TV Heartbreak Ahead: Which Fall 2025 Exit Will Shatter Fans the Most?

9-1-1 will be entering its first full season without its captain, Bobby Nash (Peter Krause), after a tragic on-the-job death. The Dick Wolf universe will be losing characters from three shows, Chicago Fire, Chicago P.D., and Law & Order: SVU — and there haven’t been hints about how any of them will be written out. Fire Country left three characters’ lives hanging in the balance after a massive fire consumed significant parts of Edgewater, and only one of the two characters whose actors won’t be back was involved in that cliffhanger. Below, we’ve ranked the characters who will be missed next season by the impact their absences will have on their shows.

TV Fans, Brace Yourselves: Major Exits Are Coming This Fall

Every fall brings a new wave of excitement for TV lovers—new seasons, cliffhangers resolved, fresh stories. But Fall 2025? It’s got heartbreak written all over it. With beloved characters exiting iconic shows like Law & Order: SVU, 9-1-1, and the One Chicago franchise, fans are asking: Which TV goodbye will cut the deepest? Let’s dive into the major exits coming this fall and rank the ones that might leave the biggest emotional crater behind.

Why 2025 Is the Year of TV Goodbyes

This year marks the end of an era for several long-running dramas. Whether it’s actors stepping down after decades or shows wrapping up, the Fall 2025 TV lineup is shaking up the small screen.

‘9-1-1’: A Fan-Favorite Leaves the Firehouse

Evan “Buck” Buckley Says Goodbye?

Rumors are swirling, and they’re getting louder: Oliver Stark may be stepping away from 9-1-1. After playing the fearless yet emotionally layered firefighter Buck for nine seasons, sources suggest Stark is eyeing a break—or maybe even a new chapter.

Fans have watched Buck grow from impulsive and wild to mature and reliable. Losing him now would be gut-wrenching. Plus, let’s be real: no one swings an axe with emotional baggage quite like Buck.

Why Buck’s Exit Would Devastate Fans

  • He’s the emotional heart of the 118.

  • His bond with Eddie Diaz is iconic (Buddie fans, we see you).

  • He’s been part of the show’s most jaw-dropping rescues.

‘Law & Order: SVU’: Could Benson Really Retire?

Mariska Hargitay and the End of an Era

If Captain Olivia Benson leaves SVU, it’s not just a character exit—it’s the end of television history. Mariska Hargitay has played Benson for over 26 seasons, becoming the longest-running female character in TV drama history.

Talk of retirement or a graceful send-off is growing louder, especially as Benson navigates motherhood and command responsibilities. While NBC remains tight-lipped, fans are preparing for the worst.

Why Benson’s Exit Would Break Us All

  • She’s the face of SVU—period.

  • Her survivor advocacy storyline has changed lives.

  • Viewers have grown up with her strength and compassion.

One Chicago: Who’s Leaving What?

The One Chicago universe is no stranger to exits, but this fall’s departures feel… different.

‘Chicago Fire’: Is It Time for Severide’s Final Call?

Taylor Kinney’s back-and-forth presence on Chicago Fire has sparked ongoing exit rumors. If Severide leaves for good in Fall 2025, the firehouse won’t be the same. His chemistry with Stella Kidd, his deep moral compass, and that brooding intensity? Irreplaceable.

‘Chicago P.D.’: Goodbye, Voight?

Jason Beghe’s portrayal of Hank Voight has kept Chicago P.D. gritty and grounded. If the rumors are true, and Voight bows out, the power dynamic of the Intelligence Unit could crumble.

‘Chicago Med’: New Faces, Old Favorites Gone

While cast turnover is common on Med, saying goodbye to longtime characters like Dr. Will Halstead (if he returns only to exit) or Sharon Goodwin would mark a big shift in tone.

The Wildcards: Other Major Departures That Could Rock Us

‘Grey’s Anatomy’: Is Meredith Truly Gone for Good?

Although Ellen Pompeo stepped back in 2023, hints of a possible farewell arc have fans speculating. A true goodbye to Meredith Grey in 2025 could be the emotional closure fans never wanted—but desperately need.

‘NCIS’: Will Ducky’s Legacy Live On?

With David McCallum’s passing, tribute episodes are expected. Any additional character exits—especially if they’re tied to long-running agents—could deepen the blow.

Ranking the Most Devastating Exits (Emotional Impact)

  1. Olivia Benson – Law & Order: SVU

    Legacy, longevity, leadership. Enough said.

  2. Buck – 9-1-1

    Emotional core + fan favorite = heartbreak.

  3. Severide – Chicago Fire

    The brooding hero we can’t quit.

  4. Voight – Chicago P.D.

    His moral complexity is the show’s backbone.

  5. Meredith Grey – Grey’s Anatomy

    We thought she was gone. But if it’s final, we’ll feel it.

Why These Departures Hit So Hard

TV isn’t just entertainment—it’s comfort. These characters have been with us through pandemics, breakups, bad days, and everything in between. So when they leave, it feels personal. Like losing a friend.

Their exits aren’t just plot points; they’re cultural moments.

What Fans Are Saying Online

Twitter, Reddit, and fan forums are buzzing with grief and speculation. “I grew up with Olivia Benson—what do I even do after she leaves?” one fan posted. Another wrote, “If Buck dies, I riot. Plain and simple.”

This kind of emotional investment is rare—and powerful.

Behind the Scenes: Why Are So Many Actors Leaving?

The TV landscape is shifting. Streaming wars, contract negotiations, burnout, and the allure of new projects all play a role. Some actors want new creative challenges. Others just want a break.

And some characters… well, their storylines have come full circle.

Silver Lining? New Characters, Fresh Stories

Yes, change is tough. But with every exit comes an opportunity for reinvention. New faces might just become your next favorite. (Maybe.)

But until then? We mourn.

Final Thoughts: The Exit That Will Hurt the Most

If we’re picking just one, it’s got to be Olivia Benson’s farewell.

She’s not just a character—she’s a symbol of strength, justice, and heart. No matter how SVU handles her exit, fans across generations will feel it deeply.

FAQs About Fall 2025 TV Exits

1. Is Olivia Benson really leaving SVU in 2025?

Nothing’s confirmed yet, but strong rumors—and narrative build-up—suggest this could be her last season.

2. Why might Oliver Stark leave 9-1-1?

Stark has hinted at needing a break and exploring other roles. Fox hasn’t confirmed anything yet.

3. Are any One Chicago shows being canceled?

No cancellations announced yet, but big cast shakeups are expected in all three series.

4. How can fans cope with these character exits?

Rewatch their best episodes, engage with fan communities, and embrace the new arcs—TV is always evolving.

5. Will these exits hurt ratings?

It’s possible in the short term, but fresh storylines and strong writing can keep momentum going.

Rate this post