Now, some may think that Colter Shaw’s (Justin Hartley) career as a full-time rewardist is a bit out there, and admittedly, there may be some truth to that. But we’ve already calculated how much Colter makes each season, and it actually seems quite doable. It’s only when Reenie gets involved that I struggle to believe her role in his adventures. Sure, perhaps if he only worked in a single state or two (or even three) it would make sense, but Colter works all over the country, and Reenie is constantly bailing him out of jail or giving him some sort of helping hand (despite the fact that the very first episode, “Klamath Falls,” clearly establishes that Colter has other lawyers he could call). Considering that every state has a bar exam that lawyers would need to submit to, it hardly seems feasible for Reenie to pay the fees associated with practicing law in each of these states. Even with her own practice, it feels like too big a stretch.
Of course, she may be applying for reciprocity in different states, which, if granted, means that you can practice law in another state in which you did not take the bar. That’s certainly a possibility in certain cases, namely in the states surrounding wherever Reenie has put down her roots. However, reciprocal agreements can be tricky, because not every state offers them — and those that do only allow agreements in certain states. This means that it would likely be impossible for Reenie to be Colter’s on-call lawyer (or for her to represent some of his clients or their loved ones) in each of his individual adventures. But there is one other possibility…
If you’ve been watching Tracker, you’ve probably raised an eyebrow more than once at Reenie’s impressive legal reach. Whether the team is in Arizona, Texas, or somewhere in the snowy peaks of Montana, Reenie always seems ready to drop legal bombs — contracts, subpoenas, court orders, you name it.
But how is that even possible? Let’s dive deep into Reenie’s jet-setting, justice-slinging lifestyle and figure out how she pulls it off — or if it’s just TV magic wrapped in legal jargon.
Who Is Reenie on ‘Tracker’?
A Quick Character Breakdown
Reenie Green is Colter Shaw’s lawyer and confidante. She’s sharp, resourceful, and doesn’t back down from a legal challenge — no matter where the case takes them. Reenie isn’t just a side character; she’s the team’s legal lifeline.
The Role She Plays in Each Episode
Every time Colter gets entangled in another dangerous case, Reenie is just a phone call away. Need a warrant challenged? She’s on it. Need someone bailed out in another state? She makes it happen.
But… how?
Can a Lawyer Really Practice Law Everywhere in the U.S.?
Understanding Legal Jurisdiction
Here’s the thing: Lawyers are licensed state by state. So unless Reenie holds licenses in every single U.S. state — which is super rare — she shouldn’t be able to practice law everywhere.
The Multistate Practice Myth
Some legal fans argue that Reenie might have multistate bar memberships or work under a special provision. But legally speaking, that’s a long shot.
What the Show Tracker Might Be Bending
TV Logic vs. Legal Reality
Let’s be real — TV shows often take creative liberties. Tracker likely bends reality for the sake of fast pacing and character involvement. Reenie’s legal involvement is probably exaggerated to keep her close to the action.
Is It Possible She’s Offering “Legal Advice,” Not “Practicing”?
Some viewers suggest that Reenie may simply be offering informal legal advice rather than officially representing clients in court — which would be more legally plausible.
States Where She Could Legally Assist Remotely
Reciprocity Agreements Between States
Certain states have bar reciprocity, meaning lawyers licensed in one state can practice in another without taking a new bar exam. If Reenie is licensed in one of those states, it could explain some of her flexibility.
Pro Hac Vice – Temporary Admission
Lawyers can sometimes appear in courts outside their home state pro hac vice — with permission for a specific case. Maybe Reenie files for this when needed (though the show never explains it).
Technology and Remote Legal Practice
The Rise of the Virtual Lawyer
Thanks to Zoom courtrooms and online filings, many lawyers can now handle aspects of cases remotely. Reenie could be using modern tools to bridge the gap between states.
But Remote Doesn’t Mean Universal
Even if she’s helping virtually, the legal documents and filings she references still require licensing — which brings us back to the legal gray zone.
The Possibility of a Federal Law License
Practicing in Federal Court
Lawyers licensed to practice in federal court aren’t limited by state boundaries. If Reenie mostly deals with federal legal matters, that could be her golden ticket.
But Most of Colter’s Cases Are Local
Here’s the rub: Colter’s cases are typically rooted in state issues — missing persons, local crimes, custody battles — not federal matters.
Could Reenie Work Behind the Scenes with Local Counsel?
Partnering with In-State Attorneys
In real life, out-of-state lawyers team up with local counsel to handle jurisdiction-specific tasks. Maybe Reenie does this behind the scenes — and the show skips the details for dramatic effect.
The Real Reason Viewers Don’t Care
Suspension of Disbelief Is Key
At the end of the day, audiences love Reenie’s character and her unwavering support for Colter. Whether she’s “technically” allowed to practice law or not is usually overlooked in favor of keeping the narrative moving.
Why Reenie’s Role Still Works on TV
She’s a Plot Device That Delivers
Reenie is the glue that holds the legal side of Colter’s cases together. Her intelligence, wit, and fast thinking keep the storyline flowing — and give viewers a much-needed break from the physical chase scenes.
A Fan Favorite With Brains and Backbone
Reenie’s confidence and no-nonsense attitude have made her a fan favorite. She’s the rare character who brings a dose of reality and sass to each episode.
What Legal Professionals Think
Mixed Reactions From Real Lawyers
Some legal professionals love her character but roll their eyes at how she navigates the legal system. Others appreciate the representation of a strong, smart female attorney — even if it’s not 100% realistic.
Could Reenie Be Based on a Real Type of Lawyer?
Legal Consultants and Fixers
In the real world, there are legal fixers and consultants who travel and help clients across the country — but even they don’t practice law in every state.
Reenie Might Be Loosely Modeled After Them
She’s likely a blend of real-world inspiration and narrative convenience — and that’s what makes her so compelling.
The Bottom Line on Reenie’s Legal Reach
She’s Not Meant to Be 100% Accurate
Reenie is a functional character, not a law school case study. Her purpose is to solve problems and push the story forward, not teach us about state licensing laws.
Conclusion: Reenie’s Legal Magic on ‘Tracker’
So, how does Reenie practice law everywhere on Tracker? The answer lies somewhere between fiction and function. She’s not constrained by real-world legal borders because she doesn’t need to be. Her role is to be present, powerful, and pivotal — and she nails it every time. While her actions might not stand up to a real-life bar review, they absolutely deliver in the world of television storytelling. And honestly? We wouldn’t have her any other way.
