For the first time since Tracker stormed onto network television, Justin Hartley’s hit crime drama may finally be facing serious competition. ABC’s new crime show isn’t just another procedural filling a time slot—it’s a calculated swing at the very audience that made Tracker such a juggernaut. And honestly? It might land.
So what makes this new ABC series different? Why are industry insiders whispering about it as a potential disruptor? And could it really chip away at Tracker’s dominance? Let’s break it all down.
The Unstoppable Rise of Justin Hartley’s Tracker
Why Tracker Became a Ratings Powerhouse
When Tracker debuted, expectations were solid—but no one predicted how fast it would explode. The formula was deceptively simple: a rugged lone-wolf protagonist, emotionally grounded storytelling, and mysteries that felt personal rather than procedural.
Justin Hartley didn’t just star in Tracker—he anchored it.
Viewers weren’t just tuning in for the case of the week. They were tuning in for him.
Justin Hartley’s Star Power Can’t Be Ignored
Hartley brought credibility, charisma, and emotional weight to the role. After years of strong performances, Tracker felt like his moment. He wasn’t playing a superhero or a soap heartthrob—he was playing a man shaped by loss, instinct, and moral gray areas.
That authenticity became the show’s secret weapon.
Why Network TV Is Hungry for the Next Big Crime Hit
Crime Dramas Still Dominate Prime Time
Despite streaming’s rise, crime dramas remain network TV’s most reliable genre. Why? Because they’re comforting, familiar, and endlessly adaptable. Audiences like knowing what they’re getting—just with a new twist.
Tracker mastered that balance. Now ABC wants its own version of lightning in a bottle.
ABC’s Strategic Push for Prestige Crime
ABC has quietly been rebuilding its crime-drama identity. Instead of pumping out endless procedurals, the network has shifted toward character-driven stories with darker tones and serialized arcs.
This new show fits that strategy perfectly.
Inside ABC’s New Crime Show
A Premise That Feels Fresh—but Familiar
ABC’s upcoming crime drama centers on a deeply flawed investigator navigating high-stakes cases that blur the line between justice and obsession. Sound familiar? That’s intentional.
The show doesn’t reinvent the wheel—it polishes it.
Think less “paint-by-numbers procedural” and more “slow-burn psychological thriller with emotional consequences.”
A Protagonist Built to Rival Tracker’s Lead
At the heart of the show is a lead character designed to pull viewers in emotionally, not just intellectually. This isn’t someone solving crimes from behind a desk. This is a character who feels every case.
That emotional proximity is exactly what made Tracker work—and ABC knows it.
What Makes This Show a Genuine Threat to Tracker
Darker Themes, Higher Emotional Stakes
While Tracker balances grit with heart, ABC’s new show leans harder into darkness. Trauma isn’t backstory—it’s an active force shaping decisions.
For viewers craving something heavier, this could be the draw.
Serialized Storytelling Keeps Viewers Hooked
One of the biggest differences? Serialization.
Instead of neatly wrapping up every episode, this show stretches its mysteries across multiple episodes, encouraging binge-style viewing—even on network TV.
That’s a smart move in a post-streaming world.
Comparing ABC’s New Show and Tracker Side by Side
Tone and Mood
-
Tracker: Grounded, emotional, quietly intense
-
ABC’s New Show: Darker, more psychological, morally ambiguous
Both work—but appeal to slightly different emotional cravings.
Character Complexity
Justin Hartley’s character is introspective and instinct-driven. ABC’s lead appears more volatile, possibly even self-destructive.
That contrast alone could split audiences.
Why Viewers Might Actually Want an Alternative to Tracker
Audience Fatigue Is Real
Even the most loyal fans eventually want something new. That doesn’t mean abandoning Tracker—it means supplementing it.
ABC’s show arrives at the perfect moment: familiar enough to feel safe, different enough to feel exciting.
The Curiosity Factor
Let’s be honest—viewers love a challenger. When a show is labeled “the next big thing,” people tune in just to see if it lives up to the hype.
That curiosity could translate into strong early ratings.
The Role of Casting in ABC’s Gamble
A Lead Actor With Something to Prove
While Justin Hartley is a proven draw, ABC’s new series reportedly features a lead actor on the verge of a breakout. That hunger often translates to risk-taking performances.
Sometimes, that’s magic.
Supporting Cast That Adds Depth
Early buzz suggests the supporting characters aren’t filler—they’re fully realized, morally complex figures who evolve over time.
That ensemble strength could be a major advantage.
How Scheduling Could Decide the Winner
Time Slots Matter More Than Ever
If ABC positions this show directly against Tracker, things could get interesting fast. Head-to-head competition forces viewers to choose—and not everyone will stick with habit.
Lead-In and Lead-Out Strategy
Strong lead-ins can make or break a premiere. ABC seems aware of this and is reportedly building a night that keeps viewers locked in emotionally.
Smart scheduling could tip the scales.
Streaming, Social Media, and the Buzz Factor
Why Social Media Reaction Will Be Crucial
Tracker thrives on word-of-mouth. ABC’s show will need the same organic buzz—clips shared, moments dissected, characters debated.
If Twitter and TikTok latch on, momentum could snowball fast.
Next-Day Streaming Numbers Matter
Network TV isn’t just about live ratings anymore. Streaming performance will play a massive role in determining whether this show truly threatens Tracker long-term.
Could Both Shows Win? Absolutely
Competition Doesn’t Always Mean Casualties
Here’s the thing: this doesn’t have to be a zero-sum game. Tracker can remain dominant while ABC’s show carves out its own loyal fanbase.
In fact, competition often sharpens quality across the board.
Viewers Benefit the Most
More high-quality crime dramas mean better storytelling, stronger performances, and higher stakes. That’s a win for audiences.
What This Means for the Future of Network Crime Dramas
The Genre Is Evolving—Fast
ABC’s bold move signals a shift. Crime dramas aren’t just comfort TV anymore—they’re becoming emotionally layered, stylistically daring, and narratively complex.
Tracker helped pave the way. Now others are following.
Expect More Risks, Fewer Safe Bets
Networks are realizing that safe isn’t enough. To compete with streaming, they need shows that feel urgent and alive.
This new series is a step in that direction.
Final Verdict: Is Tracker Finally in Trouble?
Not exactly—but it’s no longer alone at the top.
ABC’s new crime show feels like the first real attempt to challenge Tracker on its own turf: emotional depth, character-driven storytelling, and high-stakes mysteries. Whether it dethrones Justin Hartley’s hit or simply stands beside it, one thing is clear—the crime drama landscape just got a lot more interesting.
And for viewers? That’s very good news.
Conclusion
ABC’s new crime show isn’t just another procedural—it’s a calculated, confident swing at one of network TV’s biggest successes. While Tracker remains a powerhouse, this new contender brings darker themes, serialized storytelling, and emotional risk-taking that could lure viewers looking for something fresh. Whether it becomes a true rival or a complementary hit, it proves one thing: Justin Hartley’s reign has officially entered its most interesting chapter yet.