If you’re a fan of television drama, you likely felt the shock when CBS announced the cancellation of three of its shows: So Help Me Todd, CSI: Vegas and NCIS: Hawai’i. But the story doesn’t stop at “cancelled.” CBS executives have spoken out, explaining why these decisions were made and whether there’s any chance of revival. In this article, we’ll dig deep into what we know so far, what the executives said, what it means for fans, and whether any of these shows might yet have a future.
Why Did CBS Cancel These Shows?
The Three Shows in Question
-
So Help Me Todd: A light-hearted procedural with a twist.
-
CSI: Vegas: The latest iteration of the famous CSI franchise.
-
NCIS: Hawai’i: The tropical spin-off of the long-running NCIS brand.
All three were cancelled around the same time as part of CBS’s spring schedule shake-up.
What CBS Execs Actually Said
Tough choices and roster space
CBS Entertainment President Amy Reisenbach said the network “tosses and turns” over cancelling shows. She pointed out that even shows with decent viewership sometimes must go because of flow, cost, and schedule cohesion.
CBS Chief George Cheeks admitted they had “wonderful experience” with So Help Me Todd, and he called it “heartbreaking” to cancel.
Ratings, costs, platform shifts
For example:
-
NCIS: Hawai’i averaged 7.81 million viewers with Live+7 across season 3 — up 4 % from season 2 — yet was still cancelled.
-
CSI: Vegas averaged around 6.1 million viewers, up 7 % year-over-year, yet it drew the lowest audience among CBS dramas.
-
So Help Me Todd pulled about 6.2 million viewers and was down 3 % from its freshman season.
So even when the numbers aren’t disastrous, other factors weigh in.
Strategic Shuffling: Why Cancel When Ratings Are Not Horrible?
Legacy vs. Fresh Content
CBS talked about wanting to “keep the schedule fresh” and create stronger momentum. The execs pointed out that many shows returned strong after the strikes, so space became limited.
Franchise fatigue & brand focus
With the NCIS and CSI brands dominating for years, there’s an argument that newer entries may get squeezed. One exec said of CSI: “That franchise is alive and well and we continue to be in discussions.”
That suggests they might be thinking about fewer but bigger franchise installments instead of multiple spinoffs.
Cost structure & streaming pressure
Production costs for hour-long dramas keep climbing. At the same time streaming and platform metrics are more important than ever. Some shows may look better on paper than in streaming value-creation. While CBS didn’t share detailed cost numbers publicly, industry observers point to those factors. (See Reddit commentary for audience sentiment)
What Does This Mean for Each Show?
So Help Me Todd
The show’s profile and cancellation
So Help Me Todd ran for two seasons before CBS pulled the plug. Despite a loyal fanbase, CBS cited scheduling and flow concerns.
Is there hope for revival?
CBS indicated the experience was “wonderful,” and nothing rules out a pick-up elsewhere (“we had a wonderful experience… it was heartbreaking”).
Given the lighter tone and procedural format, it might have a chance on a streaming service or via syndication if a budget-friendly partner emerges.
Fan reaction & sentiment
Fans on Reddit lament the cancellation:
“Loved So Help Me Todd. It was smart and funny.”
This shows there’s emotional investment, which sometimes helps in revival campaigns.
CSI: Vegas
The show’s profile and cancellation
Now in its third season when cancelled, CSI: Vegas drew around 6.1 million viewers but was the lowest-performing CBS drama by that metric.
What the executives hinted
Amy Reisenbach said the franchise is “alive and well” and “we continue to be in discussions” — suggesting that while the current version ended, the CSI brand might persist in some form.
Possible directions forward
-
A streaming revival or a different network pickup
-
A limited-series or event special under the CSI banner
-
A shift in format (e.g., international spinoff)
All speculative, but the mention of “continue to be in discussions” keeps hope alive.
NCIS: Hawai’i
The show’s profile and cancellation
Despite showing growth (+4 % YoY to 7.81 million viewers), NCIS: Hawai’i was cancelled.
Executives’ messaging
Reisenbach acknowledged the fans’ disappointment but reiterated the job is about evaluating “future opportunities” and “momentum.”
Chief Cheeks added he had “a wonderful experience” working with the show.
Is there another chance?
Because the NCIS brand is key to CBS’s franchise strategy, there’s potential:
-
Maybe a spin-off or retooled version could spring up
-
Or maybe a streaming companion series or special
Still, no public commitment yet.
Broader Implications for TV Fans & the Industry
Networks must prioritize fewer, stronger shows
The cancellations suggest that even well-performing shows aren’t safe if the network believes there is a limited number of slots or budget. This is a wake-up call for showrunners and fans alike: “good enough” may no longer suffice.
The streaming factor is a heavy anchor
More than ever, networks care about streaming catch-up, global rights, platform metrics—not just live ratings. Some shows may be cancelled because their streaming-value-generation is lower than expected.
Franchise fatigue vs. brand value
Long-running brands like NCIS and CSI appear to be valuable—but the new spinoffs may struggle if they don’t differentiate sufficiently from the original. Networks might decide to consolidate to protect the brand rather than spread it thin.
Fan campaigns may help—but with limits
While fans can rally (#SaveSoHelpMeTodd, etc.), networks ultimately make decisions based on business metrics. Social media noise helps, but doesn’t always sway these outcomes.
What Could Come Next?
Possibility 1: Streaming or network pickup
Shows like So Help Me Todd might find a home on a streaming service or smaller network. With a lighter tone and loyal fanbase, it’s a candidate for rescue if the rights and budget align.
Possibility 2: Brand retooling
For CSI: Vegas and NCIS: Hawai’i, the parent brands could be reimagined:
-
A new location for NCIS
-
A spin-off series under the CSI umbrella
The execs’ comments about “the franchise is alive” support this possibility.
Possibility 3: Farewell seasons or limited specials
Even if full seasons don’t return, networks sometimes produce limited specials, wrap-up episodes or mini-series to give closure to loyal fans. That might be a realistic option.
What fans can do
-
Continue streaming or purchasing the existing seasons (to show value)
-
Engage with official social media campaigns
-
Rally together (but stay realistic about business constraints)
Why You Should Care as a Viewers
The shows you invest in aren’t guaranteed longevity
It’s easy to assume that if you like a show and it seems popular, it will stick around. These cancellations serve as reminders that even shows with solid numbers can end if they don’t align with broader network strategy.
Your viewing choices matter
When you stream, re-watch or buy episodes, you contribute to a show’s value. Networks increasingly look at those metrics—so your behavior does influence decisions (though it’s only one piece of the puzzle).
Fan loyalty has power—but not unlimited power
Fan outcry can raise visibility and maybe persuade networks or streaming platforms to pick up shows—but it doesn’t guarantee success. As one Reddit commenter put it:
“So Help Me Todd was such a comfort show… I hate this trend
Emotional investment is real, but the business side is harsh.
Frequently Asked Questions (Pre-Conclusion)
Were the cancellations a surprise?
To many fans yes—but in the context of industry shifts they’re less surprising. CBS had already signalled a desire to reshape its lineup and make more room for high-potential content. Executive comments confirm the decisions weren’t made lightly.
Do these cancellations mean the shows will never return?
Not necessarily. While CBS has ended them in their current form, the executives left the door open for possibilities such as streaming pickups or brand retooling. The franchise comments suggest at least CSI might find another path.
What about the original NCIS and CSI series?
It appears the core brands remain key to CBS’s strategy. While specific spinoffs were cancelled, the parent series and brand value remain strong. For example, CBS remains committed to the NCIS brand.
Are there any signs of a revival yet?
As of now, no formal revival has been announced for these shows. The execs’ comments suggest possibility, not guarantee. Fans and industry watchers should monitor future announcements.
What can fans do to help?
-
Watch existing episodes (legally) to increase streaming/monetary value.
-
Engage positively on social media (but avoid toxic campaigns).
-
Support the show creators, casts and networks by showing commitment—but also be realistic about cancellation risks.
Conclusion
When you’re invested in a TV show, hearing it gets cancelled feels personal. The endings of So Help Me Todd, CSI: Vegas and NCIS: Hawai’i underscore how complex television programming has become: it’s not just about ratings or fan love—it’s about budget, streaming value, brand strategy, schedule flow, and platform metrics.
The good news? There is still hope. CBS executives haven’t ruled out alternate futures, especially for the big franchise brands. But you should also accept the reality that many shows—even good ones—won’t survive in their current form. As viewers, our role is shifting: our streaming habits, engagement, and platform choices matter more than ever.
For now, keep watching, keep sharing, and keep advocating—but stay gritty. Networks may change, platforms may shift—but your fandom can make a difference.
