A massive bombshell is rocking the Blue Bloods and Boston Blue fan communities this week — discussions are exploding online over whether the legendary Frank Reagan himself could be headed back to television.
For over a decade, Tom Selleck anchored Blue Bloods as New York City Police Commissioner Francis “Frank” Reagan — a role that became iconic not only for his commanding presence, but for the emotional heart he brought to the Reagan family saga. He remained at the center of the show through all 14 seasons, building a legacy fans still cherish.
But after Blue Bloods ended in 2024 and the spin-off Boston Blue launched focusing on Donnie Wahlberg’s Danny Reagan, fans were left wondering: Will Frank ever show up in the new series?
That question ignited once again this week when a fan-sourced report began circulating claiming Selleck might make a special guest appearance as Frank Reagan on Boston Blue* — a move that would bridge the old series with the new and shake up the narrative in a big way.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749x0:751x2)/cast-of-blue-bloods-94-10172024-7d2169070fa0457b98f6b721e4de1f7d.jpg)
Why Fans Are Reacting So Strongly
The reaction on Reddit, Twitter, and fan forums is intense and emotional. Here’s what people are debating:
A Legacy Comeback: Many longtime fans see a potential Selleck cameo as a dream reunion — proof that the franchise still values its roots and isn’t afraid to honor what made Blue Bloods great in the first place.
Too Little, Too Late? Others argue that if Selleck returns only briefly, it could feel like a cheap nostalgia stunt instead of a meaningful narrative choice — especially if it doesn’t help answer unanswered questions from the original show’s finale.
Story Implications: Some viewers are already theorizing how Frank’s return might affect major dynamics:
-
Might he mentor Danny in Boston?
-
Could he confront new enemies or unresolved family issues?
-
Or would the cameo serve as final closure for the character?
The Bigger Question Fans Are Asking
Even fans who don’t want Selleck back universally agree on one point:
If Frank Reagan returns to the screen — even for a single scene — it will be one of the most emotional TV moments of the year.
One popular fan comment summed it up this way:
“If they bring Frank back for Boston Blue, it has to count as canon family history — not just a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it cameo. Give us heart, give us weight.”
With Boston Blue set to return this month, the rumor is fueling endless discussion, wild theories, and hopeful anticipation. Fans are debating plot directions, how the Reagans will intersect with the Boston PD storyline, and whether Selleck’s potential appearance could redefine the spin-off’s emotional landscape.
Will Frank Reagan ride again?
Only time — and perhaps a CBS announcement — will tell.