Once NCIS held a five-year streak as the most-watched scripted show on TV. Season 21 saw multiple lows: famously low ratings, key character departures, and noticeably fading narrative freshness Reddit+15TV Insider+15Screen Rant+15IMDb+2Reddit+2Wikipedia+2Screen Rant. Despite still promising numbers, fans on Reddit commented:
“I stopped watching when Gibbs left. He WAS NCIS.”
“It started when Tony left… really fell off when Gibbs left.” Reddit+1Reddit+1
The sentiment is clear: without original characters, *NCIS feels like a different show—less compelling, less authentic.
📉 CBS Still Believes—But They’re Worried
CBS remains cautious. Though NCIS averages around 9.6–10.6 million viewers in multiplatform totals, it was dethroned by Tracker as most-watched scripted drama Next TVTheWrap. CBS did renew the flagship for Season 23, anchored by its enduring loyal base. However, executives canceled NCIS: Hawai’i due to underperformance despite fan outcryReddit+15The Sun+15The Sun+15.
Collectors: That slot shift to Tuesday, making room for a full NCIS night, shows CBS investing deeper—but even that hinges on strong performance from the original show and its spinoffs Screen RantGood Housekeeping.
🚨 The Potential Fix: Bringing Back Original NCIS in Some Form
H2: Why Revival is Not Just Nostalgia—but Necessity
The NCIS universe has expanded: Origins, Sydney, Tony & Ziva streaming—crowding a franchise that once felt lean and powerful. Some argue this oversaturation might dilute brand equity unless the core remains strongew.com+3MovieWeb+3Cinemablend+3.
Reviving JAG or another original series could re-ground storytelling and re-energize the franchise. JAG set the tone for Gibbs, and fans still talk about wanting closure or crossover with those roots Cinemablend+1ew.com+1.
H3: Original Characters Still Resonate
Longtime experts like Gibbs and Tony defined the emotional soul of NCIS. Reintroducing even memory or flashback arcs—or bringing back characters like JAG’s Harmon Rabb—could tap into deep fan attachment and raise creative stakes.
H3: Boost Ratings and Credibility
Season 21 of NCIS marked its smallest same-day audience ever. A revival with original leads or a reboot could potentially reverse that trend. Origins is doing well on streaming, but CBS theater still needs the original show’s ratings to anchor Tuesday night block effectively CinemablendTV Insider+1Screen Rant+1.
🧭 What Kind of Revival Could Work
H4: A Full Return of NCIS with Gibbs Involved
Mark Harmon’s Gibbs left physical form but still narrated NCIS: Origins. An on‑screen return—even limited—could mend the emotional gap in the fandom and restore confidence in storytelling integrity.
H4: A JAG Revival or Reunion
Given NCIS originated from JAG, bringing back character Harmon Rabb (David James Elliott) or referencing episodes with Catherine Bell’s Mac could reinforce franchise continuity. Fans and the actor are open to itMovieWebCinemablend+1ew.com+1.
H4: Supercrossovers Across NCIS-Series
Using crossovers where original NCIS characters anchor arcs within Origins, Sydney, or upcoming Tony & Ziva could revitalize interest without full revival but still deliver emotional payoff.
📣 Fan Sentiment: Resurrection or Regression?
Reddit fans express strong divide:
“If he acts like Season 4 DiNozzo, I’m out.”
“It fell off in Season 13 when Tony left.” WikipediaReddit
Others remain loyal but critical:
“I still enjoy the show… but it genuinely feels like a different show.” Reddit+1Reddit+1
This suggests fans aren’t against evolution—they want authenticity. A revival that honors original tone and characters could recapture that.
📊 Summary Table
| Area | Challenge | Revival Potential |
|---|---|---|
| Ratings | Hit all‑time low, dethroned by Tracker | Star-power draw of original characters could boost viewership |
| Storytelling | Loss of original core = weaker emotional stakes | Roots revival reinforces narrative depth |
| Franchise Saturation | Too many spinoffs watering down focus | Original returns refocus universe |
| Fan Engagement | Nostalgia fatigue without substance | Structured revival gives meaningful payoffs |
✅ Final Take
CBS’s NCIS franchise isn’t dead—but it’s limping. With fatigue setting in and ratings slipping, reviving or re-centering on original characters (Gibbs, Tony, even JAG leads) could reignite emotional investment and narrative direction.
A smart revival—not just nostalgic callbacks, but integrated storytelling—could steer NCIS back from overflow to optimal.
🙋 5 Unique FAQs
Q1: Is CBS planning a full reboot today?
A: No official reboot has been announced—but JAG revival chatter and Mark Harmon’s ongoing producer involvement suggest potential narrative reconnections.
Q2: Could Gibbs return on-screen in NCIS?
A: There’s no confirmed return—though fans hope Harmon’s voice or cameo might tie into future arcs.
Q3: Is NCIS ratings slide permanent?
A: While viewership dropped, multiplatform totals remain strong. Ratings aren’t catastrophic—but renewal momentum hinges on reversal in Season 23.
Q4: Can spin-offs like Origins save the franchise alone?
A: Streaming spin-offs succeed on Paramount+ but network primetime still relies heavily on the flagship show’s performance.
Q5: Would reviving JAG help NCIS tonally?
A: Yes—JAG defined NCIS’s core ethos. A reboot or crossover could restore emotional roots and strengthen continuity.
Custom Message:
Thanks for reading! Want more deep dives into the NCISverse, its ratings, spin-offs, and next big move? Share this with fellow fans and keep the conversation going.
