For 14 seasons, Tom Selleck’s portrayal of Frank Reagan, the steadfast patriarch and New York City Police Commissioner on CBS’s Blue Bloods was the unwavering anchor of Friday night television. The show’s cancellation in 2024, despite its sustained success and loyal audience, sent shockwaves through the industry and left millions of fans heartbroken.
That heartbreak was compounded by the swift announcement and October 2025 premiere of the spin-off, Boston Blue, starring Donnie Wahlberg as Danny Reagan, who has relocated to the Massachusetts capital. With several Blue Bloods alumni already making cameo appearances, the biggest question on every fan’s mind is simple: Will Tom Selleck reprise his iconic role as Frank Reagan and cross over to Boston Blue?
In a series of candid recent interviews, the veteran actor has finally spoken out, providing a definitive, if complicated, answer about his future with the franchise. Selleck’s comments reveal not just his reluctance to immediately return to the character, but also his lingering frustration and disappointment over the cancellation of the original series, which he believes was “taken for granted.”
💔 The Cancellation: A “Huge Disappointment”
Tom Selleck has not minced words regarding his feelings about CBS’s decision to conclude Blue Bloods. The show was a reliable performer, often winning its competitive Friday night time slot and consistently ranking in the top 10 of broadcast television’s most-watched series when sports were excluded.
Taken For Granted
Selleck expressed his deep disappointment, noting that he still doesn’t fully understand the network’s reasoning. He pointed out the show’s sustained popularity over a decade and a half:
“It was a huge disappointment, and I still don’t know why CBS did it… My frustration is the show was always taken for granted because it performed from the get-go.”
This frustration speaks to the difficult financial realities facing long-running network dramas, where increasing production costs (including regular cast salary increases) often outweigh even strong ratings, particularly when a show doesn’t generate massive additional revenue streams like merchandise or syndication deals. For Selleck, however, the sentiment is purely about creative success and connection to his character and cast family.
The Emotional Ending
Selleck highlighted the unique family atmosphere on the Blue Bloods set, noting the cast and crew were as close as the fictional Reagan family, which made the finale even more emotional. The iconic Reagan Family Dinner scene, which was the first and last scene he shot as Frank Reagan, symbolized the powerful emotional closure the cast shared.
🚫 The Boston Blue Question: “That’s Another Show”
The launch of Boston Blue, with Donnie Wahlberg taking his detective character, Danny Reagan, to the Boston Police Department, has provided an immediate continuation of the Blue Bloods universe. Cameos from Bridget Moynahan (Erin Reagan) and Marisa Ramirez (Maria Baez) have already cemented the connection, leaving the door wide open for the family patriarch.
However, when asked about joining the spin-off, Selleck was clear about his current position:
“I don’t know if I would do Boston Blue — that’s another show,” he stated. He added that his focus is ensuring Blue Bloods secures its legacy, not necessarily extending his run as the police commissioner indefinitely.
Why the Hesitation?
Selleck’s reluctance stems from a few key factors:
-
Creative Closure: He believes he has fulfilled his role and is satisfied with the legacy of Frank Reagan. He does not feel it is his “lot in life to keep playing Frank Reagan” simply because a spin-off exists.
-
Focus on New Projects: At 80 years old, Selleck has expressed interest in exploring different genres, specifically mentioning a desire to star in a comedy, referencing his past successes in films like Three Men and a Baby and his recurring role on Friends.
-
Physical Demands: While never confirmed by the actor himself, fan speculation noted his limited physical movement in later seasons of Blue Bloods due to chronic arthritis. The intensity of an ongoing network series, even in a command role, is a major physical commitment he may not be eager to resume.
Wahlberg’s Optimism
Despite Selleck’s hesitation, co-star and Boston Blue executive producer Donnie Wahlberg remains optimistic. Wahlberg confirmed he discussed the new series with Selleck from the beginning and that Selleck is supportive. Wahlberg emphasized that any potential appearance by Frank Reagan would need to be driven by strong, meaningful material.
“Tom’s always going to base his decisions on the work and material, and so yes, of course, I’d love to work with him on the show, and when the time comes, we will hopefully craft an idea that moves his heart and makes him want to do it,” Wahlberg said. The possibility of Danny visiting his father in New York, rather than Frank traveling to Boston, remains a popular and plausible scenario.
🔮 The Future: Beyond the Badge
While the door to Frank Reagan is not bolted shut—Selleck himself noted he “can’t predict the future”—his current comments suggest he is ready for a new chapter.
The Legacy of Frank Reagan
Selleck’s tenure as the police commissioner solidified his status as one of television’s most dependable leading men. The character of Frank Reagan resonated deeply, representing an old-school blend of integrity, moral conflict, and devotion to family. His influence on the character of Danny Reagan is the central premise of Boston Blue, ensuring his presence is felt even if he never physically appears on the new show.
A Move to Comedy?
The most intriguing hint Selleck dropped was his desire to transition to comedy. Having spent nearly two decades in procedural dramas (Blue Bloods and Magnum, P.I.), a change of pace is understandable. A move to a half-hour or limited comedy series would offer a lighter schedule and a refreshing creative challenge for the celebrated actor.
🔑 Conclusion: The Commissioner’s Choice
Tom Selleck’s response to the question of moving to Boston Blue is definitive for the present: He is unlikely to appear in the immediate future.
His focus is not on extending his run as Frank Reagan, but on preserving the legacy of the original Blue Bloods and moving on to new creative endeavors, potentially a comedy project. His ongoing frustration with the original show’s cancellation serves as a powerful reminder of how deeply connected he was to the series and how highly he valued its success.
While fans may not see Frank Reagan cross over to Boston, the spirit of the Reagan family, and the high bar for quality television that Selleck established, will undoubtedly continue to guide Donnie Wahlberg’s new series. For now, the commissioner has earned his rest, but the door for one final family dinner cameo remains tantalizingly ajar.
