Losing Bobby and Velma isn’t just a missed opportunity narratively, but it’s also a step backward in terms of representation. Eric Graise, a disabled actor and bilateral amputee, brought sharp wit and authenticity to Bobby’s character without ever slipping into a stereotype. Abby McEnany, the show’s only queer character, gave Velma a laid-back cool and dry humor that made her instantly memorable. In an era when audiences are asking for more inclusive, fully realized characters, letting go of two voices like theirs especially without giving them proper development, feels like a misstep.
There’s still time for Tracker to course-correct. Fiona Rene’s Reenie Green became a standout in the latter half of Season 2, as the show finally gave her more to do and allowed her legal work to take center stage. Rene and Hartley share great on-screen chemistry, and there’s real potential for a more emotionally layered dynamic if the writers choose to explore it. If Tracker leans into that relationship and continues developing the broader mystery around Colter’s family, it could finally build the stronger emotional core the series has been missing.
Still, Bobby and Velma had the potential to be more than background support and they could’ve become the foundation for a grounded, recurring team around Colter. Their presence offered a chance to challenge his lone-wolf mentality and show that while he can do everything on his own, he doesn’t have to. That kind of dynamic would’ve added richness and contrast to Colter’s worldview. Instead, they were written out before they had a chance to fully grow.
In the end, their exits may make sense within the show’s current structure, but that doesn’t make them any less frustrating. The best procedurals allow their characters to evolve alongside the cases. Tracker has the star power, the success, and the potential to go deeper. It’s just unfortunate that it will have to do so without two fan-favorite characters who clearly deserved more.
A Shake-Up No One Asked For
If you’ve been riding along with Colter Shaw on Tracker, then you know how crucial chemistry and compelling characters are to the show’s success. But Season 3 brought an unexpected curveball: Bobby Exley and Velma are out.
Wait, what? Yep, you read that right.
The decision to remove Bobby (played by Eric Graise) and Velma (played by Fiona Rene) from the storyline isn’t just surprising—it’s a major misstep. These two added depth, balance, and charm to a series that relies heavily on one man’s mission. So, let’s break down exactly why losing them is a huge missed opportunity for Tracker Season 3.
Who Are Bobby and Velma?
Bobby Exley – The Brain Behind the Mission
Bobby isn’t just Colter’s tech guy—he’s the lifeline behind the laptop. Whether he’s tracking a suspect’s digital footprint or feeding Colter real-time updates, Bobby’s value is more than functional. He’s quirky, clever, and emotionally grounded.
Velma – The Voice of Balance
Velma, Colter’s sister and therapist, brought emotional nuance and a much-needed grounding presence. She wasn’t just his family—she was his moral compass and personal anchor in a chaotic world of chasing criminals.
The Fallout: What Their Departure Means
Less Depth in Storytelling
Without Velma’s emotional insight and Bobby’s digital expertise, the storytelling could lose its multi-layered impact. We’re left with more action but less heart.
Repetitive Plotlines Loom
Losing core team members often forces writers to recycle old tropes or stretch the protagonist too thin. Without contrasting voices like Bobby and Velma, Colter risks becoming a one-note hero.
Reduced Representation
Let’s be real: Bobby and Velma offered diverse representation that resonated with many viewers. Their presence wasn’t just symbolic—it was authentic and relatable.
Why They Were Irreplaceable
Essential Puzzle Pieces
Bobby and Velma weren’t just sidekicks—they were narrative tools. Bobby could find a criminal hiding on the dark web in 10 seconds flat. Velma helped Colter work through trauma, which is a goldmine for character development.
Dialogue Chemistry Was Gold
The snappy banter between Colter and Bobby or the grounded heart-to-hearts with Velma added flavor. Now, without them, there’s a noticeable gap in tone and energy.
Emotional Layers Made It Human
What makes Tracker binge-worthy isn’t just the chase—it’s the human stakes. Bobby and Velma peeled back Colter’s armor in a way no one else could.
Common Misconceptions About Supporting Roles
“They’re Just Background Characters” – Nope.
Bobby and Velma weren’t just there for filler. They actively drove the plot forward, influenced decisions, and made Colter more than just a guy with a mission.
“New Characters Can Replace Them” – Can They, Though?
Maybe they’ll try bringing in new faces. But the real question is—can chemistry be replicated? That’s a tall order.
The Impact on Viewership and Fan Loyalty
Fans Are Already Speaking Out
Twitter, Reddit, Facebook—fans are not staying quiet. The common thread? “Where are Bobby and Velma?” This kind of buzz isn’t good buzz.
Risk of Dropping Engagement
Characters like Bobby and Velma create emotional attachment, and when you rip them away, you risk losing not just plot depth—but loyal viewers.
Missed Creative Opportunities
Bobby-Centered Episodes Could’ve Thrived
Imagine a standalone Bobby episode where he’s forced into the field? Or maybe a deep dive into his past? Those stories had endless potential.
Velma Could’ve Explored Mental Health Themes
Velma’s background opens doors to real conversations about PTSD, grief, and family dynamics. All of that’s gone now.
Behind-the-Scenes Choices: Business or Blunder?
Was this decision based on budget cuts? Creative redirection? Either way, the cost is bigger than money—it’s about creative integrity and audience connection.
What the Writers Can Still Do
Bring Them Back (Even Temporarily)
Maybe not full-time, but recurring roles or guest appearances could ease the sting. Fans would love to see Bobby or Velma show up in a pinch.
Acknowledge Their Absence Properly
Don’t just brush it off with a throwaway line. Give them a respectful narrative send-off that honors their impact.
Lessons for Future Seasons
Build the Core Team—Don’t Dismantle It
The key to longevity in shows like Tracker is having a strong ensemble cast. Colter can’t carry the emotional and intellectual load all by himself forever.
Listen to Fan Feedback
Your audience isn’t just watching—they’re invested. Ignoring their feedback is like ignoring your compass during a manhunt.
Final Thoughts: A Costly Gamble
Removing Bobby and Velma from Tracker Season 3 feels like a decision made in a vacuum. It’s not just a casting change—it’s a creative regression. The show had an opportunity to evolve with these characters, but now it’s chosen a lonelier, narrower path.
And while Colter may still find the missing people, Tracker might have lost something—and someone—irreplaceable.
