With The Golden Bachelorette concluding in a heartwarming engagement between Joan Vassos and Chock Chapple, fans are already buzzing about who might take the lead in The Golden Bachelor Season 2. Among the contenders, three fan-favorites—Mark Anderson, Guy Gansert, and Pascal Ibgui—stood out for their unique personalities and memorable moments on Joan’s season. However, it seems unlikely that any of these three will be invited back for another shot at finding love. Here’s why.
Mark Anderson May Have Already Found His “Happily Ever After”
Mark Anderson, known as the “Hot Dad” from The Bachelor Season 28, charmed audiences with his humor and good looks. Despite being a popular pick among fans, his connection with Joan fizzled after an awkward one-on-one date, leading to his elimination.
Since then, Mark’s romantic life seems to have taken an unexpected turn. Rumors swirled after actress Barbara Woods (One Tree Hill) shared a Halloween photo with Mark. Dressed as Cinderella and Prince Charming, the two sparked speculation with a caption that read, “When Cinderella and Prince Charming have a baby,” as Barbara’s daughter, Natalie Alyn Lind, posed alongside them.
Although neither Mark nor Barbara has confirmed the dating rumors, their public appearances suggest a growing connection. If Mark is in a relationship, he’s likely off the table for The Golden Bachelor Season 2. After all, why search for love on national TV when you may have already found it?
Guy Gansert’s Past Could Be a Dealbreaker
Guy Gansert, the runner-up of The Golden Bachelorette, seemed like an ideal match for Joan. His adventurous spirit and compassionate nature made him a fan favorite. However, unsettling details about his past emerged after the show, casting doubt on his potential as the next Bachelor.
Legal documents revealed that Guy’s ex-wife, Heidi Seevers O’Gara, once filed for a restraining order against him, alleging aggressive behavior. Heidi claimed that Guy’s actions, possibly linked to sleeping medication, made her fear for her safety. In one incident, she accused him of making a gun-like gesture toward her after tampering with her car.
Although Heidi later withdrew her application, the allegations stirred controversy. Guy faced backlash for failing to disclose this part of his history during the show. While he remains a compelling figure, his reputation may be too tarnished for producers to risk bringing him back as the leading man.
Pascal Ibgui’s Unfiltered Personality Could Be Too Much
Pascal Ibgui, the candid French salon owner, was one of the most entertaining contestants on The Golden Bachelorette. Known for his unapologetic honesty, Pascal quickly became a fan favorite despite admitting he couldn’t cook, clean, or do laundry.
However, his unfiltered nature might make him a liability for the show. Pascal’s post-show interviews, particularly one with Glamour, criticized the production team for manipulating his words during his emotional exit. He accused producers of encouraging him to downplay his feelings for Joan, which left her questioning her self-worth.
While Pascal’s bluntness and charm made for great TV, his outspokenness about behind-the-scenes manipulation could deter the franchise from inviting him back. Producers might prefer someone less likely to air grievances publicly.
The Future of The Golden Bachelor
Mark, Guy, and Pascal each brought something unique to The Golden Bachelorette, but their individual circumstances make it unlikely they’ll return as contenders for The Golden Bachelor Season 2. Whether it’s Mark’s potential relationship, Guy’s troubled past, or Pascal’s unpredictability, these factors may lead producers to look elsewhere for their next senior love story.
Fans can only speculate about who will take the lead, but one thing is certain: The Golden Bachelor Season 2 will bring new surprises, drama, and hopefully, a heartwarming ending.
