In Chicago Fire Season 10, Episode 7, which aired on November 3, viewers were left in tears over a heartfelt scene that highlighted the deep emotional impact of Captain Matthew Casey’s (Jesse Spencer) sudden departure. The moment focused on Casey’s girlfriend, Sylvie Brett (Kara Killmer), and showcased her struggle to cope with his absence. Although fans have been divided about Brett and Casey’s relationship in the past, they seem united in their grief over the couple’s separation. Adding to the emotional weight of the episode is the tension surrounding Casey’s temporary replacement, Lieutenant Jason Pelham (Brett Dalton), who has yet to win over the fans.
Sylvie Brett’s Heart-Wrenching Moment
The emotional rollercoaster for fans started in the previous episode, where Brett listened to a voicemail from Casey that left many in tears. In Episode 7, the heartbreak continued with a simple yet gut-wrenching text message from Casey. The message informed Brett that he had to cancel her visit to Portland due to a new training program for fighting forest fires. Though Jesse Spencer’s voice was absent from the scene, Kara Killmer’s performance perfectly conveyed the depth of Brett’s pain and disappointment.
In a raw and vulnerable moment, Brett shares her sorrow with Gallo (Alberto Rosende). Visibly shaken, she admits, “I really miss him,” her voice cracking with emotion. Gallo, equally affected by Casey’s absence, responds, “I do too.” Their shared moment of grief becomes a brief but powerful bond, as they try to console each other by imagining what Casey would say to lift their spirits. This touching exchange resonates deeply with fans, who are clearly not ready to move on from Casey’s departure.
Fans React to Brett’s Tearful Scene
The scene struck a chord with viewers, who took to social media to share their emotional reactions. Twitter user @Learnthingss posted a clip of the scene, captioning it, “Despite seeing Brett cry THIS WAS MY FAVORITE SCENE,” which quickly garnered hundreds of likes. Many fans expressed their heartbreak over seeing Brett’s raw vulnerability, with @DanielleKGomes1 tweeting, “So sad… I don’t like to see her suffering… it’s not fair!” Another fan, @HKoonts, joked, “I’m not crying, YOU’RE crying,” echoing the sentiment of many viewers.
Some fans found comfort in the bond between Brett and Gallo. Twitter user @deviero10 shared, “Love to see they can support each other,” highlighting the strength of their friendship during a difficult time. Others, like @youpin99, called it the “best scene of the night,” with several fans agreeing that it was a standout moment in the episode.
Criticism and Hopes for Brett’s Future
Not everyone was entirely satisfied, though. Some fans used the scene as an opportunity to critique the direction of Brett’s storyline. User @Kathy_Dominguez noted, “As much as I’m not a fan of Brett and Casey together, I feel like the writers don’t want her character to be happy. It never works out whenever she has a boyfriend.” Others wished the scene had focused on different relationships, with @_hellotherese suggesting, “I wish it was Severide that saw her cry. Perfect moment for their friendship to grow. He didn’t just ‘lose’ Matt; she did too.”
What’s Next for Brett and Casey?
The question now is whether Brett will be able to move on from Casey or if his return to Chicago Fire is still a possibility. For now, fans continue to hold on to the hope that the beloved captain might come back to Firehouse 51. Until then, the emotional toll of his absence remains a central theme, leaving viewers eagerly awaiting what’s next for Brett’s character arc.
No matter what happens, it’s clear that the impact of Casey’s departure is still felt throughout the series. The love and longing for his return persist, proving that the bond between him and Brett has left a lasting mark on fans — a fire that even the heroes of Firehouse 51 can’t put out.
