As reported by Deadline’s sister site, TVLine, yesterday, the Justin Hartley vehicle saw the departures of series regulars Eric Graise (computer expert Bobby Exley) and Abby McEnany (business handler Velma Bruin), leaving Hartley’s one-man-operation Colter Shaw and Fiona Rene’s lawyer Reenie Green as the sole stars going into Season 3. (Fellow original cast member Robin Weigert, who portrayed Velma’s wife Teddi Bruin, as well as the backend of Colter’s operation, left the series after Season 1.) Based on the bestselling novel The Never Game by Jeffery Deaver, Tracker stars Hartley as Colter Shaw, “a lone-wolf survivalist who roams the country as a reward seeker, using his expert tracking skills to help private citizens and law enforcement solve all manner of mysteries while contending with his own fractured family,” per the official logline.
The series has been a major draw for the network, landing in the Top 5 of Nielsen’s 35-day most-watched shows across all streaming and linear series, alongside fellow standout Matlock, back in May. Per CBS data, the show is also No. 1 in broadcast. Tracker was renewed by CBS alongside other drama and ratings mainstays Elsbeth, Fire Country and its three NCIS series back in February. In the dramatic conclusion to Season 2, Colter finally uncovered the mystery man behind his father’s killer, but not without unfolding a series of questions, including his mother’s involvement in the death. The drama is produced by 20th Television, with Deaver producing alongside EPs Hartley, Ken Olin, Elwood Reid, Connie Dolphin, Sharon Lee Watson and Alex Katsnelson.
The Calm Before the Storm
Change is in the air over at CBS. Just as fans of Tracker were eagerly awaiting what Season 3 would bring, the network dropped a bombshell: series regulars Eric Graise and Abby McEnany will not be returning. And let’s be honest—that’s a pretty big deal. In this deep-dive, we’ll break down why this matters, what might’ve caused it, and how it could shape the future of this beloved show. So buckle up, because the Tracker train is shifting tracks.
What Is CBS’ ‘Tracker’ All About?
A Quick Recap for the Uninitiated
If you’re new to the party, Tracker is a hit procedural drama that first aired on CBS, centered around Colter Shaw, a skilled lone-wolf tracker who solves crimes and rescues people in danger. The show blends suspense, mystery, and emotional grit into each episode, building a loyal fan base since its debut.
Who Are Eric Graise and Abby McEnany?
Eric Graise: The Standout Fan Favorite
Eric Graise, who played Bobby Exley, brought heart, humor, and depth to the series. As a tech-savvy, wheelchair-using operations coordinator, Bobby was more than just comic relief—he was the brains behind Shaw’s missions.
Abby McEnany: The Unapologetically Bold Character
Abby McEnany portrayed Velma, the sharp, slightly eccentric communications expert. She added a unique flavor to the team dynamic, providing levity and perspective.
The Big Exit: What We Know So Far
The Official Announcement
CBS confirmed that Graise and McEnany won’t be returning as series regulars in Season 3. While no specific reason was given publicly, the network thanked them for their contributions and hinted that their stories may not be completely over.
No Drama—At Least Publicly
There’s been no mention of behind-the-scenes drama, which leaves the door open to speculation. Contract negotiations? Creative changes? A shift in narrative focus? All plausible.
What This Means for ‘Tracker’ Season 3
A Leaner Cast, A Tighter Storyline?
Removing two major players could signal a new narrative direction. Could the series be aiming for a darker tone or more serialized storytelling? It wouldn’t be the first time a show changed lanes mid-run.
Potential New Characters Incoming
In TV land, exits usually mean fresh faces. Season 3 might introduce new team members—or lean harder into existing ones. That creates both risk and opportunity.
The Strategic Reason Behind the Cast Changes
Network Efficiency: Budget Reallocation
Let’s face it—money talks. CBS might be tightening the budget, especially if they’re investing more in production value or bringing on new talent. Cutting regulars can help shift those resources.
Plot Evolution: Story Arcs Completed
It’s also possible that Graise’s and McEnany’s story arcs have run their course. Showrunners often write characters out to give the plot room to grow.
Fan Reactions: Mixed But Vocal
Twitter and Reddit Are On Fire
Fans took to social media with mixed emotions. Some expressed disappointment, especially about Bobby’s departure, while others are cautiously optimistic.
“Bobby was the heart of the show. I’m not sure how I feel about this…” — @trackerfan90
Petitions, Memes, and Theories Galore
Yep, there are already change.org petitions calling for their return. Fandoms don’t take change lightly—and Tracker fans are no exception.
What’s Next for Eric Graise and Abby McEnany?
Bright Futures Ahead
Both actors have strong reputations and growing fanbases. Graise has hinted at future projects that focus on accessibility and inclusion, while McEnany continues to be a fierce advocate for LGBTQ+ representation in Hollywood.
Could They Return as Guest Stars?
Never say never. CBS left the door cracked open. Whether in flashbacks, cameos, or a surprise storyline twist, their return isn’t entirely out of the question.
Behind-The-Scenes Shifts: Showrunner Decisions
Creative Redirection at the Top
There’s buzz that the Tracker writers’ room is undergoing a shake-up. New showrunners or executive producers often bring a vision that doesn’t include every original cast member.
Connecting the Dots: Clues Hidden in Season 2
Subtle Send-Offs?
Re-watch the latter half of Season 2 and you’ll notice softer focus on Bobby and Velma. Some are now interpreting those storylines as a gentle goodbye.
Industry Experts Weigh In
Is This Just the Nature of TV?
Absolutely. Long-running shows often evolve. Cast changes can be bittersweet but necessary. Think of it as pruning a tree—it hurts, but it helps new branches grow.
What Fans Should Watch For in Season 3
-
New character intros in Episode 1
-
A more streamlined operations team
-
Possibly darker, more intense themes
-
Callbacks to Bobby or Velma in passing dialogue
Could This Actually Be Good for the Show?
Believe it or not—yes. While fans are attached to familiar faces, shaking up the cast could bring fresh energy and new dynamics. It’s a risk, but sometimes a calculated one.
Lessons in Representation and Inclusion
Eric Graise represented visible disability on a major network drama. His exit is not just a casting change—it’s a cultural moment. The industry needs to keep pushing for diversity in meaningful roles, not just one-offs.
Final Thoughts: Every Ending Starts a New Chapter
Characters come and go, but great stories adapt. While Eric Graise and Abby McEnany will surely be missed, Tracker now has the challenge—and opportunity—to evolve. Let’s see where this road leads.
