When Tracker first hit screens, Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw immediately captivated audiences as the rugged survivalist who turned his unique skill set into a business of saving others. But with the premiere of Season 3 just weeks away, hints from both the trailer and behind-the-scenes chatter suggest that Colter may not be the same man fans thought they knew.
From Lone Wolf to Something Else
Colter Shaw has always been a complex figure—a drifter who lives by his own rules, guided by both justice and profit. Yet the tone of the new season points to a more morally gray path. In the trailer, we see him making choices that seem less about helping others and more about vengeance, self-preservation, or something darker.
“Colter is evolving,” Justin Hartley teased in a recent interview. “He’s still the tracker, but the world is changing around him. And when the world changes, so do your choices.”
The Shadow of Family Trauma
One of the most defining aspects of Colter’s backstory is his troubled family past—particularly the tension and tragedy surrounding his father. Season 3 seems ready to dig deeper into those scars. Quick cuts in the trailer reveal Colter staring at old photographs, haunted by memories he can’t outrun.
“The past isn’t done with him,” a showrunner hinted. “Season 3 is about what happens when you can’t just keep running.”
More Ruthless Than Ever?
What worries fans is Colter’s increasingly ruthless edge. In one striking trailer moment, he’s shown pressing a gun to a man’s chest, whispering something cold before walking away. For a character who’s always tried to stand on the right side of the line, the scene suggests he might be closer than ever to crossing it.
Is this still the Colter Shaw fans rooted for—or is the show preparing to challenge the audience’s loyalty to its hero?
Justin Hartley’s Transformation
For Hartley, playing Colter in this new phase has been both thrilling and daunting. Known for his charisma on This Is Us, Hartley has leaned into the grit, bringing a hardened intensity that’s drawing critical buzz even before the premiere.
“This is Justin Hartley like we’ve never seen him before,” one critic wrote after the trailer dropped. “Colter isn’t just a TV hero anymore—he’s on the verge of becoming a tragic antihero.”
The Fan Divide
Already, forums are lighting up with debate.
-
“Colter going darker? Yes please. Give me morally gray tracker all day.”
-
“Nope. If he loses his moral compass, he loses me.”
-
“The whole point is his struggle. That’s what makes this so compelling.”
A Season That Redefines the Show
What’s clear is that Tracker Season 3 isn’t playing it safe. By reshaping its central character, the show risks alienating some fans while electrifying others. But that may be exactly the point.
Television history is filled with iconic heroes who turned darker, from Walter White to Dexter Morgan. Could Colter Shaw be next on that list?
As the premiere approaches, one question towers above all: Will Colter still be the hero fans fell in love with—or is Tracker about to rewrite its own rules?
