After seven seasons, The Rookie has built a rich world with a wide range of fascinating characters. However, some of them left the show too soon, leaving fans longing for their return. Here are five characters from the past who deserve another chance to come back to the series.
1. Talia Bishop
Talia Bishop (Afton Williamson) was John Nolan’s very first training officer back in season 1. Tough, ambitious, and uncompromising, she embodied the strength of a female police officer striving for success. Her sudden exit left a major gap in the show. Bringing Bishop back could reignite the formative dynamics of Nolan’s early journey.
2. Ben McRee
Ben (Currie Graham), Nolan’s lifelong friend, offered a rare glimpse into the personal side of the character. He reminded viewers that Nolan wasn’t just a cop — he was a man with roots and relationships outside the LAPD. His return could restore that sense of balance between Nolan’s professional and private life.
3. Grace Sawyer
Grace (Ali Larter) — the doctor and Nolan’s former flame — brought romance and conflict to the series. Their unfinished love story left fans wanting more. If Grace were to come back, it could shake up Nolan’s pursuit of stability and add a new layer of emotional tension.
4. Aaron Thorsen
Aaron (Tru Valentino) joined the team later on but quickly won viewers over with his troubled past and his determination to redeem himself. His sudden absence at the end of season 6 left plenty of unanswered questions. A return for Aaron would give the show an opportunity to explore his growth and resilience after personal struggles.
5. Ellroy Basso
Ellroy (Alan Tudyk), the quirky crime scene cleanup expert, was a minor character but a fan favorite. His eccentric humor lightened up the otherwise tense storylines, making him unforgettable. A comeback for Ellroy would bring back that perfect balance of drama and comedy the show does so well.
Conclusion
The Rookie has done a great job of refreshing its stories with new characters, but revisiting old favorites could create a powerful blend of nostalgia and fresh storytelling. Talia, Ben, Grace, Aaron, and Ellroy aren’t just part of the past — their return could be the key to shaping the show’s future in exciting new ways.
