On the latest installment of Hell’s Kitchen Season 24 (titled “There’s Something Fishy Going On”), the pressure ratcheted up yet again in Chef Gordon Ramsay’s kitchen, culminating in the elimination of one competitor — and a cliffhanger that leaves the remaining chefs uneasy. primetimer.com+2primetimer.com+2
The Setup: Fish Challenge and Dockside Drama
The episode opened with a high‑stakes seafood relay at the docks of Stonington, Connecticut. Both teams — red and blue — were tasked with identifying and retrieving seven species of fish, among them flounder, monkfish, sea bass, and mackerel. SoapCentral+1 The winning team would earn a five‑minute head start in the cooking phase. primetimer.com+1
The Red Team performed well in the dock challenge, securing the time advantage. primetimer.com+1 But the real test came during the dinner service.
Dinner Service Woes and Key Mistakes
During dinner service, both teams faced serious issues. On the Blue Team side, delayed beef Wellington dishes and mis‐timed stations caused trouble. CT Insider+1 Meanwhile the Red Team struggled with internal communication and, notably, problems at the garnish station. Chef Cat Smith repeatedly served undercooked carrots that were returned by Ramsay himself:
“They’re f***ing hard. They need to be cooked.” SoapCentral
That misstep proved costly: the Red Team was ultimately declared the losing side of the night. SoapCentral+1
Nomination, Pleas, and Elimination
Following the loss, the Red Team was asked to nominate three chefs for elimination. They chose Cat Smith, Alexandra Jones and Cara Marie Hall. primetimer.com+1
During the elimination round:
-
Alexandra argued she’d been playing team‑player but got caught in “high school politics.” primetimer.com
-
Cara Marie accepted responsibility for earlier mistakes and pledged improvement. primetimer.com
-
Cat acknowledged her repeated errors but emphasised her passion and determination. primetimer.com
Ultimately, Gordon Ramsay eliminated Cat Smith, citing her performance at the garnish station as evidence she isn’t ready to lead a kitchen. primetimer.com+1
The Cliffhanger: What’s Next?
Just when it seemed the night was over, Ramsay called forward Chef Bradley Wildridge of the Blue Team and inserted a final twist: he singled him out for apparently dropping the ball — and then sent the rest of the contestants away. The episode ended without clarifying whether Bradley faced elimination or other consequences. primetimer.com+1
Why This Elimination Matters
This episode highlights several recurring themes of the competition:
-
Precision under pressure: Even sides like garnish matter — sloppy execution in a supposedly “minor” station can sink a chef’s night.
-
Team dynamics: The Red Team’s communication breakdowns — especially around Cat’s station and the resultant delays — undermined their service.
-
Fresh escalation: Ramsay’s move to single out Bradley and leave the elimination uncertain raises the stakes for the remaining chefs.
For Cat Smith, the message from Ramsay was clear: passion is not enough. The role of head chef demands consistency, leadership, and technical command — and in his view, she hadn’t demonstrated that yet.
Looking Ahead
With Cat gone and uncertainty surrounding Bradley’s fate, Episode 5 promises high drama. Will Ramsay conduct a surprise double elimination? Will the Blue Team’s hesitation around Bradley fester into a deeper issue? The remaining chefs now know that any station – from garnish to entremets – can be a make‑or‑break moment.
