🍞
If Jack’s Bar feels like the heart of Virgin River, then Preacher’s grilled cheese and tomato soup might just be its most comforting signature dish. Now, fans can recreate the cozy favorite at home thanks to Netflix’s official recipe — the same one served at Netflix House locations in Philadelphia and Dallas.
The meal even carries emotional meaning in the Season 7 finale, when Jack and Preacher reflect on how the menu helped transform the bar into a welcoming space for the entire community.
Tomato Soup Highlights
Start by sautéing diced onion, carrot, and garlic in olive oil until softened. Add basil along with canned tomatoes and roasted Roma tomatoes, then simmer for 30–45 minutes until tender. Blend the mixture until smooth before stirring in heavy cream, chili flakes, salt, and pepper for a rich finish. Garnish with olive oil before serving.
Grilled Cheese Highlights
Spread garlic aioli on rustic sourdough bread and layer American cheese with shredded fontina, sharp cheddar, and butterkäse. Grill the sandwich until golden brown on both sides and fully melted inside. Serve with soup — and optional pickles — for the full Jack’s Bar experience.
Even Alexandra Breckenridge gave the dish her approval after trying it at Netflix House, calling it simply “delicious.”