Despite upcoming cast exits, Chicago Fire overlooked a heartwarming opportunity to revive the spirit of Firehouse 51—by failing to permanently replace its beloved Dalmatian.
With Chicago Fire entering its 14th season, the series is facing another round of cast upheaval. Fan favorites like Darren Ritter and Sam Carver are set to depart, stirring questions about how Firehouse 51 will adapt once again. But while much of the attention has been on the show’s human characters, one particular loss from seasons past still lingers in the background—and it’s one the series should’ve addressed long ago.
Chicago Fire has never been shy about shaking things up. However, not every character departure receives a fitting replacement. One especially meaningful absence continues to leave a paw-shaped hole at 51: Tuesday, the firehouse Dalmatian who stole the hearts of viewers and the crew alike.
Tuesday Was More Than A Mascot — She Was Family
Tuesday, Darren Ritter’s excitable Dalmatian, first arrived in Season 7 and quickly became an integral part of life at 51. Though initially a source of comic frustration—especially for Herrmann—Tuesday soon warmed up to the crew, and viewers, with her playful energy and chaotic charm.
She wasn’t the first canine companion on Chicago Fire—that title belongs to Pouch, who briefly brought joy to the firehouse back in Season 4—but Tuesday felt like the show’s most fully realized four-legged character. She had her own storylines, from a failed talent show debut to being wrongfully accused of mauling a girl (when she was only licking peanut butter off her face). But perhaps most importantly, Tuesday radiated warmth and levity in a workplace constantly surrounded by danger and tragedy.
Her real-life passing after Season 10 was felt deeply by fans, and yet, Chicago Fire never truly filled that void.
Season 13 Teased The Perfect Replacement—And Let It Slip Away
In a touching storyline during Season 13, a dog named Fridge briefly joined Firehouse 51 after his owner was hospitalized. Brought in by Sam Carver and supported by Stella Kidd, Fridge instantly bonded with the team—echoing Tuesday’s impact in earlier seasons. For Carver, who was secretly struggling after a breakup with Tori, Fridge offered rare emotional support and connection. It was a beautiful moment that showed just how much a dog could still mean to the team.
Unfortunately, Fridge was written out after his owner recovered. But what made it even more frustrating was this: Fridge appeared to be the same dog who briefly appeared next to Tuesday in a past episode—a subtle Easter egg that hinted at long-term plans. That symbolic passing of the torch never came to fruition.
Firehouse Dogs Are More Than Just Props On Chicago Fire
From Pouch to Tuesday, dogs have brought more than just charm to Firehouse 51. They’ve helped shape lighter moments, bonded the crew together, and reminded viewers of the show’s emotional heartbeat. Tuesday’s presence, in particular, allowed Chicago Fire to explore softer sides of characters like Stella and Ritter, proving that even in the high-stakes world of first responders, joy and companionship matter.
In a firehouse reeling from losses—both on and off-screen—a permanent firehouse dog could bring needed levity and continuity.
With Ritter Leaving, A Firehouse Dog Could Preserve His Spirit
Darren Ritter’s upcoming exit in Season 14 is another gut punch. Quiet, reliable, and full of heart, Ritter embodied the compassion and humanity that defined the best of Firehouse 51. Tuesday was an extension of that. Replacing her now would be more than nostalgia—it would be a tribute to Ritter’s legacy.
Moreover, with Carver also on his way out and Violet likely losing yet another love interest, morale will be lower than ever. Between personal tragedies and professional uncertainties, 51 could benefit from the healing energy only a loyal pup can bring.
Why Now Is The Time To Bring Back A Firehouse Dog
Network dramas like Chicago Fire thrive when they balance grit with heart. A dog isn’t just comic relief—it’s a symbol of home. Amid the flames, fractured relationships, and ever-changing cast, something as simple as a tail wag or a playful bark can anchor the show emotionally.
With several major characters leaving and fans fearing that the show’s ensemble magic is fading, it’s time to reintroduce a permanent furry companion to Firehouse 51. The emotional payoff could be huge—for both the characters and the audience.
Conclusion: Firehouse 51 Needs a New Hero—Even If They Walk on Four Legs
The heart of Chicago Fire has always been about more than sirens and rescues. It’s about found family. And for a brief time, that family included Tuesday, a lovable Dalmatian who made us laugh, cry, and believe in something good.
Now, with change on the horizon once again, the series has the perfect opportunity to bring that spirit back. Whether it’s Fridge or another pup waiting in the wings, Chicago Fire needs a dog again. Not just to fill a space—but to heal a wound.
