The Andy Griffith Show Stars Picked Their Favorite Episodes of the Series
Few TV shows have left as big of an impact as The Andy Griffith Show. Running from 1960 to 1968, this beloved sitcom captured the heartwarming charm of small-town life in Mayberry, with unforgettable characters like Sheriff Andy Taylor, his goofy deputy Barney Fife, and lovable Aunt Bee.
Over the years, fans have argued over which episodes are the best, but what did the show’s stars think? The cast members themselves had their own favorites—some of which might surprise you! Let’s take a deep dive into which episodes they loved most and why.
Andy Griffith’s Favorite Episode – A Classic That Defines Mayberry
Andy Loved “Barney’s First Car” (Season 3, Episode 27)
Andy Griffith, the show’s star, played the calm and wise Sheriff Andy Taylor. He once said that his favorite episode was “Barney’s First Car.”
In this hilarious installment, Barney Fife gets swindled into buying a broken-down lemon of a car from a sweet old lady. The entire episode is packed with Don Knotts’ brilliant physical comedy, and Andy Griffith loved how it perfectly showcased Barney’s gullibility.
Why Andy Chose This Episode
- It highlighted Don Knotts’ unmatched comedic talent.
- It had one of the show’s most iconic slapstick scenes.
- The storyline was simple yet hilarious.
Don Knotts’ Pick – A Barney Fife Masterpiece
Don Knotts Loved “The Pickle Story” (Season 2, Episode 11)
Don Knotts, who played the legendary Deputy Barney Fife, had many iconic moments on the show. But his personal favorite episode? “The Pickle Story.”
In this fan-favorite episode, Aunt Bee makes a batch of homemade pickles that taste absolutely terrible. Barney, Andy, and Opie try to switch them out with store-bought pickles to spare her feelings—but chaos ensues.
Why Don Knotts Loved This Episode
- The comedic timing was perfect.
- It was one of the funniest episodes in the entire series.
- Aunt Bee’s terrible pickles became an unforgettable running gag.
Ron Howard’s Favorite Childhood Moment on the Show
Ron Howard Picked “Opie the Birdman” (Season 4, Episode 1)
Ron Howard, who played Andy’s son Opie, grew up on the show. His favorite episode? “Opie the Birdman.”
This emotional episode follows Opie as he accidentally kills a mother bird with his slingshot. Filled with guilt, he takes care of the orphaned baby birds. The episode teaches a touching lesson about responsibility and empathy.
Why This Episode Was Special to Ron Howard
- It had a strong moral lesson.
- The emotional depth made it stand out.
- It was one of Opie’s biggest character growth moments.
Frances Bavier’s Favorite Aunt Bee Episode
Frances Bavier Chose “Aunt Bee’s Medicine Man” (Season 6, Episode 23)
Frances Bavier, who played Aunt Bee, had many memorable moments in Mayberry. One of her favorite episodes was “Aunt Bee’s Medicine Man.”
In this episode, Aunt Bee gets tricked into buying a phony health tonic that makes her act completely out of character. Seeing the normally composed Aunt Bee under the influence of the “magic elixir” had Frances Bavier in stitches!
Why Frances Loved This Episode
- It allowed Aunt Bee to break free from her usual role.
- The humor was unexpected and fun.
- The storyline was a refreshing change of pace.
Jim Nabors (Gomer Pyle) and His Favorite Mayberry Moment
Jim Nabors Loved “Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C.” (Season 4, Episode 32)
Jim Nabors, who played the lovable, goofy gas station attendant Gomer Pyle, got his own spin-off series. But his favorite episode from The Andy Griffith Show was “Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C.”
In this episode, Gomer enlists in the Marines, setting up the premise for his spin-off show. It was a bittersweet farewell to Mayberry, and Jim Nabors considered it one of his proudest moments.
Why Jim Nabors Loved This Episode
- It launched his own successful TV series.
- It gave Gomer a heartfelt and respectful sendoff.
- The episode was both funny and emotional.
Why These Episodes Still Resonate Today
Even decades later, The Andy Griffith Show remains a staple of classic television. The episodes chosen by the cast highlight everything that made the show special—timeless humor, heartfelt lessons, and unforgettable characters.
Whether it’s Barney Fife’s wild antics, Opie’s coming-of-age moments, or Aunt Bee’s motherly wisdom, the show’s magic still holds up today. If you’re looking for a place to start rewatching, these episodes are a great place to begin!
Conclusion
The Andy Griffith Show left an undeniable mark on television history, and its stars had their own personal favorites that perfectly encapsulated the show’s charm. From Andy Griffith’s love for “Barney’s First Car” to Don Knotts’ comedic gold in “The Pickle Story,” these episodes remain timeless classics.
No matter how many years pass, Mayberry’s simple and heartwarming world continues to capture new generations of fans. If you haven’t already, give these episodes a rewatch—you might just find a new favorite yourself!
FAQs
1. What is the most-watched episode of The Andy Griffith Show?
One of the highest-rated episodes was “Barney’s First Car”, which is also Andy Griffith’s favorite episode!
2. Did Andy Griffith and Don Knotts remain friends after the show?
Yes! Andy Griffith and Don Knotts had a lifelong friendship that lasted until Knotts’ passing in 2006.
3. Why did The Andy Griffith Show end?
The show ended after eight seasons because Andy Griffith wanted to explore other projects and felt the time was right to move on.
4. Did Ron Howard enjoy being on The Andy Griffith Show?
Yes! Ron Howard has always spoken fondly of his time on the show and credits it with shaping his career in Hollywood.
5. Where can I watch The Andy Griffith Show today?
You can watch The Andy Griffith Show on streaming platforms like Amazon Prime, Pluto TV, and MeTV, or purchase the DVD collections.
If you’re a longtime fan or a newcomer to Mayberry, these episodes are the perfect way to experience The Andy Griffith Show at its finest. Which episode is your favorite? Let us know in the comments! 😊
