As the longest-running series in the One Chicago franchise, Chicago Fire has built a reputation for delivering high-stakes drama, character-driven storytelling, and the occasional dose of humor. While its ability to balance the emotional weight of Chicago Med and the gritty action of Chicago P.D. has been a hallmark, not every episode lands perfectly. Some rise above as prime examples of the show’s strength, while others fall flat, weighed down by uneven plots or underwhelming character arcs.
With Season 13 halfway through, IMDb ratings reveal the highs and lows so far, highlighting what fans loved most—and least—about the current season.
The Best: “Through the Skin” (8.1 IMDb Rating)
Topping the IMDb ratings for Season 13 is the standout episode “Through the Skin,” which earned an impressive 8.1 rating. The episode focuses on Violet Mikami (Hanako Greensmith) as she makes a high-stakes decision that risks her career. When faced with a dilemma during a medical emergency, Violet prioritizes what she feels is morally right over strict adherence to the rules, sparking thought-provoking questions about ethics and responsibility.
The tension of Violet’s storyline is balanced perfectly with a lighter subplot. Joe Cruz (Joe Minoso) enlists Mouch (Christian Stolte), Capp (Randy Flagler), and Tony (Anthony Ferraris) to recover his son’s stolen bike. This comedic side quest injects humor and heart into the episode, offering viewers a much-needed breather from the intensity of Violet’s challenges. Together, the elements create a well-rounded hour of television that showcases Chicago Fire at its best.
The Worst: “Birds of Prey” (7.5 IMDb Rating)
On the opposite end of the spectrum is “Birds of Prey,” which IMDb users rated the lowest of the season at 7.5. While that’s still a respectable score, it’s a noticeable dip compared to the series’ usual standard.
The episode initially seems promising as it centers on Severide (Taylor Kinney) investigating an arson case at a storage unit filled with hidden firearms. While Severide’s detective-mode storylines are typically engaging, this one fails to deliver, feeling formulaic and predictable.
What ultimately drags the episode down is its lack of balance. Severide’s solo investigation leaves the rest of the Firehouse 51 crew with little to do, resulting in a disjointed narrative. Even Sam Carver (Jake Lockett), a character known for his compelling screen presence, is relegated to a lackluster subplot that feels like an afterthought.
What Makes a Chicago Fire Episode Shine?
The stark contrast between these two episodes highlights what fans love most about Chicago Fire: balance. The show excels when it weaves together dramatic, action-packed storylines with moments of levity and camaraderie among the Firehouse 51 crew. Episodes like “Through the Skin” demonstrate how a strong, character-driven arc paired with lighthearted subplots can create a satisfying viewing experience.
In contrast, episodes like “Birds of Prey” falter when they fail to utilize the ensemble cast effectively. Chicago Fire thrives on its team dynamic, and when key players are sidelined, the show loses much of its charm.
What’s Next for Chicago Fire Season 13?
With half the season still to go, there’s plenty of time for more memorable moments—and perhaps a few more missteps. Fans eagerly await what’s in store for their favorite characters and hope for episodes that strike the perfect balance of drama, humor, and heart.
What has been your favorite episode of the season so far? And your least favorite? Let us know as Chicago Fire continues to blaze forward!
