In a stunning twist that has sent shockwaves through the entertainment industry, a leaked internal memo—allegedly circulating among CBS executives—has described Tracker, the network’s hit drama led by Justin Hartley, as “the worst show ever produced in CBS history.” The memo, whose authenticity remains unconfirmed, exploded across social media overnight, sparking chaos among fans, cast members, and TV insiders who can’t believe the network would use such brutally dismissive language toward one of its own flagship series.
According to a source who claims to have seen the memo firsthand, the document outlines a string of “creative failures,” “inconsistent vision,” and “overall disappointing execution,” blaming the show for what it calls “a brand identity crisis” at CBS. The wording is harsh, unprecedented, and completely at odds with the show’s strong ratings — which only deepens the mystery behind the network’s internal frustration.
But the biggest shock?
The memo reportedly singles out Justin Hartley himself, suggesting that his portrayal of Colter Shaw “lacks emotional depth” and calling his performance “a mismatch for CBS’s premium drama lineup.” The source insists that Hartley’s name appeared multiple times in what they described as an “unusually personal” critique.
Unsurprisingly, Hartley is said to be furious.
Another insider close to the actor claims he was blindsided by the leak and felt “deeply insulted” by what he believes to be an unfair and exaggerated attack on the cast and crew’s work. Hartley has allegedly demanded immediate clarification from CBS executives and is “not ruling out” the possibility of a formal response if the memo proves authentic.
Fans are equally enraged.
Within hours, hashtags like #RespectTracker, #JusticeForHartley, and #CBSApologize were trending worldwide, with viewers calling the memo “disgraceful,” “unprofessional,” and “clearly written by someone who hasn’t watched the show.” Many pointed out that Tracker is one of CBS’s strongest-performing new dramas, making the memo’s brutal wording even more baffling.
Even more dramatic are the rumors swirling around what caused the memo in the first place. Some believe a powerful executive—reportedly unhappy with the direction of Season 3—may have used the internal document as a way to pressure the creative team. Others insist that the memo is part of a much bigger internal conflict at CBS involving budgets, scheduling battles, and strategic disagreements.
So far, CBS has remained completely silent, refusing to comment on the memo, the leak, or Justin Hartley’s alleged reaction. The lack of clarification has only fueled further speculation, with industry analysts calling it “one of the most chaotic PR moments CBS has faced in a decade.”
Whether the memo is real or the product of internal sabotage, one thing is certain: Tracker fans aren’t going anywhere, and Justin Hartley’s supporters are rallying louder than ever.
But the question now hanging over Hollywood is a chilling one:
If CBS truly believes Tracker is its worst show ever… what does that mean for the future of the series?
