Young Sheldon wrapped up its seventh season, inching closer to the events of The Big Bang Theory. While fans reveled in the nostalgia and character development, one plot point left some viewers scratching their heads: the rapid deterioration of George Sr. and Mary’s relationship.
Balancing Canon with Character Growth
Young Sheldon isn’t afraid to deviate from The Big Bang Theory’s established canon. For instance, Sheldon’s infamous “cheating” narrative gets a revision, revealing a misunderstanding. While these changes can be refreshing, they can also create inconsistencies. Similarly, season 7’s portrayal of Mary and George Sr. felt like a rushed attempt to align with their dynamic in The Big Bang Theory at the expense of natural storytelling.
Meemaw’s Metamorphosis: Missed Opportunity?
Season 6’s finale saw Meemaw’s home destroyed. This event could have provided a reason for the more conservative Meemaw we see in The Big Bang Theory. However, Young Sheldon season 7 goes in the opposite direction, portraying her as even more rebellious. This disconnect adds to the feeling that Young Sheldon might be creating an alternate universe rather than a seamless prequel.
The Spark That Faded Too Soon: Mary & George Sr.’s Romance Cut Short
Season 7, episode 5, “A Frankenstein’s Monster and a Crazy Church Guy,” throws a curveball. Just a week after Mary’s heartwarming return from Germany, tensions resurface between Mary and George Sr. While Young Sheldon thrives on its bickering characters, the quick turnaround in their relationship raised eyebrows.
Understanding the Big Bang Theory Connection
The Big Bang Theory rarely paints George Sr. in a positive light. It stands to reason that Mary and George Sr. wouldn’t be picture-perfect before his tragic demise. Short-lived happiness might even amplify the emotional impact of his death. After all, learning George Sr. was innocent of Mary’s cheating accusations already added a layer of sadness. A perfectly happy marriage would only heighten the tragedy.
Setting Up the Stage: A Necessary Bickering for Backstory
George Sr.’s death is a pivotal point in Sheldon’s backstory, impossible to ignore. In this light, Mary and George Sr.’s argument over her donation becomes a necessary plot element. It reinforces their longstanding dynamic while reminding viewers of their underlying love and chemistry after years of marriage. This bittersweet ending sets the stage for Young Sheldon season 7’s emotional finale, making the transition to The Big Bang Theory’s timeline feel earned.
Conclusion: A Balancing Act?
Young Sheldon navigates a delicate balance between adhering to canon and developing its own narrative. While some fans appreciate the show’s willingness to rewrite established storylines, others feel it disrupts the flow. George Sr. and Mary’s rushed conflict highlights this debate. While necessary to bridge the gap to The Big Bang Theory, it sacrificed some of the season’s emotional potential. Ultimately, it’s up to the individual viewer to decide whether Young Sheldon struck the right chord.
FAQs
1. Why did Young Sheldon season 7 change the “cheating” narrative?
Young Sheldon offers a different perspective on Sheldon’s childhood memories. Instead of infidelity, it portrays a misunderstanding between George Sr. and Mary.
2. Did Young Sheldon contradict The Big Bang Theory by making Meemaw more rebellious?
Young Sheldon is taking liberties with established canon. Meemaw’s transformation may be a creative choice, but it creates a potential timeline inconsistency with The Big Bang Theory.
3. Was the argument between Mary and George Sr. in Young Sheldon necessary?
Yes. It establishes a foundation for the conflict we see in The Big Bang Theory while reminding viewers of their complicated yet enduring love.
4. How will Young Sheldon handle George Sr.’s death?
Considering the show’s dedication to character development, we can expect a nuanced and emotional portrayal of this pivotal event in Sheldon’s life.
5. Will Young Sheldon continue to deviate from The Big Bang Theory’s canon?
It’s likely. Young Sheldon prioritizes character growth over strict adherence to canon, which may lead to further revisions of established storylines.
