Could This Is Us Stars Reunite in Tracker Season 4? Here’s What Fans Are Hoping For

Television fans love a good crossover, and lately, there’s been a buzz about whether the beloved cast of This Is Us could make an appearance in CBS’s hit series Tracker. The thought of seeing Milo Ventimiglia, Mandy Moore, Sterling K. Brown, and the rest of the Pearson family cross paths with Colter Shaw (played by Justin Hartley) feels like the kind of television magic that would break the internet.

But is it possible? And why does the idea resonate so strongly with fans? Let’s dig deep into the possibilities, the fan theories, and what a reunion could mean for both shows.

Why the Idea of a Crossover Feels So Perfect

Fans aren’t pulling this thought out of thin air. This Is Us wrapped up with an emotional finale that left many viewers craving more time with the cast. Meanwhile, Justin Hartley, who played Kevin Pearson on This Is Us, has taken the lead in Tracker, bringing his charisma and charm to an entirely new role.

So naturally, the idea of seeing his old co-stars alongside him again has everyone buzzing.

A Look Back: Justin Hartley’s Journey From Kevin Pearson to Colter Shaw

• On This Is Us, Justin Hartley made audiences laugh, cry, and feel deeply with his portrayal of Kevin Pearson, a man constantly striving for meaning and belonging.

• Now, as Colter Shaw in Tracker, he’s embodying a lone wolf—a survivalist who helps people in exchange for reward money.

The transition showcases Hartley’s range. Bringing his former castmates into his new world would feel like a nod to fans who followed his journey from NBC to CBS.

Which This Is Us Actors Could Realistically Appear in Tracker?

Not every actor may fit into Tracker’s tone, but some seem like a perfect match:

Milo Ventimiglia (Jack Pearson)

Milo has experience in drama, action, and mystery (Heroes, Gilmore Girls). He could slide into Tracker as a mentor figure, rival tracker, or even a mysterious client.

Mandy Moore (Rebecca Pearson)

Though Rebecca was the emotional heart of This Is Us, Mandy has the chops to play a strong, independent character in Tracker. Imagine her as a determined investigator or someone from Colter’s past.

Sterling K. Brown (Randall Pearson)

Sterling has already proven his versatility. In Tracker, he could embody a lawyer, government agent, or high-stakes adversary for Colter.

Chrissy Metz (Kate Pearson)

Chrissy could bring warmth and depth. As a client in need, her appearance would instantly tug at viewers’ heartstrings.

How a Crossover Could Work

The beauty of Tracker is its case-of-the-week structure. Each episode introduces new characters, making it easy to slot in guest stars without derailing the bigger narrative.

Picture this: Colter Shaw takes on a missing persons case. The family hiring him? Played by none other than Milo Ventimiglia and Mandy Moore. Fans would instantly connect, and social media would explode with nostalgia.

Would Fans Actually Tune In For This?

Absolutely. Nostalgia is one of the most powerful forces in entertainment. Just look at how Friends, Gilmore Girls, and Fuller House reunions broke viewing records.

A crossover or reunion episode would not only draw This Is Us fans back to the screen but also introduce Tracker to viewers who may not have given it a shot yet.

Network and Production Realities

Of course, it’s not as simple as waving a magic wand. This Is Us aired on NBC, while Tracker is a CBS property. Cross-network collaborations aren’t common, but they’re not impossible either. It usually comes down to contracts, schedules, and fan demand.

Given the buzz online, the networks may at least consider it.

Why Season 4 Seems Like the Right Time

Tracker is still finding its groove. By Season 4, the show will likely have a well-established audience, strong ratings, and more room to take creative risks. That’s often when series experiment with bigger guest stars and crossover ideas.

So, if we’re going to see This Is Us alumni, Season 4 feels like the sweet spot.

The Emotional Impact of a Reunion

Fans of This Is Us didn’t just connect with the story—they connected with the family. Seeing those familiar faces again, even in different roles, would stir up emotions and bring back that bittersweet mix of joy and nostalgia.

Think of it as a TV comfort meal—something that feels familiar yet excitingly new.

Justin Hartley’s Perspective

Justin has often spoken fondly about his time on This Is Us. While he’s focused on building Tracker, he’s never shied away from acknowledging the bond with his castmates. If given the chance, it’s hard to imagine him saying no to a reunion.

The Social Media Buzz Factor

In today’s landscape, a single episode featuring a mini This Is Us reunion could dominate Twitter, TikTok, and Instagram. Fans would share clips, memes, and emotional reactions for weeks. That kind of organic buzz is priceless for a TV show.

Would It Be a One-Time Thing or Recurring Guest Spots?

There are two ways this could play out:

• One-time reunion episode: A special treat for fans, full of nostalgia.

• Recurring guest stars: Certain actors return over multiple episodes, weaving into Colter’s world more deeply.

Either approach would thrill fans.

Potential Storylines For Guest Appearances

• A Lost Family Member: One of the Pearson actors hires Colter to find someone who vanished.

• A Dangerous Adversary: Sterling K. Brown as a high-stakes rival who challenges Colter’s methods.

• An Emotional Rescue: Chrissy Metz as a desperate parent seeking help.

• A Mentor Figure: Milo Ventimiglia guiding Colter through a tough personal decision.

Could This Be The Beginning of a Trend?

If successful, this could inspire more TV reunions across genres. Imagine seeing stars from shows like Parenthood or Friday Night Lights pop up in new series led by their former co-stars.

Television thrives on nostalgia, and this could set a new standard for keeping fans engaged long after a show ends.

Final Thoughts: Will It Happen?

For now, the idea of This Is Us stars joining Tracker Season 4 is just fan speculation. But sometimes, fan speculation turns into reality—especially when the demand is this strong.

Whether it’s a full-blown reunion or just a couple of cameo appearances, the possibility alone has fans excited. And in the world of television, excitement is everything.

Conclusion

Bringing This Is Us actors into Tracker Season 4 isn’t just a fun idea—it’s a smart move that could benefit both the show and the fans. It would blend nostalgia with fresh storytelling, boost ratings, and create the kind of TV moment people talk about for years. While nothing is confirmed, the buzz proves one thing: audiences aren’t ready to say goodbye to the Pearsons just yet.

FAQs

1. Has there been any official announcement about This Is Us actors joining Tracker?
No official confirmation yet, but fans are eagerly hoping for it.

2. Would cross-network issues make this difficult?
Yes, since This Is Us was on NBC and Tracker is on CBS, but special deals could make it possible.

3. Why is Season 4 the most talked-about possibility?
By then, Tracker will be established and more open to experimental casting and storylines.

4. Which This Is Us actor is most likely to appear?
Milo Ventimiglia and Sterling K. Brown seem like natural fits, but any cast member could bring excitement.

5. How would fans react to a crossover?
Most would celebrate—nostalgia plus Justin Hartley’s current popularity equals guaranteed buzz.