As CBS eyes a second spinoff of The Rookie, lessons from The Rookie: Feds must be learned. Here’s what went wrong—and how the new series can avoid the same fate.
The Rookie’s Second Spinoff Has Huge Potential—But It Must Avoid This One Major Mistake
With The Rookie franchise continuing to expand, buzz is building around a second spinoff that promises to bring fresh characters and high-stakes drama to the universe. But as fans and producers reflect on the short-lived The Rookie: Feds, one thing is clear: if this new show wants to survive, it can’t repeat the same mistake.
What Went Wrong with Feds?
The Rookie: Feds, despite its promising premise and strong lead in Niecy Nash-Betts, struggled to find its footing. While the show had a loyal fanbase and shared the same DNA as its predecessor, it failed to deliver the same grounded storytelling and emotional stakes that made The Rookie a hit. Viewers felt the tone was inconsistent, the characters underdeveloped, and the action lacked urgency.
Ultimately, the series couldn’t sustain long-term interest, leading to its early cancellation. It’s a cautionary tale for any new spinoff hoping to ride the success of a franchise without carving its own unique space.
What the New Spinoff Needs to Get Right
To avoid a similar fate, the second spinoff needs to focus on a few key elements:
-
Authentic Characters: Audiences connected with John Nolan and Chenford because they felt real. The next spinoff must prioritize deep, relatable character development over flash.
-
Grounded Storytelling: While high-stakes drama is essential, it needs to be rooted in emotional truth. Over-the-top plots without payoff won’t work.
-
A Clear Identity: The spinoff must stand on its own. Leaning too heavily on The Rookie name without building its own tone, theme, and purpose will only weaken its impact.
-
Consistent Tone: Unlike Feds, which struggled with tonal shifts, this new series must establish whether it’s character-driven drama, action procedural, or something else—and stick to it.
A Fresh Setting Could Be the Key
There are rumors that the second spinoff will take place in a more rural, small-town setting—a bold contrast to the urban environments of The Rookie and Feds. This change could give the show a distinct feel and allow it to explore themes of community, resource limitations, and underdog policing that resonate with new audiences.
Final Thoughts
The Rookie franchise has the potential to grow into a long-lasting universe, but the next spinoff must learn from the missteps of Feds. With the right balance of originality, character depth, and grounded storytelling, the new series could be the breakout hit fans have been waiting for. The spotlight is on—now it just has to get it right.
