Chicago Fire has always thrived on its mix of high-stakes rescues and deep character bonds. But as Season 13 approaches, many longtime viewers feel the series is losing its way. Cast shake-ups and questionable storylines have fans wondering if Firehouse 51 has drifted too far from what made it a hit in the first place.
Carver and Ritter’s Exits Hit Hard
The recent decision to write out Sam Carver and Darren Ritter has drawn sharp criticism. Both characters were considered fan favorites, bringing energy, heart, and depth to the team. Their exits follow a painful pattern: Otis, Kylie, Gallo, Casey, and Sylvie were all written out in recent years, leaving some fans feeling like the firehouse family has been gutted.
Novak Under Fire
Not every character has won over the audience. Paramedic Novak is being slammed as “window dressing,” with fans calling her storylines weak and her presence unnecessary. Harsh criticism has even been directed at the actress’s performance, with some suggesting Novak should be the next to go.
Violet’s Credibility Questioned
Violet Mikami, once a fan-favorite, is also under scrutiny. Viewers argue her constant string of love interests has made her character “unbelievable.” Many hoped her romance with Carver would finally ground her, but his departure has left fans convinced she’ll simply move on again—just as she did after losing Hawkins.
Pascal vs. Boden: Leadership Void
The arrival of Chief Dom Pascal has not filled the shoes of beloved former Chief Boden. Fans describe Pascal as “a round peg in a square hole,” lacking the tough love and loyalty that Boden brought to the role. Instead, Pascal is seen as distant and awkward, leaving Firehouse 51 with a leadership vacuum.
Severide Alone at the Top
Kelly Severide remains the undeniable rock star of the series, but without Casey or another strong alpha presence, fans argue the show leans too heavily on him. The lack of balance risks turning Severide into a lone anchor rather than part of a dynamic leadership duo.
Cruz and Stella Draw Criticism
Even longtime characters are under fire. Cruz and his wife have been labeled “drama queens,” while Stella’s constant anxiety over Severide has sparked frustration. Viewers joke that he can’t disappear for two minutes without her spiraling, reducing a once-strong character to repetitive worry.
Is Chicago Fire Losing Its Spark?
The overall fan sentiment is clear: Chicago Fire is drifting away from the grit, loyalty, and firehouse camaraderie that defined its golden years. By sidelining beloved characters and focusing on weaker arcs, the series risks alienating its loyal audience.
Fans want the show to return to its roots — with bold leadership, authentic relationships, and the raw intensity of saving lives. Without that, Firehouse 51 may be burning out.
