Two quirky legal minds. One shared time slot. And a network strategy that’s turning heads. In what might be the most delightfully unexpected crossover of Fall 2025, CBS is teasing the possibility of bringing together Matlock and Elsbeth — two of its breakout dramedies — for a must-see primetime event. At first glance, the match-up seems odd. But when you dig deeper, it could signal a strategic evolution in how CBS delivers character-driven storytelling and capitalizes on audience overlap.
🔁 CBS Loves a Good Crossover — But This One’s Different
For years, CBS has used crossover events as a clever tool to unify its procedural universe. The NCIS and FBI franchises are built on it — from three-show crossover blockbusters to surprise returns like LL Cool J’s Sam Hanna appearing on NCIS to honor NCIS: LA’s Hetty Lange. Crossovers have served as soft launches, brand extensions, and even emotional payoffs. But those have largely stayed within the gritty, gunmetal-blue world of law enforcement drama.
Now, enter Matlock and Elsbeth: two legal-adjacent shows with flair, fun, and standout female leads. Both are independent of established CBS universes. And both offer something fresh — meaning a crossover here wouldn’t just be marketing. It would be a new kind of narrative experiment.
👠 Courtroom Couture Meets Quirky Crime-Solving
On paper, Matlock and Elsbeth don’t belong in the same courtroom. One is a modern-day reboot of a beloved legal classic, reimagined with Kathy Bates’ razor-sharp Matty Delgado leading a team of sharp young lawyers. The other is a spin-off from The Good Wife universe, following Carrie Preston’s brilliantly oddball detective Elsbeth Tascioni as she outwits suspects in style.
Yet, they share key ingredients that make a crossover surprisingly natural:
-
Both lead characters are older women — sharp, underestimated, and unbothered by conventional rules.
-
Both series air back-to-back on Thursday nights, and Matlock has already helped funnel viewership toward Elsbeth.
-
And both shows blend legal drama with dry humor, making for a genre pairing that actually feels seamless.
A crossover could shine a rare spotlight on older female leads — a demographic still underrepresented in lead roles. Watching Matty and Elsbeth team up (or better yet, go toe-to-toe) could deliver must-see television with sass, intellect, and just the right amount of chaos.
🧠 A Narrative Goldmine in the Making
If CBS goes all-in on the crossover, what might it look like? The possibilities are juicy.
Picture this: Matty Delgado takes on a controversial murder case — one where she suspects her client is innocent but can’t prove it. She calls in Elsbeth, who has a sixth sense for sniffing out liars and hidden motives. Their investigation pulls them into a web of deception, possibly tied to Matty’s mysterious past — still unresolved after Matlock’s twisty season one finale.
But what if Elsbeth already knows Matty’s secret? That she isn’t who she says she is? The tension would be delicious, and the chemistry between Bates and Preston could unlock a whole new fan-favorite dynamic. Think Columbo meets Perry Mason, with a glass of wine and a wink.
💬 What This Means for CBS
CBS has built its empire on familiarity — tight formulas, reliable formats, returning characters. But with this potential crossover, it signals a subtle shift: recognizing that character-first storytelling and tonal synergy can be just as valuable as shared universes.
It’s a lesson networks are starting to learn from shows like Abbott Elementary, which found success in unconventional cameos and tonal pairings (hello, It’s Always Sunny crossover). It’s also reminiscent of 9-1-1 and Doctor Odyssey joining forces, not because they shared a world, but because their characters could emotionally elevate each other.
🎬 Final Verdict
A crossover between Matlock and Elsbeth isn’t just fan service — it’s a clever strategy. It offers deeper character insight, revitalizes the Thursday night block, and provides a platform to celebrate older women on television not just as side characters, but as sharp, funny, powerful leads.
In a TV world filled with spin-offs and reboots, this pairing is anything but stale. It’s smart. It’s unexpected. And it’s exactly what CBS needs to keep the courtroom — and the audience — on its toes.
