CBS’ missing persons drama Tracker just got a bit smaller.
As reported by Deadline’s sister site, TVLine, yesterday, the Justin Hartley vehicle saw the departures of series regulars Eric Graise (computer expert Bobby Exley) and Abby McEnany (business handler Velma Bruin), leaving Hartley’s one-man-operation Colter Shaw and Fiona Rene’s lawyer Reenie Green as the sole stars going into Season 3. (Fellow original cast member Robin Weigert, who portrayed Velma’s wife Teddi Bruin, as well as the backend of Colter’s operation, left the series after Season 1.) Based on the bestselling novel The Never Game by Jeffery Deaver, Tracker stars Hartley as Colter Shaw, “a lone-wolf survivalist who roams the country as a reward seeker, using his expert tracking skills to help private citizens and law enforcement solve all manner of mysteries while contending with his own fractured family,” per the official logline.
The series has been a major draw for the network, landing in the Top 5 of Nielsen’s 35-day most-watched shows across all streaming and linear series, alongside fellow standout Matlock, back in May. Per CBS data, the show is also No. 1 in broadcast. Tracker was renewed by CBS alongside other drama and ratings mainstays Elsbeth, Fire Country and its three NCIS series back in February. In the dramatic conclusion to Season 2, Colter finally uncovered the mystery man behind his father’s killer, but not without unfolding a series of questions, including his mother’s involvement in the death. The drama is produced by 20th Television, with Deaver producing alongside EPs Hartley, Ken Olin, Elwood Reid, Connie Dolphin, Sharon Lee Watson and Alex Katsnelson.
A Sudden Shift for ‘Tracker’ Fans
Just when you thought Tracker was hitting its stride, CBS throws a curveball. Ahead of Season 3, two series regulars—Eric Graise and Abby McEnany—are officially out. For a show that’s just beginning to cement its place in primetime, this sudden cast shuffle has fans scratching their heads and asking: What happened? Let’s dive deep into what this means for the show’s future, why the actors are leaving, and how this impacts the heart and soul of Tracker.
The Big News: Two Fan Favorites Exit ‘Tracker’
Eric Graise and Abby McEnany Leave Series Regular Roles
The exits of Eric Graise (Bob Exley) and Abby McEnany (Velma) ahead of Season 3 came as a shock to many fans. These weren’t just side characters—they were part of the emotional fabric of the show. While neither actor has spoken publicly yet, the news confirms that both will not be returning as regulars next season.
Who Are Eric Graise and Abby McEnany on ‘Tracker’?
Eric Graise as Bob Exley – A Beloved Tech-Sidekick
Graise brought charm, wit, and humanity to Bob—a disabled tech wizard who brought both brains and heart to Colter’s missions. His representation of a disabled character with agency was both powerful and long overdue in network TV.
Abby McEnany as Velma – Quirky and Grounded
McEnany’s Velma balanced the action with humor and a sense of grounded realism. As Colter’s logistical guru, she often added levity to high-stakes moments. Her character gave the audience breathing space amid the show’s intensity.
Why Are They Leaving? Let’s Break It Down
Creative Direction Shifts in Season 3
Word from inside sources suggests Tracker is moving in a “new creative direction.” That often means leaning into different character dynamics, plots, and themes. This shift could explain why Graise and McEnany were let go or chose to exit.
Contractual and Industry Factors
In the world of TV, many exits boil down to contracts. Whether it’s budget restructuring or behind-the-scenes negotiations, there’s often more to the story than what fans see on screen.
Is It Permanent? Or Could They Return?
While they won’t be regulars, sources suggest both actors could return in guest spots. That’s some comfort for fans hoping this isn’t a permanent goodbye.
What This Means for ‘Tracker’ Season 3
Colter Ford’s World Just Got Smaller
Justin Hartley’s Colter Ford depends on a tight-knit team. Removing Bob and Velma from the equation leaves a big hole. The emotional and tactical support they brought will be missed—and fans will definitely feel it.
A Chance to Introduce New Characters
On the flip side, their departure opens the door for new faces. Could CBS be planning to bring in high-profile guest stars or even permanent replacements with big star power?
A Risky Move or a Necessary One?
Let’s face it: shaking up a cast is always risky. But sometimes, it’s necessary to keep the story fresh. Will it pay off for Tracker? Only time (and ratings) will tell.
Fan Reaction: Social Media Is Buzzing
Mixed Feelings from the Tracker Fandom
Fans took to social media almost instantly, with reactions ranging from disappointment to outrage. One fan tweeted: “Tracker won’t be the same without Bob and Velma. CBS, what are you doing?”
Petition Launched to Bring Them Back
Yep, it didn’t take long. A Change.org petition is already gaining traction, demanding CBS reconsider the decision. Fan power, after all, has reversed TV decisions before (remember Brooklyn Nine-Nine?).
Looking at the Bigger Picture: TV Trends
The Rise of Short-Term Characters
More shows are cycling through cast members to keep stories dynamic. This isn’t just a Tracker thing—it’s a growing trend in network and streaming dramas alike.
Representation Still Matters
Graise, a disabled actor, and McEnany, a non-binary performer, brought much-needed diversity to mainstream TV. Their exits highlight an ongoing challenge: keeping diverse voices on screen long-term.
What’s Next for the Actors?
Eric Graise: A Star on the Rise
From Step Up: High Water to Locke & Key, Graise is already well-established and in demand. Industry insiders expect him to book major roles soon—perhaps even a lead on a streaming series.
Abby McEnany’s Next Chapter
McEnany, already known for Showtime’s Work in Progress, has a distinct comedic voice. Her return to the indie comedy scene could be just around the corner.
How the Writing Team Might Handle Their Exit
Off-Screen Explanation or On-Screen Farewell?
Will they vanish with a quick line of dialogue? Or get a full sendoff in Episode 1? Fans are hoping for proper closure—especially after two seasons of emotional investment.
A Tragic Twist or Peaceful Departure?
Some speculate that the writers might give Bob and Velma dramatic exits—possibly involving danger or sacrifice. Others expect a more peaceful explanation, like a job change or moving away.
Potential New Cast Members: Who Could Fill the Void?
Room for Fresh Talent or Big Names?
CBS might use this opportunity to bring in younger talent or boost ratings with big names. Think of what NCIS or FBI does when revamping teams—Tracker could follow suit.
Diversity in Casting Moving Forward
Given the loss of two diverse characters, the showrunners will likely face pressure to maintain or improve representation going forward.
Conclusion: A Turning Point for ‘Tracker’
The departures of Eric Graise and Abby McEnany mark a bold turning point for Tracker. Whether it’s a stumble or a strategic leap, it’s clear Season 3 will look and feel different. While fans are understandably disappointed, this could be the spark that reinvents the series—if done right. Let’s hope CBS balances risk with respect, honoring the characters while evolving the story.
