
Three months after NCIS: Hawai’i was canceled, showrunners Jan Nash, Christopher Silber and Matt Bosack are opening up about how they were “obviously surprised” by the show’s untimely ending. The showrunners shared in a joint email Q&A with TVLine that they would have ended the island spinoff’s third season differently if they had known the show wasn’t returning to CBS.
“If we’d known it was coming, we probably wouldn’t have ended the series on a cliffhanger,” they explained. “The fact that the studio and the network didn’t stop us makes it seem like they might not have seen it coming either. We loved our show and know other people loved it, too, but the TV business is a fickle mistress and one can’t take business decisions personally. But it still stings.” Despite the surprise, the trio said there is “a lot to be proud of” from the experience of making the CBS procedural, which starred Vanessa Lachey.
“We did what we set out to do. We created a show with a strong female lead and a cast that reflected the diversity of Hawai’i and the world. We told interesting Navy crime stories,” they said. “All while maintaining a workplace where people could hopefully do their best work and be valued for it.”
As fans may recall, season 3 of NCIS: Hawai’i concluded with Maggie (Julie White) telling Jane (Lachey), “Janie, you’re probably going to need a drink for what’s coming next” in the final moments of what would become the series finale. Nash, Silber and Bosack say the conclusion of the cliffhanger was not yet “not fully fleshed out.”
“We had a general idea of where the Maggie story was going,” they explained. “It would have eventually intersected with Jane Tennant’s mother, but it was also going to move back into the dark world of Tennant’s spy past, using those stories to increase our understanding of who Jane was, but also to learn more about her team in the process.”
The showrunners added that they were excited to continue telling stories on the show, saying, “We loved our repertoire of characters and we would have kept using them as much as we could. We were talking about Tennant’s mom and Ernie’s ex-wife, but other than following up on our cliffhanger, there were no ‘musts’ on the list.” “Our goals every season were the same: tells good stories with these great actors,” they added.
When NCIS: Hawai’i was canceled in 2024 after just three seasons, fans were shocked—and frankly, so were the people behind the scenes. The showrunners, Jan Nash and Matt Bosack, recently opened up about the show’s sudden end, calling the cancellation “painful” and “unexpected.” And now, in a bittersweet reveal, they’ve shared what could have been in a fourth season—leaving fans with a deeper sense of loss and longing.
What Led to the Cancellation of NCIS: Hawai’i?
Ratings vs. Reality
Despite a solid fanbase and decent ratings, NCIS: Hawai’i met its end as part of a broader network reshuffle. CBS made the tough decision as they pivoted toward cost-saving strategies and rebalanced their programming slate.
The Unseen Toll on the Creative Team
Behind the cameras, the news hit hard. According to Nash and Bosack, the show wasn’t just a job—it was a passion project. They built a vibrant, diverse cast and told stories set in a location rarely seen in procedural dramas.
“Still Stings”: The Emotional Aftermath
Raw Reflections from the Showrunners
“We had so much more to explore,” Bosack confessed. Nash echoed the sentiment, saying, “It still stings. We had more stories. The characters were just beginning to blossom.”
Cast Reactions That Broke Hearts
Vanessa Lachey, who played Jane Tennant—the first female lead in an NCIS franchise—shared her heartbreak too, posting tearful tributes and thanking fans for the ride.
What Would’ve Happened in NCIS: Hawai’i Season 4?
New Threats, Bigger Stakes
Season 4 was set to raise the stakes with a multi-episode arc involving international espionage and a major cyberattack aimed at Pacific naval operations.
Jane Tennant’s Character Arc
We were going to see Jane grappling with choices between her career and her family. Her leadership would have been tested in ways we hadn’t seen before.
More Crossovers Were in the Works
Another major crossover event with NCIS and NCIS: Sydney was in development—hinting at a larger, interconnected NCIS universe.
Untold Storylines That Will Haunt Fans
Kai’s Hidden Past
Kanoa Goo’s character, Kai, was set to confront his father’s criminal ties, something teased in Season 3 but never fully resolved.
Lucy and Whistler’s Relationship Growth
Fans of the beloved LGBTQ+ couple Lucy and Whistler were in for a treat—plans included a deeper dive into their relationship, including talks of marriage and future planning.
Ernie’s Hero Moment
Scene-stealer Ernie (Jason Antoon) was finally going to have a front-line mission that showed he’s more than just tech support.
The Island That Became a Character
Oʻahu Was More Than a Backdrop
The setting of Hawai’i wasn’t just beautiful—it was symbolic. It represented cultural depth, community bonds, and a unique flavor that separated NCIS: Hawai’i from the rest of the franchise.
Behind-the-Scenes Gold That We’ll Never See
Unfilmed Scripts and Ideas
Nash revealed that multiple scripts were already completed for Season 4. One involved a hostage situation aboard a U.S. Navy submarine.
Character Exits and Entrances
Season 4 would have introduced a new intelligence officer—someone who would clash with Tennant and challenge team dynamics.
Why NCIS: Hawai’i Mattered More Than Ratings
Representation on Primetime TV
Having a woman of color lead a major network procedural was groundbreaking. Lachey’s role inspired many and opened doors for future roles like hers.
Cultural Sensitivity and Respect
The writers took care to reflect Hawaiian culture with authenticity—consulting local advisors and integrating native customs and language into episodes.
What Fans Are Doing to Save the Show
Petitions and Campaigns
Multiple fan petitions are circulating online, some collecting over 100,000 signatures urging CBS or a streaming service to revive the show.
#SaveNCISHawaii Trending
Social media campaigns like #SaveNCISHawaii and #MahaloNCISHawaii continue to trend, proving the fanbase isn’t giving up without a fight.
Could NCIS: Hawai’i Be Revived?
There’s Still Hope
Nash and Bosack aren’t ruling anything out. They’ve expressed openness to continuing the story—either as a limited series, spinoff, or even a streaming movie.
The Legacy Lives On
A Franchise That Keeps Evolving
While NCIS: Hawai’i may be off the air, its impact is lasting. It added depth, representation, and heart to the long-running NCIS universe.
Lessons from the Cancellation
No Show Is Safe
In today’s TV landscape, even popular shows can be axed unexpectedly. The industry is shifting, and fan engagement matters more than ever.
Storytelling Still Matters
What made NCIS: Hawai’i stand out wasn’t just the action—it was the humanity behind the badges. The stories will stick with fans long after the final episode aired.
The Emotional Goodbye We Didn’t Get
The show never got a true finale. No send-off. No closure. That’s what makes the sting so sharp. But maybe, just maybe, that open door means the story isn’t over yet.
Conclusion: Aloha, But Not Farewell
NCIS: Hawai’i left us too soon, but the passion from the cast, creators, and fans proves that its story isn’t over—it’s just paused. Whether through a revival, a spinoff, or something entirely new, the legacy of this unique show continues to ripple across the sea of television.