While it would probably be better if Moss and Colter remained allies, the truth is that this could go the opposite direction as well. In an April 2025 interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Justin Hartley noted that he wants to see Colter Shaw on the run from the government. “It would be interesting, I think, to see him be set up,” the Tracker star explained. “In other words, to see him using all those skills to run from the authorities, because you’ve been set up for whatever reason.” Perhaps a great way to do that would be to bring in Moss as a recurring character who is on Colter’s trail. As someone who knows and understands Colter and his desire to help others, there could be some interesting conflict within him between his loyalty to the FBI and his view of Colter. That kind of episode (or arc, if we want to extend it even further) practically writes itself.
No matter what direction Tracker Season 3 goes, we cannot wait for more adventures with Colter Shaw. Hopefully, the show will be granted more than just 20 episodes, but no matter how many we get, the possibilities are endless. After a successful second season that introduced a plethora of new and engaging characters to pull from, it would be a mistake for Tracker not to bring back Special Agent Moss going forward, especially as the dark truth about the Shaw family begins to come to light.
TV thrillers thrive on tension—and Tracker, the CBS hit starring Justin Hartley, is cooking up something juicy. But here’s the kicker: what if Agent Teddi Bruin Moss, played by Robin Weigert, isn’t quite the ally we thought? According to Hartley, a twist may be coming, and it could turn Moss into the perfect foil for Colter Shaw. Sounds wild? Let’s unpack this theory.
Who Is Agent Moss? A Quick Recap
The Authority Figure With a Mysterious Edge
Agent Moss is a federal agent with a straight-laced, no-nonsense approach to justice. She appears as someone who plays by the book—but let’s be real, in a world full of secrets, that usually means there’s more to the story.
Why Fans Are Obsessed With Her Character Arc
It’s the unpredictability. Moss comes off as neutral—helpful, maybe even supportive—but fans can’t shake the feeling that she’s hiding something. Could that something be her true intentions?
Who Is Colter Shaw, and Why Is He Always Running Into Trouble?
The Lone Tracker With a Knack for Trouble
Colter Shaw, played brilliantly by Justin Hartley, is a survivalist bounty hunter who tracks down people for cash. But don’t mistake him for your average vigilante—he’s got a personal code and a messy past that haunts his every move.
A Character Who Needs Conflict to Evolve
Let’s be honest, characters like Shaw thrive on tension. Internal struggles? Check. Murky ethics? Double check. Add a complex foil like Agent Moss, and boom—you’ve got fire.
Why Justin Hartley Wants Moss as a Foil
It’s All About Story Depth
In a recent interview, Hartley hinted that Moss could evolve into more than just a background player. He sees her as a potential antagonist—not a villain, but someone whose goals clash hard with Shaw’s. That’s storytelling gold.
Think Batman vs. Gordon—But With More Shade
Imagine if Jim Gordon suddenly had a hidden agenda. That’s the energy Hartley wants to channel between Shaw and Moss. Tension. Mistrust. Unpredictable alliances.
How TV Shows Thrive on Twists Like This
The Power of the Unexpected Ally Turned Adversary
Think of shows like Breaking Bad or Homeland. The best arcs? When trusted characters flip. It keeps viewers glued to the screen—and keeps social media buzzing.
Agent Moss Could Be the ‘Loki’ of Tracker
Not evil. Not good. Just complicated. And those are the characters that make shows unforgettable.
Psychological Warfare: A New Type of Conflict
Moving Beyond Physical Threats
Sure, Shaw faces danger all the time. But imagine a conflict that messes with his mind—legal battles, moral dilemmas, and trust issues. That’s next-level storytelling.
The Mental Game Could Elevate the Show
It’s not just about chasing bad guys anymore. It’s about questioning who’s really wearing the white hat.
The Perfect Setup: Seeds Are Already Planted
Clues Hidden in Season 1
Sharp-eyed fans have spotted subtle moments where Moss’s motives seem… questionable. Is she watching Shaw a little too closely? Is she letting some people off too easy?
Room for Expansion in Season 2
If the writers run with Hartley’s idea, Season 2 could see Moss using her influence to slow Shaw down—or manipulate him. That’s juicy TV.
Foils Make Protagonists Better
What Is a Foil in Storytelling?
A foil is a character who contrasts with the protagonist, highlighting their traits and flaws. Think Sherlock and Moriarty—or even Mulder and Scully before they synced up.
How Moss Could Amplify Shaw’s Journey
Shaw’s trauma and instincts make him unpredictable. Moss’s rigidity could force him to either grow—or fall apart.
Fans Are Already Buzzing About This Twist
Reddit Threads and Twitter Theories Are Heating Up
From “Moss is too clean” to “She’s a plant,” fans are all over this theory. And Hartley’s comments are just fueling the fire.
Engagement Could Skyrocket With This Twist
Let’s face it, social media lives for plot twists. A Moss heel-turn could turn Tracker into appointment TV.
What Makes a Great Foil Pairing on TV?
Contrast, Chemistry, and Clashing Ideals
Moss and Shaw couldn’t be more different—and that’s what makes it work. They challenge each other in ways that spark tension and, yes, curiosity.
Room for Redemption or Ruin
The best part? A foil doesn’t have to stay an enemy. There’s room for redemption—or a total breakdown. That’s drama.
The Legal Angle: Could Moss Use the System Against Shaw?
Weaponizing the Rulebook
While Shaw operates in the gray, Moss is all about order. What if she starts using the system to block his investigations—or expose his methods?
A Game of Chess, Not Checkers
Imagine two players—one emotional, one methodical. Every move is strategic. That’s the kind of slow-burn tension that builds real suspense.
Backstory Matters: Could Moss Have a Personal Vendetta?
A Past Connection to Shaw’s Family?
Some fans speculate that Moss may know more about Shaw’s past than she lets on. If that’s true, her actions could be personal—not just professional.
Revenge Disguised as Duty?
Now that’s a twist. What if Moss’s motivations are tangled in revenge or guilt? Suddenly, she’s not a villain—she’s a tragic character.
How the Show Could Drop Hints Without Giving It All Away
Layered Dialogue and Subtle Actions
Writers could plant little moments—long glances, questions with double meanings, or unexplained absences—that slowly build suspicion.
The Best Payoffs Come From Slow-Burn Arcs
This isn’t a twist you drop in one episode. This is a simmering subplot that erupts mid-season and shakes everything up.
Casting Choices and Acting Nuance
Robin Weigert’s Performance Can Carry It
Weigert brings gravitas, subtlety, and range—everything you need for a slow-burn character turn. Hartley knows that, and it’s part of why he wants this arc.
Nuance Wins in Long-Form Storytelling
TV isn’t a sprint—it’s a marathon. And Moss’s arc, if done right, could be one of the most talked-about turns in prime-time drama.
Conclusion: Will Agent Moss Become Colter Shaw’s Foil?
Nothing is confirmed. But if Justin Hartley gets his way, Tracker could be headed for a bold and brilliant narrative shift. A once-ally turning into a calculated opponent? That’s how you level up a show. Moss vs. Shaw could be the rivalry that defines the series, creating the kind of dynamic that keeps fans coming back week after week.
