A Shocking Departure From Chicago Fire
In October 2021, fans of NBC’s Chicago Fire were stunned when Jesse Spencer announced his exit from the long-running series. As Matthew Casey, Spencer had been a pillar of the show since its very first episode, making his departure after 200 episodes a game-changer for the One Chicago universe.
Though Spencer has since returned as a guest star, his farewell in season 10 marked one of the show’s most emotional shifts. For co-stars and fans alike, saying goodbye to an original cast member was no easy task—and David Eigenberg, who plays Christopher Hermann, has now shed light on how the cast handled those bittersweet final moments.
David Eigenberg Shares a Heartfelt Memory
Speaking on the One Chicago Podcast with producer Brian Luce, Eigenberg recalled a quirky but deeply meaningful send-off tradition that took place when Spencer left.
During downtime on set, the cast had often entertained themselves by playing “water bottle ball”—a silly game involving an empty bottle kicked between friends. When the time came to film Spencer’s farewell, that lighthearted tradition returned in a surprising way.
Eigenberg described how the cast huddled together for a group hug, only for someone to drop a water bottle into the circle. What followed was an impromptu round of their beloved game—this time infused with tears, laughter, and the weight of goodbye.
“It was like little tears and stuff like that,” Eigenberg said, reflecting on the moment. “It didn’t belong in the show, but it belonged to us.”
Matthew Casey’s Story After Leaving
Spencer’s character, Matthew Casey, left Chicago to move to Oregon, creating a noticeable gap in the firehouse family. Yet the writers have made sure Casey’s presence is still felt.
Since his official farewell in season 10, Casey has appeared almost once a season. He returned for the season 10 finale, popped up in season 11, and had multiple appearances in season 12. These guest spots allow Spencer to provide closure for fans while also keeping Casey’s connection to the team alive.
For a series that thrives on camaraderie, his recurring role helps maintain the emotional core of the show—even as new departures loom.
The Impact on Cast and Fans
Eigenberg’s story highlights more than just a quirky behind-the-scenes ritual—it reflects the genuine bond shared by the Chicago Fire cast. That bond is part of what has made the series resonate for over a decade.
Spencer’s exit was one of several notable departures from the One Chicago franchise, but his willingness to return demonstrates his continued commitment to the team and the fans who’ve supported him since day one.
As Eigenberg explained, the water bottle game wasn’t about the show itself, but about the friendships formed behind the camera—proof that the One Chicago family extends well beyond what fans see on screen.
What’s Next for Chicago Fire
Chicago Fire season 14 returns to NBC on Wednesday, October 1, at 9 PM ET. But once again, fans will be forced to say goodbye, this time to Jake Lockett’s Sam Carver. Just like Spencer’s departure, the show will have to adapt to losing a core character.
Still, if the past is any indication, the series will lean on its tight-knit ensemble, both on-screen and off, to weather the change. With Casey’s occasional returns, the door remains open for more emotional reunions in future episodes.
