Let’s be honest—fans of police procedurals love a good crossover. Imagine Angela Lopez from The Rookie teaming up with Athena Grant from 9-1-1. The drama, the action, the chaos. Viewers have been buzzing about the idea for years. But despite both shows existing in the same creative universe and airing on the same network (ABC, following 9-1-1‘s move from FOX), the crossover just hasn’t materialized. Why?
Well, The Rookie’s showrunner has finally spoken up—and his response sheds light on more than just logistics.
What Sparked the Crossover Hype in the First Place?
A Shared Audience and Genre
Both 9-1-1 and The Rookie are adrenaline-packed series that focus on first responders. It makes perfect sense why fans think a crossover would be gold. With similar tones, overlapping fan bases, and high-octane emergencies, the synergy is undeniable.
Network Merge Made the Rumors Louder
After 9-1-1 made the jump from FOX to ABC in 2023, crossover buzz intensified. For fans, this move seemed like the final puzzle piece. Finally, both shows under one roof—how could they not collaborate?
The Showrunner Finally Breaks the Silence
Who Said What?
Alexi Hawley, The Rookie’s showrunner, has finally addressed the elephant in the room. When asked directly about the possibility of a crossover with 9-1-1, his answer was frank: “It would be hard.”
Why So Difficult? Let’s Break It Down
This wasn’t a coy evasion. Hawley dove into the complexities that make a crossover challenging—even in today’s interconnected TV world.
Scheduling Nightmares
Different Production Timelines
One of the biggest barriers? Production schedules. While both shows air on ABC, they don’t necessarily run on synchronized shooting calendars.
Imagine trying to book Nathan Fillion (The Rookie) and Angela Bassett (9-1-1) on the same day. Not easy.
Cast Commitments & Contracts
Each show has a large ensemble cast. Coordinating their availability—especially for a script that intertwines two big storylines—isn’t just a challenge, it’s a potential nightmare.
Geographical Barriers Within Storylines
Los Angeles vs. Los Angeles, But Not Really
Yes, both shows are technically set in L.A., but they depict very different versions of the city. The Rookie is more grounded in LAPD politics and personal character arcs, while 9-1-1 leans into disaster spectacle with a more sensational tone.
Mismatched Story Arcs and Styles
While The Rookie embraces slow-burning character development, 9-1-1 thrives on fast-paced, crisis-of-the-week storytelling. Blending those two? Think oil and water.
Narrative Compatibility: A Risky Move
Tone Clashes Could Alienate Audiences
A crossover isn’t just about plot logistics—it’s about mood. Fans who tune into 9-1-1 expect edge-of-your-seat chaos. The Rookie fans? They’re more invested in long-term character growth.
Mixing the two could end up pleasing no one.
Creative Control Is a Tug-of-War
Multiple Writers’ Rooms = Multiple Visions
To execute a crossover, you need unity in direction. But these shows have separate writing teams, each with their own priorities and storytelling philosophies.
Who Gets the Final Say?
Even if the logistics work, someone has to lead. Would it be a Rookie episode guest-starring 9-1-1 characters, or vice versa? That creative tug-of-war could muddy the waters fast.
What Could a Crossover Even Look Like?
Dream Scenarios Fans Are Pitching
-
A major L.A. disaster requiring all hands on deck.
-
A fugitive running from LAPD crosses into 9-1-1 territory.
-
A mutual character with ties to both departments.
The possibilities? Exciting. The reality? Complicated.
Other Shows Have Done It—So Why Not These Two?
The Chicago Universe Success Story
NBC’s Chicago Fire, Chicago P.D., and Chicago Med nail crossovers regularly. But those were designed to work together from day one.
The Rookie and 9-1-1 were created independently, by different teams, on different networks, with different tones. It’s not apples to apples.
Could the Writers Find a Compromise?
Mini Crossovers or Character Cameos
Some fans suggest starting small: a cameo from a 9-1-1 paramedic in a Rookie scene, or a dispatch call that mentions LAPD. Easter eggs like that could satisfy fans without complicating the main storylines.
Is a Crossover Even Worth the Effort?
Short-Term Buzz vs. Long-Term Disruption
Sure, a crossover could generate a ratings spike. But is it worth the disruption to both shows’ rhythms? That’s a question execs are clearly weighing.
Final Thoughts From The Showrunner
Hawley’s bottom line? While it’s fun to imagine, a crossover would be a massive undertaking—not impossible, but certainly not easy. And unless all the stars align (literally and figuratively), it’s just not a current priority.
Fan Reactions: Mixed, But Mostly Hopeful
Fans are divided. Some are crushed by the realism; others are just happy the idea is still on the table.
The conversation isn’t over. But for now? The dream remains just that—a dream.
Conclusion: Crossovers Aren’t Off the Table, Just Off the Calendar (For Now)
We get it—crossovers are thrilling. They bring worlds together and unite fandoms. But as The Rookie’s showrunner explained, they’re also incredibly complex. From scheduling nightmares to narrative clashes, there’s a lot more under the hood than meets the eye.
That said, the door’s not fully closed. As the TV landscape evolves, and as fans continue to voice their love for both shows, who knows? Someday, maybe Athena Grant will team up with John Nolan after all.
Until then, we’ll just have to keep dreaming—and tweeting.
FAQs
1. Are The Rookie and 9-1-1 in the same universe?
No official universe link has been confirmed, though both are on ABC and set in Los Angeles.
2. Has there ever been a crossover between 9-1-1 and another show?
Not yet, though 9-1-1: Lone Star has crossed over with 9-1-1 itself.
3. Could a crossover still happen in the future?
Absolutely. While it’s complicated now, future seasons may find a creative and logistical way to make it work.
4. Why do fans want a crossover so badly?
Fans love seeing characters from different shows interact, especially when the genres and tones match well.
5. What’s stopping the crossover from happening right now?
Mainly production logistics, tone differences, and complex scheduling conflicts between two large casts and crews.
