After more than a decade on air and twelve seasons deep, Chicago P.D. remains one of NBC’s most recognizable procedural dramas. But a question many fans continue to ask is simple — is it still as good as it was in the early seasons?
For some viewers, the raw intensity of the first few seasons set an almost impossible standard. Early Chicago P.D. was darker, grittier, and less restrained, with morally complex storylines that pushed boundaries. Characters like Voight, Erin Lindsay, and the original Intelligence Unit felt unpredictable, and that edge became a defining trait of the show.
As the series evolved, so did its tone. Later seasons shifted toward a more character-driven approach, focusing on emotional fallout, trauma, and long-term consequences rather than constant shock value. For many fans, this growth has been a strength — allowing characters like Burgess, Atwater, and Upton to develop deeper, more layered arcs.
Of course, not everyone agrees. Some longtime viewers feel that the show has softened over time, especially compared to its earlier, more controversial storytelling. This criticism mirrors reactions seen with other long-running franchises, such as Law & Order, where newer versions sometimes struggle to satisfy fans who fell in love with the originals.
Yet Chicago P.D. continues to maintain a loyal fanbase. Unlike some procedurals that feel repetitive after many seasons, the series has shown a willingness to adapt, refresh its cast, and tackle contemporary issues without completely abandoning its core identity. The tension between justice and morality — a hallmark of the show — remains very much alive.
So, is Chicago P.D. still “as good as it used to be”? The answer largely depends on what viewers loved about the show in the first place. If the appeal was relentless darkness and shock, the early seasons may still reign supreme. But for fans who value character growth and emotional depth, Chicago P.D. may be stronger and more mature than ever.
One thing is certain: twelve seasons in, Chicago P.D. is still sparking debate — and that alone is a sign that the show hasn’t lost its relevance.