Breaking Down the Most Underrated Scene in The Sopranos Series Finale

Tony and Uncle Junior shared a rocky relationship, to say the least. From Junior plotting with Livia (Nancy Marchand) to kill Tony in the earliest episodes to him shooting his nephew toward the end, the state of their partnership was complex, juicy, and almost always poignant. These are two men who loved and respected each other in their own twisted, mafia-machismo way, but a tinge of jealousy and betrayal always dragged them down. The family game was more important than the family name, that is until Junior’s dementia and elderly decline were able to strip away the superficiality and reveal the authenticity lurking behind the curtain.

Tony wants to talk specifics about who will inherit Junior’s money after Bobby Bacala (Steve Schirripa) is murdered in “Blue Comet.” To his surprise, Junior stares blankly into the distance, barely understanding who Tony is and especially not grappling with the significance of any financial issues within the crime family. “What, you don’t recognize me?” Tony sarcastically tests Junior’s memory, to which his uncle says, “We used to play catch.” This line is so sharp, and so powerful, that it’s hard to put into words how much credit the scriptwriters deserve here.

Tony tells his kids to remember the good times in life back in season 1, a statement that A.J. immediately brings up to his father once again at the restaurant just a few minutes after this scene. When Tony wants Junior to recall mobster turmoil and family politics, the only thing his lost brain can find is a moment of innocence. As much as the Soprano family wants to act high and mighty, they’re just like any other kin unit in America. This fleeting image in Junior’s head of a simple time between a nephew and an uncle, throwing a baseball in the backyard, reveals the affection that existed before it was killed by the business.

Tony ignores the positive memory and again attempts for Junior to identify his mobster past. “You and my dad, you guys ran North Jersey.” Junior’s response spoils the importance Tony tries to place upon it. “We did? Well, that’s nice.” All of the fanfare and faux importance placed upon organized crime in the world of The Sopranos is ripped in half right at this moment. These people serve no purpose to society except in their own minds. At the end of their lives, the only details that matter are the daily excursions, games, and interactions that every other person might have. We place so much value on our jobs, and in the case of these characters their jobs are killing rival gang leaders and evading prison, that we forget to appreciate the good times and the shared experiences that make us human.

The penultimate moments of The Sopranos serve as a concrete contrast to the ambiguity and artistic flair presented in the diner right after it. While the dinner scene represents the show at its most daring, the nursing home encounter symbolizes the series at its most somber. It’s the calm before the storm, but it also stands alone as the best conversation in the series. It didn’t get discussed by bloggers or journalists in the days after the episode aired, and it rarely gets brought up in Reddit talk or water cooler blabbing two decades later. But just like that catch that Tony and Uncle Junior shared, it’s the type of moment that would pop into our heads when recounting TV’s zeitgeist when everything else fades away.