The NCIS franchise has been a powerhouse on television for two decades, launching hit spinoffs like NCIS: Los Angeles, NCIS: New Orleans, and the most recent NCIS: Hawai’i. But as Season 23 of the flagship series unfolds, fans are beginning to ask a controversial question: Did CBS choose the wrong leader to carry the torch in its spinoff strategy?
In this article, we’ll break down the rising debate, look at character choices, explore fan reactions, and dig into how NCIS Season 23 is reshaping the legacy of this legendary franchise.
The Long Reign of NCIS on TV
From JAG to Global Phenomenon
What started as a backdoor pilot from JAG has turned into one of television’s most successful franchises. NCIS has aired over 20 seasons, spawning several spinoffs across different cities.
Why Leadership Matters in NCIS
Each spinoff has relied on a strong central figure. Mark Harmon’s Gibbs set the gold standard—tough, loyal, and morally grounded. Leaders define tone, and fans either buy into their story… or they don’t.
Season 23’s Leadership Spotlight
A Shift in Focus
Season 23 highlights characters who were once secondary but are now stepping into leadership positions. While this keeps the show fresh, it also highlights gaps in CBS’s spinoff strategy.
The Wrong Pick?
The franchise may have bet on the wrong horse when developing its last spinoff. Some fans argue another character—currently thriving in Season 23—should have been handed the reins instead.
The Case for Torres as a Spinoff Leader
Nick Torres: From Lone Wolf to Leader
Wilmer Valderrama’s Nick Torres has grown tremendously. He started as a reckless agent but has evolved into a strong, emotionally complex figure.
Fan Momentum
Fans online are buzzing about Torres, many suggesting he could have carried a spinoff with ease. Season 23 is showcasing his leadership skills—skills CBS overlooked when pushing NCIS: Hawai’i.
Why Knight Could Have Worked
Jessica Knight’s Rising Popularity
Katrina Law’s Knight is another fan favorite. Sharp, witty, and emotionally grounded, she has quickly won audiences over.
A Missed Opportunity
Her character development in Season 23 makes it clear she could have anchored her own series, perhaps even more effectively than Jane Tennant (NCIS: Hawai’i).
NCIS: Hawai’i’s Leadership Struggles
Jane Tennant’s Mixed Reception
While Vanessa Lachey’s Jane Tennant broke barriers as the first female Special Agent in Charge in the NCIS franchise, fan reception has been divided. Some appreciate the bold direction, while others feel her character hasn’t reached Gibbs-level gravitas.
Comparisons to Gibbs, Pride, and Callen
It’s tough to live up to legends like Gibbs (NCIS), Dwayne Pride (NCIS: New Orleans), and G. Callen (NCIS: Los Angeles). Tennant hasn’t resonated in the same way, making fans question CBS’s leadership choice.
The Power of Fan Perception
Social Media Backlash
Twitter, Reddit, and Facebook discussions show clear divides. Many argue Season 23 proves Torres or Knight could’ve led a spinoff that fans would instantly rally behind.
Ratings Reflection
Although NCIS: Hawai’i isn’t a flop, its ratings never matched the explosive success of NCIS: LA or NCIS: New Orleans. Leadership could be the missing piece.
The Legacy of Leroy Jethro Gibbs
Gibbs as the Benchmark
Mark Harmon’s Gibbs wasn’t just a leader—he was the backbone of NCIS. Every spinoff has tried to replicate that balance of grit, wisdom, and humanity.
The Leadership Gap
Season 23 highlights how few characters have truly filled Gibbs’ shoes. That contrast is making fans more critical of CBS’s spinoff choices.
Season 23 Storylines Fueling the Debate
Torres’ Redemption Arc
Torres’ storyline about personal redemption and loyalty to the team is drawing praise. It’s the type of narrative that could anchor an entire spinoff.
Knight’s Tactical Brilliance
Knight continues to prove she’s more than a supporting character. Her strategies and bold decision-making scream “team leader.”
Spinoff Success vs. Spinoff Struggles
NCIS: LA – A Gold Standard
With Callen and Sam at the helm, NCIS: Los Angeles thrived for 14 seasons. Strong leadership drove the storytelling.
NCIS: New Orleans – Steady but Safe
Scott Bakula’s Pride gave authenticity, even if the series never quite hit NCIS: LA highs.
NCIS: Hawai’i – Still Finding Its Footing
Despite strong representation, leadership hasn’t connected with audiences in the same way. Season 23 makes that more obvious.
Why Leadership Makes or Breaks a Spinoff
Leadership isn’t just about being the boss—it’s about charisma, chemistry, and vision. Without that, even a well-written series can feel hollow.
Could CBS Course-Correct?
Future Spinoff Potential
Season 23 could inspire CBS to rethink its strategy. If Torres or Knight continues to shine, there’s room for another NCIS expansion.
A Franchise Always Evolving
NCIS has survived cast changes, cancellations, and shifts in leadership before. If CBS made a misstep, there’s still time to correct it.
What Fans Really Want
At the end of the day, fans crave authenticity. They want leaders who feel real, flawed, and inspiring. Season 23 is reminding viewers who truly has those qualities.
Conclusion
NCIS Season 23 isn’t just another season—it’s a wake-up call. It’s proving that CBS may have picked the wrong leader for its latest spinoff. With Torres and Knight stepping into the spotlight and resonating deeply with fans, it’s becoming clear that the franchise has untapped potential leaders waiting for their chance.
The NCIS universe thrives on strong characters and compelling leadership. If CBS listens to its audience, the next spinoff could be the one that brings the franchise back to its golden era.
FAQs
1. Who is the current leader in NCIS: Hawai’i?
Jane Tennant, played by Vanessa Lachey, is the Special Agent in Charge and the first female lead in the NCIS franchise.
2. Why do fans think Torres could lead a spinoff?
Torres’ emotional growth, leadership qualities, and popularity make him a standout character in Season 23.
3. Has NCIS made spinoff mistakes before?
Not major ones, but some spinoffs have performed better than others—largely due to leadership and character chemistry.
4. Could NCIS still launch another spinoff?
Yes, CBS could easily develop another spinoff focusing on Torres, Knight, or even both as co-leads.
5. What makes Gibbs such an iconic leader?
Gibbs combined toughness, empathy, and moral clarity—qualities fans feel newer leaders haven’t fully captured.
