Introduction
Eloise Bridgerton is more than just a character in Bridgerton—she’s the show’s voice of rebellion, wit, and independent thought. Unlike her siblings, Eloise has never been one to conform to society’s expectations. But when it comes to her future love story, does her book husband, Sir Phillip Crane, truly suit her fiery personality? Fans argue no, and here’s why.
In this article, we’ll explore why Eloise deserves a love story that matches her strength and intellect. From alternative romantic storylines to the flaws in her book-based relationship, let’s dive into what makes Eloise such a compelling character—and why her romantic arc needs a serious rewrite.
The Problem with Eloise Bridgerton’s Book Husband
Who Is Sir Phillip Crane?
Sir Phillip Crane is introduced in Bridgerton as Marina Thompson’s husband. After a tragic series of events, he marries Marina to protect her honor. His backstory, filled with grief and loss, creates a somber tone that feels at odds with the lighthearted nature of the series.
Why Sir Phillip Doesn’t Suit Eloise
Eloise Bridgerton is a sharp, independent thinker who challenges societal norms. Sir Phillip, while a decent man, lacks the depth and intellect required to truly complement Eloise’s personality. Their relationship, as written in the book To Sir Phillip, With Love, feels forced and doesn’t align with Eloise’s established character in the show.
A Tragic Backstory That Clashes with the Show’s Tone
Marina’s tragic storyline, which includes depression and eventual suicide in the books, adds a heavy layer to Sir Phillip’s character. While this makes for compelling reading, it feels out of place in the show’s typically romantic and uplifting narrative.
Eloise’s Character Deserves a Better Love Story
Eloise as the Rebellious Bridgerton
From the very beginning, Eloise has stood out. She’s uninterested in balls, husbands, or societal expectations. Instead, she values intellectual conversations, personal growth, and her independence.
Why Her Partner Needs to Match Her Intellect
For Eloise, a meaningful connection isn’t about status or appearances—it’s about shared values and mutual respect. Her ideal partner would need to challenge her mind and respect her autonomy.
Alternative Love Stories for Eloise
A Scottish Romance
At the end of Bridgerton season 3, Eloise travels to Scotland. This opens the door to an entirely new romantic possibility. Imagine Eloise meeting a rugged, intellectual Scotsman who shares her love for literature and debate. A romance set against Scotland’s breathtaking landscapes could add an adventurous twist to her story.
Reuniting with Theo Sharpe
Theo Sharpe, the passionate printer’s assistant from season 2, is an ideal match for Eloise. Their chemistry is undeniable, and their shared love for intellectual pursuits makes their connection feel genuine. Reuniting with Theo could bring closure to their unfinished storyline and offer viewers a romance rooted in mutual respect and understanding.
Why Theo Sharpe Is the Perfect Match
An Intellectually Stimulating Connection
Theo challenges Eloise in ways no other character has. Their debates and discussions are the foundation of a relationship built on more than physical attraction—it’s about a meeting of minds.
A Romance Rooted in Equality
Unlike many of the suitors in Bridgerton, Theo sees Eloise as an equal. He respects her ideas and encourages her to explore her potential, making their relationship a refreshing contrast to traditional Regency-era romances.
How Eloise’s Story Can Evolve in the Show
Moving Away from Tradition
Bridgerton has already shown its willingness to deviate from the books. Eloise’s story provides the perfect opportunity to break free from tradition and give her a modern, empowering love story.
Balancing Romance with Independence
Eloise’s journey doesn’t need to end with marriage. Instead, her season could focus on finding a partner who values her independence while also supporting her personal growth.
Why Fans Want a Different Love Story
A Stronger Emotional Payoff
Fans want Eloise to find someone who truly appreciates her unique qualities. A love story that feels authentic and earned would provide a much stronger emotional payoff than her book-based storyline.
Reflecting Modern Values
Eloise represents modern ideals of equality and individuality. Giving her a love story that aligns with these values would resonate with contemporary audiences and make her journey even more compelling.
Conclusion
Eloise Bridgerton is far too complex and dynamic to settle for a love story that doesn’t reflect her character. While Sir Phillip Crane may work in the books, his somber backstory and mismatched personality clash with Eloise’s vibrant spirit.
By exploring alternative romances—whether a fresh Scottish love interest or rekindling her connection with Theo Sharpe—the show can give Eloise the storyline she truly deserves. Her season should be one of growth, passion, and a romance that feels both authentic and empowering.
FAQs
1. Why doesn’t Sir Phillip suit Eloise in the show?
Sir Phillip’s reserved nature and somber backstory don’t align with Eloise’s fiery personality and intellectual curiosity.
2. Who is Theo Sharpe, and why is he a good match for Eloise?
Theo Sharpe is a printer’s assistant introduced in season 2. He shares Eloise’s love for intellectual pursuits, making their connection heartfelt and genuine.
3. Could Eloise find love in Scotland?
Absolutely! A Scottish romance could introduce a fresh storyline filled with adventure, new characters, and beautiful scenery.
4. Will the show deviate from Eloise’s book storyline?
Given the show’s track record of making creative changes, it’s highly likely Eloise’s storyline will be adapted to better suit her character.
5. What makes Eloise’s love story so important?
Eloise’s story represents individuality, intellectual connection, and modern values, making her romantic arc crucial for audience satisfaction.
