For decades, Friends fans have theorized, debated, and re-watched every episode searching for hidden drama and alternate universe plotlines. But the most explosive behind-the-scenes revelation to surface recently isn’t about Ross and Rachel, Phoebe’s quirky love life, or even Joey’s failed spinoff — it’s the almost-forgotten early plan to pair Monica Geller and Joey Tribbiani romantically, with real spin-off potential that NBC considered before Joey got his own show.
A Relationship That Never Made It Past the Pitch Stage
According to insiders digging into Friends’ early development, executive producers David Crane and Marta Kauffman originally contemplated pairing Monica (Courteney Cox) with Joey (Matt LeBlanc) instead of Chandler. This wasn’t a fleeting joke or fan fiction — the idea was real enough to be written into early creative discussions before being scrapped because the characters’ chemistry wasn’t right once the actors were cast.
Before Chandler Bing entered the picture as Monica’s eventual love interest, Monica and Joey were intended to be more than friends in the original pitch. Creators even sketched hypothetical story arcs where the two would navigate a romantic storyline that could have led into a dedicated spinoff following their life together — a much different direction than the sitcom history eventually took.
Why It Fell Apart — Behind the Chemistry Curtain
Once filming and chemistry reads began, producers quickly realized Joey’s personality leaned into a brotherly, lovable-but-platonic role with Monica, rather than a romantic one. Matt LeBlanc’s warm, comedic portrayal of Joey as Chandler’s best friend and Monica’s confident buddy made the idea of a serious romance feel off — even to fans watching the early episodes.
Reddit discussions among superfans reveal that many still can’t believe this concept existed, often joking that “Joey’s sandwich-obsessed charm just wouldn’t have cut it as Monica’s soulmate”. Some even speculate that the later depiction of Joey as perpetually single and somewhat directionless was a direct result of this rejected storyline, as the writers leaned into his friend-zone persona instead of creating a forced romance.
How This Would Have Changed TV History
Imagine a world where:
-
Monica and Joey’s dynamic evolved from best friends to life partners on screen.
-
A Friends spinoff followed their suburban years, blending sitcom warmth with dating misadventures.
-
Joey might have avoided his infamous cancelled NBC show, Joey, if he had stayed rooted in Monica’s orbit.
This alternate trajectory would have not only reframed the dynamics among the Friends ensemble, but also altered how the cast’s careers unfolded in the years after the show ended — because Matthew Perry’s iconic Chandler wouldn’t have stepped into that leading romantic role, and Courteney Cox might never have formed the emotional attachment that fans still cherish decades later.
The Friends Universe We Know vs. the One That Almost Was
Ultimately, Friends settled into the beloved Monica-Chandler romance that became a fan favorite, with Chandler stepping in as the heart-warmed counterpart to Monica’s intensity and ambition. But the revelation that Monica + Joey was once seriously on the table continues to ignite online debates about what could have been — and why one of television’s most treasured couples almost looked very different.