Tracker is, for some reason, determined to ditch everything that made the show interesting in its third season. The procedural series has almost completely shed its original cast: Robin Weigert, Abby McEnany, and Eric Graise. The only remaining supporting character from Season 1 of the CBS series is Fiona Rene’s Reenie Greene. Her character and Colter Shaw (Justin Hartley) have a “will they/won’t they” tension that could lead somewhere in Season 3. However, a possible new love interest named Mel Day (Cassady McClincy) has been introduced on the show for the notoriously isolated rewardist. As fun as the new character already seems, it would be a shame if Tracker ignored this pairing’s clear potential.
Tracker is, for some reason, determined to ditch everything that made the show interesting in its third season. The procedural series has almost completely shed its original cast: Robin Weigert, Abby McEnany, and Eric Graise. The only remaining supporting character from Season 1 of the CBS series is Fiona Rene’s Reenie Greene. Her character and Colter Shaw (Justin Hartley) have a “will they/won’t they” tension that could lead somewhere in Season 3. However, a possible new love interest named Mel Day (Cassady McClincy) has been introduced on the show for the notoriously isolated rewardist. As fun as the new character already seems, it would be a shame if Tracker ignored this pairing’s clear potential.
Reenie is a key member of Colter’s team. She’s able to look up legal records that assist in his cases. She can also help get him out of scrapes with local law enforcement and occasionally call in favors. In both Season 2 and Season 3, we learned more about Reenie’s professional and personal life outside of Colter. That’s awesome! But that doesn’t mean she can’t also date him. Contrary to what every romantic comedy wants to sell audiences, romance and career are not mutually exclusive. Not to be dramatic, but a slow burn still has to burn or the candle will go out.
Colter and Reenie are a good team. What better basis for a romantic relationship is that? They very clearly care about each other. They worry about each other. They’re both very responsible. They have similar values, but clash over a few things. Reenie does not always approve of Colter’s vigilante methods, and Colter does not always approve of Reenie’s shady clients. It’s good to have tension in addition to chemistry. Some of the best scenes on the show occur when Reenie and Colter happen to be in the same physical location and debrief over drinks outside of Colter’s infamous van. And she’s one of the only people that he’ll open up to about his past. There’s real trust there.
The Undeniable Chemistry Between Reenie & Colter
Let’s start with the obvious: on Tracker, the dynamic between Reenie Greene and Colter Shaw simply clicks. They tease, they trust, they ride the thin line between colleagues and something more. And yet, the show seems almost reluctant to commit. If you’ve ever watched two characters orbiting each other like moons around a planet, you know the tension they generate—and how much payoff viewers crave.
Why the Writers Are Holding Back
One big reason the romance hasn’t fully blossomed is timing. Reenie is deeply established as Colter’s legal partner and occasional moral anchor. The writers have clearly built a foundation of respect and trust between them. For instance, actress Fiona Rene said that Reenie “will always love Colter” but that he isn’t ready yet.
In other words: they’ve set up the groundwork—but the leap to romance remains tentative.
Foundation First: How a Relationship Could Be Built Right
If the show wants to make Reenie & Colter work, they’ll need to keep walking the foundation route. That means more scenes where they rely on each other, more moments of vulnerability. Reenie is smart, measured. Colter is rugged, independent. Together they balance one another—but only if the writers give them the chance to move from “professional allies” to “something more.”
Trust over Sparks
Romantic tension is fun, but sustainable relationships need trust. The show has given us glimpses: Reenie stepping into danger for a client, Colter surprising Reenie by showing he can listen and support. These are the building blocks.
Shared Conflict, Shared Victory
When two characters go through adversity together—especially life-or-death or emotional stakes—they bond. On Tracker, where Colter tracks the missing, and Reenie navigates the legal fallout, there are plenty of cases to lean into. A shared foe or case could be the catalyst they finally need.
The Roadblocks Keeping Them Apart
Why hasn’t the romance happened yet? A few reasons:
-
Colter’s baggage. His past is shady, his chosen lifestyle unstable. The show is clearly signalling that Colter isn’t “settled.”
-
Reenie’s standards. Reenie isn’t looking for someone half-in. As Fiona Rene put it: Reenie wants emotional stability and vulnerability.
-
Narrative distraction. With Colter chasing missing persons and Reenie’s legal work intensifying, the show may deprioritize romance in favour of plot.
What Fans Are Asking For—and Why
When fans watch Screen 1 of a show, they see the hero save lives. But when fans watch Screen 2 (the home screen of their hearts), they want relationships. Reenie & Colter deliver that layered dynamic: banter, respect, unspoken feelings. It’s why so many viewers are shouting “ship it !” from the sidelines. And the show is ignoring the momentum at its own risk.
Evidence the Show Is Building the Romance
Despite the delays, there are clear signals:
-
In Season 2 Episode 11, the characters have “little deep convos” that open them up.
-
The narrative continues to place Reenie and Colter in scenarios where they rely on each other’s strengths.
-
Reviewers and media outlets keep pointing out the chemistry.
These bits hint that the show isn’t shying away altogether—it’s pacing it.
Why A Slow-Burn Works
Some romances burn bright and fast—and often crash. A slow burn ensures that when the “yes” happens, it carries weight. For Reenie and Colter, the show benefits by:
-
Building more emotional credibility.
-
Letting the audience invest in each step.
-
Avoiding the “instant declaration” trap that feels inorganic.
What the Show Could Still Do Better
Here are a few constructive tweaks that could elevate the pairing:
Let Reenie Say It Out Loud
Words matter. A line like “I trust you, Colter” or “I’ve always cared about you” could tip the scale from subtext to promise. The audience needs audible commitment.
Give Colter a Moment of Growth
If Colter acknowledges his fear of commitment or admits that he needs stability, it shows he’s ready for Reenie. Growth = credibility.
Create a Shared Crisis
If Reenie’s safety is compromised—say, during one of Colter’s tracking missions—and Colter goes all-in to protect her, that kind of Sacrifice moment can change everything.
Why Holding Back Could Hurt the Show
Let’s be honest: when chemistry is obvious and the show drags its feet, it risks:
-
Viewers losing patience.
-
Fans drifting to other couples or shows with more payoff.
-
The “friend zone” trope becoming permanent—no thanks.
The writers should use this as an opportunity, not a distraction.
The Big “What If?”
What if the show never fully commits to Reenie and Colter? Then we’re left with one of two outcomes:
-
A permanent “will-they/won’t-they” loop that frustrates.
-
A late-season pivot that feels rushed or out of character.
Neither is great for a show that thrives on tension and character arcs.
The Potential Pay-Off: When It Finally Happens
Picture this: Colter and Reenie sit in the camper, rain pounding outside after a long case. They’ve found the missing person. Colter offers Reenie his travel mug. She takes it. They lock eyes. And he says: “I couldn’t have done it without you.” She smiles. The camera holds. That’s not just banter anymore—that’s partnership. That’s romance. That’s payoff.
When done right, their story could be one of the most satisfying arcs on Tracker: “two strong people choose each other after recognizing they’re better together.”
How That Strengthens the Series
-
Adds emotional stakes to the procedurals.
-
Deepens character motives.
-
Encourages viewer investment.
-
Broadens storytelling possibilities (What happens when they decide to settle? What happens when one job takes the other away?).
Timing Is Everything: Why Now Is the Moment
With Season 3 underway, now is the window. The foundation is built, character arcs have matured, and viewers are ready. If the writers wait too long, momentum will fade. If they act now, the payoff will carry into future seasons and keep fans hooked.
Final Word to the Showrunners
Dear writers of Tracker: yes—keep the hunts, keep the adrenaline, keep the Colter-on-the-move energy. But don’t ignore the heart of the show. Reenie is there. Colter is there. The chemistry is there. Write the scene. Let them choose each other. Let the slow burn catch fire.
Conclusion
In a world of rapid-dump romances and throwaway hookups, the slow-build pairing of Reenie and Colter is refreshing. It’s smart, it’s layered, and most importantly, it matters. The show has done the work: groundwork laid, characters defined, chemistry undeniable. What remains is the leap. If the show takes it—beautiful. If it doesn’t, it risks wasting one of its most promising relationships. So yes—Tracker shouldn’t forget about Reenie and Colter’s potential romance. It should embrace it.
