Since its premiere in 2012, Dick Wolf’s action-drama Chicago Fire has captivated millions of viewers with its intense and seemingly authentic portrayal of the first responders at Firehouse 51. As the flagship show in Wolf’s One Chicago franchise, which also includes Chicago P.D. and Chicago Med, the series consistently delivers impressive ratings, solidifying its status as a prime-time favorite.
While Chicago Fire aims to depict the high-stakes lives of firefighters and paramedics, a closer examination reveals some elements that stretch the bounds of realism. A subtle yet significant detail regarding a critical piece of firefighting equipment has raised eyebrows among seasoned firefighters, leading to discussions about the show’s authenticity.
The Issue with the Breathing Apparatus
When firefighters enter a burning building, one of their essential tools is the Self Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA). According to MyFireFighterNation.com, the Scott Air-Pack is a popular choice among real-life firefighters, and it appears to be the model used in Chicago Fire. However, several veteran firefighters have pointed out some glaring inaccuracies in how the SCBA is depicted on the show.
In a discussion on the Firehouse.com Firefighters Forum titled “TV Show Chicago Fire,” users expressed their concerns about the show’s portrayal of the Scott Air-Pack. One commenter, FyredUp, noted, “So what is with the funky face pieces on the Scott masks? Those are NOT standard facepieces. The regulator does not lay flat like that at the bottom of the mask… Is this a new mask I haven’t seen yet or something custom made for the show so you can see the actor’s face?” Another user, Chenzo, echoed this sentiment, questioning the design of the SCBA equipment.
While one forum member, FWDbuff, attempted to provide a more forgiving perspective, stating, “…understand that it is a TV show made for entertainment purposes by Hollywood studio-types,” it highlights a broader issue: the desire for authenticity in shows that purport to represent real-life heroes.
Balancing Realism and Entertainment
Chicago Fire is ultimately a drama, and the producers are likely prioritizing narrative flow and character visibility over strict adherence to firefighting protocols. Nonetheless, for audiences familiar with the intricacies of firefighting equipment, these oversights can be distracting.
Firefighting is an inherently dangerous profession, and the gear used is designed to protect lives. Authenticity in the portrayal of such equipment can enhance the viewer’s connection to the show and its characters. While Chicago Fire excels in storytelling and character development, these subtle inaccuracies remind viewers that it is, after all, a work of fiction.
As the series continues to captivate audiences with thrilling storylines and intense drama, it’s essential for fans to acknowledge the balance between creative storytelling and the realistic representation of the challenging lives of first responders.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while Chicago Fire remains one of the standout shows in the One Chicago franchise, the subtle detail regarding the SCBA equipment underscores the challenge of maintaining realism in a drama series. As viewers continue to tune in for the adrenaline-fueled action and emotional depth, it’s a reminder that even the smallest details can impact the show’s authenticity in the eyes of those who know the realities of firefighting.
