Netflix’s holiday content machine shows no signs of slowing down, and My Secret Santa is the latest seasonal title to dominate viewer attention. The Christmas rom-com, starring Alexandra Breckenridge and Ryan Eggold, has claimed the top spot on Netflix’s U.S. charts, signaling strong viewer curiosity despite lukewarm critical reception.
Directed by Mike Rohl, the film leans heavily into classic holiday tropes, blending workplace comedy with romance and mistaken identity. The story follows a single mother who disguises herself as a male Santa to secure a seasonal job at a luxury ski resort — a premise clearly designed for cozy, low-stakes viewing.
Critics, however, remain divided. Collider described the movie as serviceable but ultimately forgettable, suggesting it works best as background entertainment during holiday activities rather than as a standout seasonal favorite. Yet Netflix audiences appear happy to press play regardless.
The film’s chart success comes amid fierce competition, with Troll 2, Jay Kelly, Rio 2, and Cast Away also ranking high. As December viewing habits skew toward comfort and familiarity, My Secret Santa proves that holiday cheer — not critical praise — is often the true streaming currency.
