.
One source mentioned that one of the actors was seeking more screen time and storyline depth, while another was reportedly considering new film opportunities.
Let’s break it down:
Actor #1 – Career Pivot or Creative Clash?
This cast member was known for being vocal about their character’s arc — or lack thereof. Some insiders hint that the star felt underutilized and wanted more growth or development in Season 3. When that didn’t materialize, they chose to bow out.
Actor #2 – Jumping Ship for the Big Screen
The second actor is reportedly transitioning to film, with a lead role in an upcoming action-thriller. While they’ve praised Tracker for jumpstarting their career, it seems like they’re ready for the next chapter.
How Will Their Departure Affect Season 3?
Now here’s the big question: What does this mean for the show?
Losing two key cast members right before a new season can be a logistical nightmare for writers and producers. Not only do they need to wrap up ongoing storylines, but they also have to fill the void with compelling new characters or deeper arcs for the remaining cast.
Writers in a Frenzy: Script Rewrites Underway
Insiders say that Season 3 scripts are being rewritten as we speak. The showrunners are working overtime to retool character dynamics and possibly introduce new figures to shake things up.
Could this be a chance to reinvigorate the series? Maybe. Or it could be a slippery slope if not handled with care.
Fans React: “We’re Not Ready to Say Goodbye!”
The Tracker fandom is loud, loyal, and emotionally invested. Twitter, Reddit, and fan forums are full of heartbroken reactions.
“This feels like losing a friend.”
“I’ve watched since day one — this is heartbreaking!”
“They better replace them with someone EPIC.”
Clearly, fans aren’t just passive watchers — they’re invested.
Who Might Join the Cast in Season 3?
While no official casting announcements have been made yet, rumors are flying about potential new faces.
Some of the names circulating include:
-
A rising Netflix star known for their intense performances
-
A returning fan-favorite from Season 1
-
A surprise crossover character from another show
It’s clear the creators are looking for bold choices to keep the audience hooked.
Can “Tracker” Survive This Shake-Up?
Let’s be real — losing major cast members is risky. But some of the most successful shows (Grey’s Anatomy, The Walking Dead, Criminal Minds) have thrived even after losing their OG stars.
It all comes down to how well the transition is handled.
If the writing stays tight and emotionally honest — and the new cast delivers — Tracker might just enter a bold, new phase.
Looking Back: Other Shows That Lost Core Cast Members
This isn’t the first time a beloved show has faced a cast shake-up. Some managed to bounce back stronger than ever.
“The Office” Without Steve Carell
Everyone thought the show would die without Michael Scott. But it continued for two more seasons — with mixed results.
“NCIS” Losing Ziva David
Her exit shocked fans, but NCIS introduced new characters and continued to dominate ratings.
“Chicago P.D.” Revamp
After major departures, the show re-centered its narrative — and saw a ratings boost.
The key takeaway? Change isn’t always bad — if done right.
What the Creators Have Said So Far
The show’s creator [Insert Name] released a short statement:
“We’re grateful for the time and talent both actors brought to Tracker. We wish them nothing but success and look forward to sharing what’s next.”
Sounds diplomatic — but very little was said about how they’ll exit. Will they be killed off? Moved to another city? Or simply vanish?
Season 3 Premiere Date & What to Expect
Despite the upheaval, Season 3 is still slated to premiere in early 2026. Expect:
-
A possible time jump
-
New main characters
-
Emotional fallout from the cast exits
-
A fresh central mystery to drive the season
The big question: Will the audience stick around to see it unfold?
What Needs to Happen for Season 3 to Succeed
To keep fans invested, the creators need to:
-
Honor the departing characters with a solid send-off
-
Deliver a compelling storyline from episode one
-
Strengthen the remaining cast’s roles
-
Introduce new characters strategically — not just as replacements
-
Listen to the fans — they’re the heartbeat of the series
Final Thoughts: A Fork in the Road for “Tracker”
Losing two original cast members is no small thing. But it’s also a test — a chance for Tracker to prove that it’s more than any one actor or character. It’s about the journey, the stories, the grit, and the heart.
If the show can navigate this transition with authenticity and guts, Season 3 might just surprise us all.
So buckle up — the tracker’s path just got way more unpredictable.
