As Virgin River heads into Season 7, fans are once again questioning the stability of Mel and Jack’s hard-won happiness. One theory gaining traction is the possibility — however uncomfortable — that Jack could cheat on Mel. The show has a long history of testing relationships through emotional pressure rather than outright betrayal, but Season 6 planted subtle warning signs: unresolved trauma, business stress, and Jack’s tendency to shut down instead of communicating.
Rather than a dramatic affair, Season 7 could explore a near-miss scenario — an emotional lapse or moment of vulnerability that crosses a line. This approach would stay true to the series’ grounded tone while still shaking Mel’s trust. Importantly, such a storyline wouldn’t be about vilifying Jack, but about confronting his long-standing flaws. If handled carefully, the idea of infidelity could become less about scandal and more about whether love can survive disappointment — a theme Virgin River knows well.