In a stunning turn of events, CBS has officially renewed Boston Blue for a Season 2, a move that has dominated headlines and sent shockwaves through the Blue Bloods fan community. Despite Boston Blue’s mixed reception, the spin-off starring Donnie Wahlberg as Danny Reagan continues to draw strong viewership — enough to secure its place in CBS’s 2026–27 lineup.
While many are celebrating a deeper dive into the Reagan universe, the reaction online is anything but uniform. Fans are torn between excitement and frustration, and some of the most heated debates focus on:
1. The Show’s Renewal Despite Mixed Reviews
Some viewers are stunned that Boston Blue was renewed even though early episodes received lukewarm feedback from critics and audiences alike. Recent discussion threads point out complaints about predictable plotting, lackluster dialogue, and comparisons to its predecessor Blue Bloods.
2. The Ongoing Maria Baez Dilemma
One of the juiciest topics right now is the uncertain status of Maria Baez, Danny’s former partner. According to Reddit discussions, Donnie Wahlberg himself teased that Baez will return in upcoming episodes, but the situation is “not resolved” yet — fueling wild speculation about a possible rekindled romance or major emotional blowup.
Fans are debating whether this storyline is a clever tease that will pay off later — or simply drawn out writing that feels inconsistent.
3. Casting and Continuity Criticism
Controversy from earlier seasons hasn’t gone away. The recasting of Sean Reagan — with Mika Amonsen replacing Andrew Terraciano — still draws fire from some corners of the fandom. Meanwhile, production decisions like filming in Toronto rather than actual Boston continue to get attention and even ridicule from viewers who feel the setting lacks authenticity.
4. Danny and Lena’s Partnership Reaction
Not all responses are negative. A vocal group of fans online has praised the evolving dynamic between Danny Reagan and Detective Lena Silver (Sonequa Martin-Green), noting that their chemistry and unique partnership have become one of the strongest parts of the series so far.
This clash — between viewers who hate the changes and those who see fresh promise — has turned Boston Blue into one of the most divisive TV dramas of the moment. Whether that controversy ultimately helps the show evolve or further divides its audience remains to be seen.
So the burning question fans are asking right now is:
Does Season 2 of Boston Blue finally have what it takes to win over critics and audiences alike… or will fans keep calling it “Blue Bloods 2.0” without heart?
Only time — and the next season — will tell.