Chicago Fire fans were still reeling from the recent departure of Jesse Spencer, who played Fire Captain Matthew Casey, when a touching scene from Season 10, Episode 6, aired on October 27. Casey’s exit had shocked viewers, especially those invested in his romance with Paramedic-in-Charge Sylvie Brett (Kara Killmer). Known as the “Brettsey” relationship, Casey and Brett’s love story had finally blossomed after seasons of build-up, and their parting left many fans heartbroken. In Episode 200, titled Two Hundred, Casey made the choice to move to Oregon, leaving Brett and his Chicago family behind.
The story, however, didn’t end there. In the following episode, Dead Zone, Brett receives an unexpected voicemail from Casey, delivering a deeply emotional moment for both Brett and fans. It’s a simple yet powerful scene that struck a chord with viewers, who took to social media to share their reactions.
The Voicemail That Broke Chicago Fire Fans’ Hearts
The scene opens with Brett in the locker room, casually checking her phone. She discovers a voicemail from Casey, and as she listens, the words he says leave her visibly moved. Casey begins by saying, “Sylvie, I hate that we keep missing each other. … Maybe we should make a call schedule, when we’re both free. We’ll figure it out.” He then softly says, “I love you,” words that Brett — and the audience — were waiting for. Her eyes close as she takes in his message, reflecting the complex mix of love and heartache the voicemail stirs.
Fans were quick to react, with one user, @Learnthingss, sharing a clip of the scene, captioned, “I-…….he said ‘I love you,'” followed by teary and broken-heart emojis. Another fan, @Joannee_tw, tweeted, “Okay, why does this need to hurt me?! I’m spending my day off relaxing at a beach and I do not want to cry in public.” The reactions continued to pour in, with fans posting GIFs and emojis of people sobbing, capturing the emotional impact of the scene.
A Bittersweet Farewell … For Now?
Not all reactions were joyful; some fans felt the “I love you” came too late. One user, @freshface81, tweeted, “He should have said I love you last week in the rain.” Others echoed the sentiment, with user @Margab282 responding, “If Chicago Fire was a show that pampers its fans, we would have had it. But it is not.” Though the timing of Casey’s declaration was bittersweet, it gave fans a sense of closure — even as it left the door open for a possible reunion in the future.
While fans may have felt the pang of loss, the voicemail served as a poignant reminder of the bond between Casey and Brett. For now, Brett appears to be moving forward, but with Chicago Fire, there’s always a possibility that their paths will cross again.
