Netflix’s annual holiday takeover has reached full throttle, and My Secret Santa has emerged as one of the season’s most unexpected success stories. The Christmas rom-com, led by Virgin River star Alexandra Breckenridge and New Amsterdam alum Ryan Eggold, has climbed to No. 1 on Netflix’s U.S. streaming charts, edging out both animated sequels and prestige dramas.
The film centers on a single mother who disguises herself as a man to secure a Santa gig at an upscale ski resort, setting off a series of romantic and comedic complications. While audiences appear to be embracing the premise, critics remain less enthusiastic. Collider’s official review labeled the movie “forgettable,” suggesting it lacks the broad appeal needed to truly stand out in the crowded holiday lineup.
Still, chart dominance tells a different story. With families settling in for seasonal streaming, visibility and timing may matter more than critical acclaim. The movie’s success underscores Netflix’s continued ability to turn modest holiday releases into viral hits.
Rounding out the current top ten are Troll 2, Jay Kelly, Cast Away, and the enduringly popular Cheaper by the Dozen franchise — proof that familiarity and festive vibes remain king in December.
