In spring 2025, Tudyk spoke with Screen Rant about his potential return to The Rookie while on the red carpet for the season 4 premiere of his Syfy show, Resident Alien. He said, “If they come up with an idea, I’ll be there.” Tudyk is evidently open to rejoining the cast of The Rookie, even though it has been three seasons since he appeared in an episode. However, there has to be a decent reason for him to come back. The good news is that I have the perfect idea that could set the scene for Tudyk’s return as Ellroy.
Tudyk’s Character Ellroy Basso Is A Surprisingly Capable Fighter
Ellroy Surprised Nolan With His Fighting Skills In The Rookie Season 4
More specifically, Ellroy started practicing tai chi following the events of his first episode of The Rookie. So, when Nolan and another officer face off against a gang in the season 4 finale, Ellroy comes to their aid. He impresses Nolan with his efficient physical combat skills as he is able to easily (and calmly) take down one of the criminals attacking them. Unfortunately, this is the last time we have seen Ellroy in a fight. However, Tudyk could return in future seasons of The Rookie and continue showing off his self-defense methods.
Tudyk Could Cameo In The Rookie Season 8 As A Civilian Consultant & Trainer
Ellroy’s Fighting Skills Could Come In Handy
Ellroy could very easily become a sort of civilian consultant to teach the new Rookie characters hand-to-hand combat. Of course, most of them would have learned about that while in the academy. However, Ellroy has a unique set of skills that could help rookies further their expertise, resulting in their success. Perhaps this reasoning behind Ellroy’s hypothetical return is a bit out there, but it might be the best way to bring Tudyk back to the ABC police procedural series.
Unfortunately, Tudyk’s The Rookie Return Could Only Ever Be A One-Off Cameo
Tudyk Is Quite Busy
