NCIS has featured tons of characters over the years, but one particular NCIS character deserved so much better, even 16 years after their death. NCIS is known for its dramatic plotlines and character endings. The show has been on the air for over 20 years and has even recently celebrated its 1000th NCIS episode. Given its long run-time, and myriad character exits, some characters are bound to have more tragic endings than others. Even so, there’s one major player who deserved so much better.
Over the past two decades, NCIS has created intense season finales to write characters off the show. Given its dramatic and police procedural nature, it makes sense to move characters around to keep the show exciting. However, some characters receive more upsetting endings than others. NCIS featured a particularly tragic ending to one of its characters in season 5, 16 years prior to the upcoming NCIS season 22. After all this time, her ending still rankles.
Jenny Shepard Was An Underrated NCIS Character
Jenny’s Appearances Were Small But Long-Lasting
Jenny Shepard, played by Lauren Holly, was the NCIS director from season 3 to season 5. She acquired this post after Thomas Morrow’s resignation following Caitlin Todd’s death in the NCIS season 2 finale. While Jenny was only the director for three seasons, her effect on the show has been long-lasting. For one thing, she was the first and only female director of NCIS and her relationship with Gibbs went a long way into revealing his character and personality.
Jenny was an ambitious and highly skilled NCIS agent, which gave her the drive she needed to be successful. Her obsession with catching Ren Benoit for his alleged involvement in the murder of her father also added to her intrigue and made her an impressive character. Her obsessive nature was largely a result of Jenny being driven by grief and revenge following her father’s death, and it gave her character a slight edge that separated her from the other NCIS team members. These qualities made Jenny a great NCIS character which is why her death still hurts, 16 years on.
Jenny’s Story Ended Abruptly
Jenny’s Impulsiveness Led To Her Demise
Jenny was a great director but her time on NCIS was cut short when she was killed in a shootout in the season 5 finale, “Judgment Day Part 1.” Season 4 of NCIS set up Jenny’s death by showing the extent of her obsession with Ren, and it was that fixation with catching him that eventually led to her death. While pursuing Ren, Jenny was assigned to kill the fianc of a Russian arms dealer in an undercover operation. Her failure to complete her mission and be honest with her teammates is what eventually killed her in 2008.
However, even without her violent death, Jenny would still have left the show in another way. Season 5 revealed that Jenny was sick, but it was not until Ducky was about to begin Jenny’s autopsy in season 5 that he revealed to Gibbs that she had been diagnosed with a debilitating terminal illness. Jenny’s exit from the show would have been abrupt either way. She is one of the many NCIS characters who left the show, but in a way, her death was on her own terms.
After Jenny was diagnosed, she seemed to have gotten more impulsive, putting the safety of her teammates at risk.
But Jenny did not need a terminal illness in the first place. She could have been written out of the show through a career change from the stress of the job. She also could have left having achieved satisfaction that Ren was dead. After Jenny was diagnosed, she seemed to have gotten more impulsive, putting the safety of her teammates at risk. She deserved a better ending because she had worked so hard to get to where she was and to have it taken from her so quickly was disappointing.
Jenny Could Come Back In NCIS: Origins
The Prequel Is Jenny’s Only Hope
Even though Jenny died 16 years ago, she could appear in the new NCIS prequel, NCIS: Origins, which will take place during the beginning of NCIS’ Jethro Gibbs’ career. NCIS has already established Jenny as both an NCIS special agent and Gibb’s former partner, so it would make sense for her to appear. It would also be exciting to see how Jenny and Gibbs’ relationship started, since most of it happened off-screen and before NCIS.
Jenny is one of the many dead NCIS characters who could appear in NCIS: Origins. Her past with Gibbs gives her even more potential to appear, since her pursuit to catch Ren overlapped with her time with Gibbs. Jenny’s story in NCIS: Origins would likely focus on their time together in the undercover operation in Paris regarding the Russian arms dealer and his fiance. Since Jenny died 16 years ago, her only hope to reappear in the NCIS franchise is through the prequel.
What Lauren Holly Has Done Since NCIS
Holly Has Continued Working In Movies And Television
Lauren Holly had a long career in Hollywood before becoming Jenny Shepard in NCIS, including memorable parts in movies like Dumb and Dumber, Beautiful Girls, and Turbulence. Not surprisingly, after leaving NCIS, she continued to get big roles in movies and television with her career still going strong more than a decade after leaving the hit series.
The former NCIS actress starred in the Netflix series Tiny Pretty Things in 2020 and has also had guest-starring roles on a number of series, from Lucifer to Designated Survivor to Alphas. Holly also began working more frequently in Canadian television, taking roles in the police procedure Motive as well as the legal drama Family Law. She also appeared in the horror film The Blackcoat’s Daughter. Holly will next be seen in the Netflix holiday comedy Hot Frosty, starring Lacey Chabert, Craig Robinson, and Dustin Milligan.
NCIS (Naval Criminal Investigative Service) focuses on the sometimes complex and always amusing dynamics of a team forced to work together in high-stress situations. Special Agent Alden Parker, a quirky former FBI agent who solves his cases with calm professionalism and sharp, sarcastic charm, leads the NCIS team, which includes NCIS Special Agent Timothy McGee, an MIT graduate with a knack for computers who has now graduated to senior field agent; the charismatic, unpredictable and resilient NCIS Special Agent Nicholas Nick Torres, who has spent most of his career on solo undercover assignments; and sharp, athletic and tough NCIS Special Agent Jessica Knight, a formidable REACT agent who specializes in hostage negotiations and high-risk operations. The nave Jimmy Palmer is assisting the team, who graduated from assistant to fully licensed medical examiner and now runs the morgue; and forensic scientist Kasie Hines, Duckys former graduate assistant. Overseeing operations is NCIS Director Leon Vance, an intelligent, highly trained agent who can always be counted on to shake up the status quo. From murder and espionage to terrorism and stolen submarines, these special agents investigate all crimes with Navy or Marine Corps ties.
Cast Rocky Carroll, Joe Spano, Brian Dietzen, Katrina Law, Sean Murray, Wilmer Valderrama, Mark Harmon, Gary Cole, David McCallum
