TVLine can exclusively confirm that Eric Graise and Abby McEnany have departed CBS’ Tracker. That leaves the procedural with just two series regulars heading into Season 3: Justin Harley (aka Colter Shaw) and Fiona Rene (who plays legal eagle Reenie Green). Graise, who co-starred as master hacker Bobby Exley, and McEnany, who played Velma Bruin, were original cast members – but seldom, if ever, shared scenes with Hartley, whose alter ego really takes the whole “lone wolf” thing to heart.
Fellow original cast member Robin Weigert, who co-starred as Velma’s wife Teddi, was written out after Season 1. Tracker, based on the best-selling novel The Never Game by Jeffery Deaver, stars This Is Us vet Hartley as the aforementioned Colter Shaw, “a lone-wolf survivalist who roams the country as a reward seeker, using his expert tracking skills to help private citizens and law enforcement solve all manner of mysteries,” according to the official logline.
What’s Going On With Tracker?
If you’ve been glued to Tracker, the hit CBS drama following Colter Shaw’s high-stakes, on-the-run investigations, then this news might hit hard. Ahead of its third season, the series is undergoing a surprising cast shake-up. Two series regulars are officially out. Yep, you read that right.
Fans are buzzing, social media is in meltdown mode, and the show’s future dynamics are officially up in the air. But what really happened? And what does it mean for Season 3? Let’s break it all down.
Who’s Leaving Tracker?
Two Familiar Faces Say Goodbye
Sources close to production have confirmed that Florence Shaw (played by Fiona Rene) and Reenie Greene (played by Abby McEnany) will not return as series regulars in Season 3. While there’s still a chance they could make a guest appearance or two, they won’t be in the driver’s seat anymore.
Florence Shaw — The Sister With Secrets
Florence, Colter’s sister, has been a complex and emotional anchor in his life. Her storyline offered glimpses into Colter’s troubled past and motivations. Losing her as a regular means major changes in the emotional tone of the show.
Reenie Greene — The Unlikely Ally
Reenie, a quirky but sharp source of support, added levity and local expertise to Colter’s journeys. Her disappearance leaves a noticeable gap in the show’s offbeat charm.
Why Did They Leave the Series?
Creative Direction Shift
Insiders say the decision came from the top. The producers are aiming to “tighten the narrative focus” on Colter’s solo missions. Translation? Less ensemble, more lone-wolf action.
Budget and Logistics Could Play a Role
TV productions are expensive. Cutting down on regulars often comes down to money. With Tracker’s growing popularity and likely bigger set pieces in Season 3, the budget may have needed reallocating.
Could It Be a Strategic Story Move?
Sometimes, stepping away from certain characters lets others shine. It also builds suspense — could Florence or Reenie return later when we least expect it?
What This Means for Season 3
More Focus on Colter’s Journey
The upcoming season seems poised to go deeper into Colter Shaw’s psyche. With fewer distractions from side plots, expect more intense tracking, confrontations, and those classic moral dilemmas that make him such a compelling character.
New Characters May Fill the Void
Every exit is also an entrance. Rumors hint at fresh faces joining the cast — potentially allies or foes that could shake up Colter’s worldview.
Fan Reactions: Heartbreak, Theories & Hope
The Fandom Is Divided
Twitter/X, Reddit, and fan forums exploded after the news broke. Some are devastated, calling it the “beginning of the end.” Others are intrigued, hoping it means tighter writing and grittier storytelling.
Theories Are Already Flying
-
“Florence is killed off — calling it now.”
-
“Reenie will return in a finale twist.”
-
“What if both join Colter later undercover?”
Fans aren’t just reacting; they’re plotting.
Behind the Scenes: Cast and Crew Speak Out
Fiona Rene and Abby McEnany Respond
Both actors posted heartfelt messages on social media. Fiona Rene wrote, “This character, this journey, changed me. Thank you for letting Florence into your homes.” Abby added, “Reenie may be off the trail… for now. Never say never.”
Showrunner Comments Offer Hints
Executive producer Ben Winters teased in an interview:
“Tracker Season 3 will be unlike anything we’ve done before. It’s leaner, riskier, and pushes Colter further than ever.”
What Could Happen Next? Plot Predictions
Colter Goes Rogue — And Deeper Into Danger
With fewer people to lean on, Colter might spiral or become more reckless. Season 3 could show a darker, more vulnerable side.
A New Nemesis Emerges
New characters often bring new threats. Could this be the season where Colter faces a long-running antagonist?
A Return from the Shadows?
Don’t count Florence or Reenie out. A dramatic return could be just the twist that turns the season finale into a jaw-dropper.
Why This Twist Might Actually Save the Series
Sometimes a show needs to evolve to survive. By narrowing its scope, Tracker has a chance to level up. With fewer distractions, the storytelling could become more emotionally potent, tightly paced, and binge-worthy.
What Fans Can Do Now
Rewatch & Reinvest
Catch up on Seasons 1 and 2. Rewatching Florence and Reenie’s scenes might reveal clues about their exits — or potential returns.
Stay Active Online
Use hashtags like #TrackerCBS #SaveFlorence #BringBackReenie. TV producers pay attention when fan movements go viral.
Final Thoughts: Change Can Be a Good Thing
Let’s be real — no one loves cast shake-ups. But they often push a series to dig deeper, aim higher, and surprise the audience. With two key players stepping away, Season 3 of Tracker has the chance to redefine itself — and possibly become its best season yet.
